Another what (wildlife) Lens thread.

[WWA]

Hi all,

I have recently got a Nikon D7200 which I feel is slightly better than my MK1 Nikon 80-400. So I'm looking to upgrade and have narrowed down to three options-

MK2 80-400
Tamron 150-600 (or sigma variant)
New Nikon 200-500

Another outside option is getting a 300 prime and adding a TC to it but I prefer the versatility of the zoom lenses.

The 80-400 is 500g lighter than the other two which is good for me because I'm normally on foot and walking quite far, but it's lacking at the long end.

The Nikon 200-500 is going to be a good lens I think, but it is fairly big and quite heavy to be carrying around all day.

The Tamron has fantastic zoom range but is heavy and maybe IQ is going to be not as good as my other two options.

I will be carrying the lens and camera with me for quite some distance sometimes and won't have a tripod or monopod so handheld shooting is the norm. So VR is helpfully. Planning on photographing all sorts of wildlife in all sorts of conditions. From shoreline seagulls to Munro red deer! (Hopefully!)


I was just wondering if anyone can offer their opinions on my options or add any personal experience of these lenses? Or suggest something else? Many thanks for any replys.

[WWA]

Gad-Westy said:

I haven't handled all of these but both Bigmas and the Tamron are big lenses to hand hold especially for long periods. I don't think I'd fancy it though they do seem great options, IQ wise and offer good value.

No idea about the 200-500, has it even been reviewed yet? Maybe worth waiting before deciding.

The 80-400 looks great but I guess seems a little tame in reach terms next to the other options. Does seem to suit your needs better than the others though.

I know you're not keen on primes but the new 300mm f/4 is a very light, compact lens. That teamed up with a 1.4x could be quite a good option. Without the TC, I'd be surprised if any of the others get close in terms of IQ.

One last curve ball. Have you thought about a used Sigma 120-300 2.8 and either a 1.4x or 2x TC? Never used one but a fascinating option.

Hi

Thanks for your reply. I will certainly look into a the 120-300 and the 300 prime. I suppose it comes down to weight, although I think I'll be investing in a Black Rapid strap no matter which lens I get. Thanks for your reply, and certainly food for though.