Suicide?

Author
Discussion

jollygreen

Original Poster:

16,154 posts

202 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
I just learned that an old friend of mine topped himself last week.

Guy was 29, I went to school with him. He was married with a 3-year old and a 3-month old. He was due to be best-man for another old school friend of mine in weeks time and it was the groom who found him. He'd left notes for his wife and the guy who's getting married. He'd also ordered a big grocery shop from the asda website which was delivered the day after he killed himself.

Nobody apparently had any clue he was going to do it but he obviously had planned it all in some detail and well in advance. Unbelievable. What could drive somebody to that? No apparent personal difficulties according his close family - they're all stumped.

eek

Cara Van Man

29,977 posts

251 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
jollygreen said:
I just learned that an old friend of mine topped himself last week.

Guy was 29, I went to school with him. He was married with a 3-year old and a 3-month old. He was due to be best-man for another old school friend of mine in weeks time and it was the groom who found him. He'd left notes for his wife and the guy who's getting married. He'd also ordered a big grocery shop from the asda website which was delivered the day after he killed himself.

Nobody apparently had any clue he was going to do it but he obviously had planned it all in some detail and well in advance. Unbelievable. What could drive somebody to that? No apparent personal difficulties according his close family - they're all stumped.

eek
I had 2 friends do this within weeks of each other (totally independant of each other), and it came as a hell of a shock as both appeared to be happy go lucky types with kids.

So sad.

Timmy35

12,915 posts

198 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
People, esp blokes bottle things up. We laugh things off, and banter, but never frankly talk about our problems.

That after all is often met with the refrain "Grow a pair" on PH. After all if you're a man there is no problem that you shouldn't be able to sort out yourself and emotions are a bit GAYE.

So we have a huge suicide rate compared to women.

Commonest cause of death in men under 35............ Suicide.

NDA

21,574 posts

225 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all

Very sad. I haven't known anyone personally who has committed suicide, but imagine the signs are hard to spot and the reasons illogical to others. A tragedy that will leave everyone thinking 'could I have prevented this?'.

It will, of course, have a terrible impact on the wedding day too....


Cara Van Man

29,977 posts

251 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
Timmy35 said:
People, esp blokes bottle things up. We laugh things off, and banter, but never frankly talk about our problems.

That after all is often met with the refrain "Grow a pair" on PH. After all if you're a man there is no problem that you shouldn't be able to sort out yourself and emotions are a bit GAYE.

So we have a huge suicide rate compared to women.

Commonest cause of death in men under 35............ Suicide.
Very true.

I've carried a lot of baggage through my life which hs caused a lot of pain and stress, thinking "i can cope". And I couldn't.

My 'special friend' says that each of us has a limited amount of resources to cope with life and when that is all used up, problems occur....anger, stress, depression etc. I used my resources up many years ago, but only recently sort help as I always considered doing this to be a bit soft or a failure.

Although not one to consider suicide I'm glad I did as it is helping me to see life in a different way and react to things better rather than being unable to cope with things that really don't matter.

AlecG

1,349 posts

214 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
Cara Van Man said:
Timmy35 said:
People, esp blokes bottle things up. We laugh things off, and banter, but never frankly talk about our problems.

That after all is often met with the refrain "Grow a pair" on PH. After all if you're a man there is no problem that you shouldn't be able to sort out yourself and emotions are a bit GAYE.

So we have a huge suicide rate compared to women.

Commonest cause of death in men under 35............ Suicide.
Very true.

I've carried a lot of baggage through my life which hs caused a lot of pain and stress, thinking "i can cope". And I couldn't.

My 'special friend' says that each of us has a limited amount of resources to cope with life and when that is all used up, problems occur....anger, stress, depression etc. I used my resources up many years ago, but only recently sort help as I always considered doing this to be a bit soft or a failure.

Although not one to consider suicide I'm glad I did as it is helping me to see life in a different way and react to things better rather than being unable to cope with things that really don't matter.
Sorry, a bit o/t...

I did the same thing after a awful time with my ex and general nasty time of my life, where I lost all confidence who I was pretty much. It is amazing what an hour a week has sorted out in my head over the last few months, and just how important (for me at least) it is to let it out, deal with problems and feelings etc.

It's also interesting to understand how deep rooted some of my issues are, and why I react like I do, and how I work.

I'm sorry to hear about your school friend too.

off_again

12,298 posts

234 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
Timmy35 said:
Commonest cause of death in men under 35............ Suicide.
Yow... didn't know that. Mind you, if you read the papers you would think it was murder, but that's another story.

Thankfully I am a few years older than that. Do you know what the figures are and how they compare to women?

anonymous-user

54 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
I think there are lots of blokes who carry on putting on a brave face and laughing things off, when they'd do better telling their mates or a professional that they're finding it hard to cope. There is no shame in it at all.

