Citroen C1/ Pug 107 - Higher mileage or CatD

[IBDAET]

I'm looking to buy a C1 or a 107 from my mother-in-law to replace an organically decomposing ford KA.

We've decided the 2012 models of both (107 Allure or C1 VTR) with the DRL lights are a good idea to make sure she is seen , given she lives in a coastal place famed for the fact the majority of road users and pedestrians are pensioners. I'd rather they saw her.


These cars seem to get written off as Cat D very easily, with relatively modest damage - bumpers and bumper bars, bonnnets and wings. No structural panels they all say. A 2012 model with 8k miles can be had for under £4k while cars without such a blemished past are 20% more and have 4x the mileage.

So my dilemma is which should I buy?

I doubt it will be needed to be resold in the next 6 years, so the stigma of a Cat D is not a problem.

Anyone had any bad experinces with Cat D C1's or 107s??

[IBDAET]

I ended up getting a 5dr 2012 model 34k mile 107 Allure (with the DRLs) in immaculate condition for £4100 which is a pretty good deal. Came from a VW Franchise and has a years unlimited warranty.

Thanks for your help.