120D GEAR BOX

120D GEAR BOX

Author
Discussion

bmw120d

Original Poster:

69 posts

184 months

Saturday 14th February 2009
quotequote all
The gearbox on my 120d has given up with only 3 weeks lease to go sound like a machine gun.
Bmw say this is the first one they had to replace!!!
I have had enough,16years bmw i have had it with this brand time to change so have gone for a scirocco gt

Neil.D

2,878 posts

207 months

Saturday 14th February 2009
quotequote all
Yup, 1 series are shiet.

Fox-

13,241 posts

247 months

Saturday 14th February 2009
quotequote all
Good luck with your downgrade.

E21_Ross

35,097 posts

213 months

Sunday 15th February 2009
quotequote all
Fox- said:
Good luck with your downgrade.
hehe it's so true.

bmw120d

Original Poster:

69 posts

184 months

Sunday 15th February 2009
quotequote all
Sorry boys and girls it’s the credit crunch

What I wont bmw 123d m sport £400+ per month
The gt scirocco £160.less

Fox-

13,241 posts

247 months

Monday 16th February 2009
quotequote all
bmw120d said:
Sorry boys and girls it’s the credit crunch

What I wont bmw 123d m sport £400+ per month
The gt scirocco £160.less
Also I found the other day that Travelodge is cheaper per night than Hilton. Also I was suprised to find a Casio watch was less than an Omega.

Edited by Fox- on Monday 16th February 14:01

Methane Bloke

264 posts

203 months

Monday 16th February 2009
quotequote all
Neil.D said:
Yup, 1 series are shiet.
But so much better than the E21s, E30s, E36s and E46s that we've also had.

E21_Ross

35,097 posts

213 months

Monday 16th February 2009
quotequote all
Methane Bloke said:
Neil.D said:
Yup, 1 series are shiet.
But so much better than the E21s, E30s, E36s and E46s that we've also had.
how so? willing to bet for pure driver involvement and fun the E21's and E30's are better than them. but not for other things. depends what you want from a car really doesn't it.

Edited by E21_Ross on Monday 16th February 21:16

Methane Bloke

264 posts

203 months

Tuesday 17th February 2009
quotequote all
E21s and E30s both sufferfed form low geared vague steering, unpredictable oversteer with the more powerfull engines, average brakes, crap seats and poor levels of equipment. I know what I'd rather be driving.

Neil.D

2,878 posts

207 months

Tuesday 17th February 2009
quotequote all
Thats pretty obvious, those cars are over 20 years old.


E21_Ross

35,097 posts

213 months

Tuesday 17th February 2009
quotequote all
but not many new cars have character. vague steering? maybe you drove a ste example....i recently drove a £50k mercedes and thought it lacked feel compared to mine. non power steering gives you exact feel of what's going on. not driven an e30. but i think i would take an E30 M3 sport evo over a new 1 series any day of the week.

all of your comments on the negative sides can easily be solved with some decent upgrades, all for less than the price of a 1 series. i'm not slating the 1 series, i do like them. but are totally different cars to the earlier bmws.

seats easy enough to get hold of, suspension kits more than plentiful (i just fitted a new one to mine), other things like rear anti roll bars etc very easy to get done. if it's power and better economy you are after....fit another engine and a longer diff. they are cracking little cars, and i've driven a fair few newer cars, and soon i'm to drive the new M3 (can't wait!!!!!). but i just love the character of the older cars.

each to their own of course, but you can't slate it for problems it has which make it worse than a 1 series, when for the price you can easily rectify them.

Edited by E21_Ross on Tuesday 17th February 17:35

Methane Bloke

264 posts

203 months

Wednesday 18th February 2009
quotequote all
Neil.D said:
Thats pretty obvious, those cars are over 20 years old.
Funnily enough it was 20 years ago we owned them.

Methane Bloke

264 posts

203 months

Wednesday 18th February 2009
quotequote all
E21_Ross said:
but not many new cars have character. vague steering? maybe you drove a ste example....i recently drove a £50k mercedes and thought it lacked feel compared to mine. non power steering gives you exact feel of what's going on. not driven an e30. but i think i would take an E30 M3 sport evo over a new 1 series any day of the week.

all of your comments on the negative sides can easily be solved with some decent upgrades, all for less than the price of a 1 series. i'm not slating the 1 series, i do like them. but are totally different cars to the earlier bmws.

seats easy enough to get hold of, suspension kits more than plentiful (i just fitted a new one to mine), other things like rear anti roll bars etc very easy to get done. if it's power and better economy you are after....fit another engine and a longer diff. they are cracking little cars, and i've driven a fair few newer cars, and soon i'm to drive the new M3 (can't wait!!!!!). but i just love the character of the older cars.

each to their own of course, but you can't slate it for problems it has which make it worse than a 1 series, when for the price you can easily rectify them.

Edited by E21_Ross on Tuesday 17th February 17:35
I'm not knocking the old threes for the sake of it, they were OK twenty years ago. Neither of the two E21s we had (316 and 323i) had power steering, they were heavy when stationery, especially the 323i and very light and imprecise at speed. The E30s were a bit better. Never had an M3 E30, wouldn't have wanted the LHD and the dog leg box. Had a genuine Motorsport 325i which was a very good car, bit thirsty and loads of oversteer, but the steering was still too lowly geared. Luckily it hads loads of extras and the dealers were biting our hands for it when it came to trade in time. I really wouldn't want to swap the one series for any of them, it's just a very practical car, boring maybe, but it suits an old fecker like me.