I knew a bloke who drove over beachy head a few years ago. I'd been at his a few days earlier having a BBQ and a few beers. He seemed on fine form. Perhaps he was less stressed as he thought he had found a way out, who knows.

If you're having problems, bottling them up never helps in the long run.

Davi

17,153 posts

220 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
Cara Van Man said:
Timmy35 said:
People, esp blokes bottle things up. We laugh things off, and banter, but never frankly talk about our problems.

That after all is often met with the refrain "Grow a pair" on PH. After all if you're a man there is no problem that you shouldn't be able to sort out yourself and emotions are a bit GAYE.

So we have a huge suicide rate compared to women.

Commonest cause of death in men under 35............ Suicide.
Very true.

I've carried a lot of baggage through my life which hs caused a lot of pain and stress, thinking "i can cope". And I couldn't.

My 'special friend' says that each of us has a limited amount of resources to cope with life and when that is all used up, problems occur....anger, stress, depression etc. I used my resources up many years ago, but only recently sort help as I always considered doing this to be a bit soft or a failure.

Although not one to consider suicide I'm glad I did as it is helping me to see life in a different way and react to things better rather than being unable to cope with things that really don't matter.
And there's the other thing... knowing Cara Van Mans (admittedly online only) persona - would you ever have thought he was the sort of person that might need to seek a bit of help? Certainly surprised me seeing that comment from him.

I know for some time now I've felt so backed into a corner I can't see any way out, period. Fortunately I'm too much of a wimp to consider ending it all but I'm certainly very much past the resources available to me!

Timmy35

12,915 posts

198 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
off_again said:
Timmy35 said:
Commonest cause of death in men under 35............ Suicide.
Yow... didn't know that. Mind you, if you read the papers you would think it was murder, but that's another story.

Thankfully I am a few years older than that. Do you know what the figures are and how they compare to women?
http://www.library.nhs.uk/mentalhealth/ViewResource.aspx?resID=111317&tabID=290

Did you know less than 20% of men under 35 who commit suicide had any contact with a GP or mental health professional before they killed themselves? The death toll is around 5000 a year in England....mainly young men.

Funny isn't it.....given all the campaigning, speedtraps, courses to stop us speeding. No one seems either aware or overly concerned about epidemic suicide amongst young men.



Edited by Timmy35 on Thursday 24th July 11:42

Mr POD

5,153 posts

192 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
Timmy35 said:
People, esp blokes bottle things up. We laugh things off, and banter, but never frankly talk about our problems.

That after all is often met with the refrain "Grow a pair" on PH. After all if you're a man there is no problem that you shouldn't be able to sort out yourself and emotions are a bit GAYE.

So we have a huge suicide rate compared to women.

Commonest cause of death in men under 35............ Suicide.
I've thought about it. The only thing that stopped me is knowing my reaction to hearing of someone else's suicide.

Last night I got home to find my wife in her usual "You are so fking useless" mode of operation, and I lost it completely, really fking lost it. She took the kids out and I sat in a corner sobbing. In fact the pain was so great that for a short while, I thought death would be a welcome relief. The only thing that stopped me in knowing no-one would say "She pushed him to it" but rather, "If it was that bad he could just have left"

King Herald

23,501 posts

216 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
Cara Van Man said:
Although not one to consider suicide I'm glad I did as it is helping me to see life in a different way and react to things better rather than being unable to cope with things that really don't matter.
I thought about suicide in my early twenties when I went through a little hell with some bh, lots of lies, a couple of kids that were supposed to be mine etc, and I found the option of suicide was quiet calming, as you knew there was an 'out' if things ever got really bad. I never actually seriously contemplated, 'planned' on doing it, but at the time life was pretty crappy, crap job, crap relationship, and I felt like there was not a lot to miss if I did top myself. It wasn't any great 'oh my god, I wish i was dead' scenario, just a nice option to end all the grief and misery.

Of course a lot of drugs and drink fueled that rationale at the time. frown

minerva

756 posts

204 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
I think that the last figures I read were that 20 times as many women attempt suicide (ie make a pretence of doing it so that people will notice and give them the attention and help they need) than men and 6 times as many men actually successfully commit suicide.

If no one knows how you are feeling, they cannot help.

Cara Van Man

29,977 posts

251 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
Davi said:
Cara Van Man said:
Timmy35 said:
People, esp blokes bottle things up. We laugh things off, and banter, but never frankly talk about our problems.

That after all is often met with the refrain "Grow a pair" on PH. After all if you're a man there is no problem that you shouldn't be able to sort out yourself and emotions are a bit GAYE.

So we have a huge suicide rate compared to women.

Commonest cause of death in men under 35............ Suicide.
Very true.

I've carried a lot of baggage through my life which hs caused a lot of pain and stress, thinking "i can cope". And I couldn't.

My 'special friend' says that each of us has a limited amount of resources to cope with life and when that is all used up, problems occur....anger, stress, depression etc. I used my resources up many years ago, but only recently sort help as I always considered doing this to be a bit soft or a failure.

Although not one to consider suicide I'm glad I did as it is helping me to see life in a different way and react to things better rather than being unable to cope with things that really don't matter.
And there's the other thing... knowing Cara Van Mans (admittedly online only) persona - would you ever have thought he was the sort of person that might need to seek a bit of help? Certainly surprised me seeing that comment from him.

I know for some time now I've felt so backed into a corner I can't see any way out, period. Fortunately I'm too much of a wimp to consider ending it all but I'm certainly very much past the resources available to me!
Well, the thing is i know lots of the people on here face to face but I'm not ashamed of the stigma. It doesn't mean I'm some kind of mentalist cos I have had a lot to cope with through life. My rather unhappy childhood is the cause of most of it. Other things since have added to my problems. It was beginning to affect my marriage, and I didn't want it to. So I felt I needed help and luckily am getting it. It's helping things make sense and helping me to let go of things that have happened in the past.

just dont fk with me though.

anonymous-user

54 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
Friend of mine did this in his early 20s. Really popular, lovely lady etc etc... then took a shotgun to himself!!! Tragic!!!

Timmy35

12,915 posts

198 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
Mr POD said:
Last night I got home to find my wife in her usual "You are so fking useless" mode of operation, and I lost it completely, really fking lost it. She took the kids out and I sat in a corner sobbing. In fact the pain was so great that for a short while, I thought death would be a welcome relief. The only thing that stopped me in knowing no-one would say "She pushed him to it" but rather, "If it was that bad he could just have left"
Book yourself into see a Relate councillor. They've got branches all over.

You can have some seperate sessions, then some with your wife.

Seriously.

http://www.relate.org.uk/

It will be £40 well spent mate.

Edited by Timmy35 on Thursday 24th July 11:44

Mr Will

13,719 posts

206 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
off_again said:
Timmy35 said:
Commonest cause of death in men under 35............ Suicide.
Yow... didn't know that. Mind you, if you read the papers you would think it was murder, but that's another story.

Thankfully I am a few years older than that. Do you know what the figures are and how they compare to women?
IIRC Attempted sucide is much more common for women than actual suicide. It is often a cry for help, rather than actually seeking to end their life.

Unfortunately the opposite is normally true for men. They tend to decide what they are going to do and make sure it works, hence little or no warning for the people around them.

I am no expert though and would be very interested to see some figures if anyone has them.

ETA: Too slow as usual!


Edited by Mr Will on Thursday 24th July 11:52

Cara Van Man

29,977 posts

251 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
Mr POD said:
Timmy35 said:
People, esp blokes bottle things up. We laugh things off, and banter, but never frankly talk about our problems.

That after all is often met with the refrain "Grow a pair" on PH. After all if you're a man there is no problem that you shouldn't be able to sort out yourself and emotions are a bit GAYE.

So we have a huge suicide rate compared to women.

Commonest cause of death in men under 35............ Suicide.
I've thought about it. The only thing that stopped me is knowing my reaction to hearing of someone else's suicide.

Last night I got home to find my wife in her usual "You are so fking useless" mode of operation, and I lost it completely, really fking lost it. She took the kids out and I sat in a corner sobbing. In fact the pain was so great that for a short while, I thought death would be a welcome relief. The only thing that stopped me in knowing no-one would say "She pushed him to it" but rather, "If it was that bad he could just have left"
Get help mate. It WILL help. It may even improve your marriage.

DO some anger management exercise (can be found online and in books).

Just cos you are seeking help doesn't automatically put you in the wrong or make things your fault......


ETA: part of anger issues are negative thinking and feeling like people are against you, in your post i picked up on these straight away.........

Edited by Cara Van Man on Thursday 24th July 11:50

Timmy35

12,915 posts

198 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
minerva said:
20 times as many women attempt suicide than men, and 6 times as many men actually successfully commit suicide.
  • / black humour mode on */
It does at least show if you want something done properly......

Edited by Timmy35 on Thursday 24th July 11:48

Tony*T3

20,911 posts

247 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
I've (briefly) considered it many many times. Daily on occasions. Even choosen the preferred methodology (large tree at speed in a car) Even chosen the flaming tree... :-) . Fortunatly always manage to snap out of it. Wouldnt take too much though to actually push you over the edge. Family/friends would be totally mystyfied if it ever happened.

"Futility of existance" seems to be the number one cause of my own issues.

Never spoken to a 'professional' of this isuse. It would only end up as a lable on a computer report that would ultimatly only push up ones life insurance premiums anyway.