Clio 172 Homemade strut brace transforms the handling :)

Clio 172 Homemade strut brace transforms the handling :)

Author
Discussion

hewlett

Original Poster:

2,186 posts

221 months

Monday 29th June 2009
quotequote all


It took a while to fabricate but oh boy is it worth it.

The car corners much flatter, feels more solid at the front end, and all those local corners I know so well can be taken 10mph more quickly and with much more confidence. Clearly the 172 front end is a thing of fragility as the stiffening has transformed it. Yes that's wood btw, a long way from any real heat and I'm sure the plastic would melt before the wood caught on fire smile

hewlett

Original Poster:

2,186 posts

221 months

Monday 29th June 2009
quotequote all
It's very solid and works a treat, not a mm of play and really does do the job smile

hewlett

Original Poster:

2,186 posts

221 months

Tuesday 30th June 2009
quotequote all
Cost: about £15
Effectiveness: 100%
Safety: well it seems very solid and hardwood catches fire at a higher temperature than the surrounding plastic so it should be OK

In summary, success..

hewlett

Original Poster:

2,186 posts

221 months

Thursday 2nd July 2009
quotequote all
Following the success of the first wooden performance enhancing device I'm planning to add a rear strut brace to 'the range' when I get a chance. For the many people who have contacted me to find out if they can have the plans, can I create a wooden strut brace/roll cage/etc, please bare with me. www.woodforperformance.com is being created and will be officially launched v soon. We're also planning a 'prestige performance' line which will include varnished and laquered product lines with 'walnut effect' amongst the many options.

hewlett

Original Poster:

2,186 posts

221 months

Thursday 2nd July 2009
quotequote all
You read my mind, there will be a button on the website called:

'Woodenise', basically just click on it and you'll see a form, describe your fabrication requirements and our Master Craftspersons will create whatever wooden object you require.


Wood, the possibilities are limited.

hewlett

Original Poster:

2,186 posts

221 months

Thursday 2nd July 2009
quotequote all
I suppose it's like coming to work wearing sandals and everyone laughing, and you saying, ''yeah but my feet were hot'' and everyone saying ''yeah but sandals, come ooonnnnn''..

This was cheap, secure, it works well, and hmmm, is wood and looks a bit strange. I can live with that, the difference in handling is night n day.


hewlett

Original Poster:

2,186 posts

221 months

Thursday 2nd July 2009
quotequote all
..or the first time someone roasted a mammoth leg into the fire, took it out and ate it. Someone I'm sure said that 'fires are for heat dude, what are you doing chucking decent food there, WTF'

hewlett

Original Poster:

2,186 posts

221 months

Thursday 2nd July 2009
quotequote all
There's a minimal fire risk IMO, bolts post bonnet closure, yes its not one for the concourse I have to concede.

hewlett

Original Poster:

2,186 posts

221 months

Thursday 2nd July 2009
quotequote all
Pre, rather.. The bonnet remains dentless.

hewlett

Original Poster:

2,186 posts

221 months

Thursday 2nd July 2009
quotequote all
Oh for intelligent analysis, so far the only fact is ... It doesn't look nice

hewlett

Original Poster:

2,186 posts

221 months

Friday 3rd July 2009
quotequote all
Firstly, thanks John D.

Well I kinda knew this would be controversial thread, thinking in advance that the rather 'bespoke' nature of the device would cause mirth at the very least. It has to be said though that it is as light as an alloy brace, robust and works. Ref insurance, yes it's covered and thankfully they didn't ask who mananufactured it, the website isn't up and running yet smile

I was considering that rather than have a 'woodenise' button, 'give me wood' would be better but my wife often reads the threads and she would not be amused. If you have one of these cars you probably don't want to go down the homemade route (details on request, I'm sure you could make it look neater) but, this makes a major difference to the handling. I put a (bought) one on the Impreza last year and it made no discernable difference whatsoever - already stiff shell I guess. Whereas on this car there's less 'jiggle' over bumps, flatter cornering and the car just feels more planted and safer on the road. As a result of this thread someone may get a strut brace and they will be very pleased with the results, the benefits of shorter/stiffer springs without the back ache. That said I still want to go for cup springs or similar.

I have been amused at many of the comments but as none have pointed out a glaring problem/issue/concern, for now at least it's staying and I'm enjoying driving the car a lot more than I did when I didn't realise that it could handle a fair bit better.


hewlett

Original Poster:

2,186 posts

221 months

Friday 3rd July 2009
quotequote all
Thanks Funk, no pun intended?

hewlett

Original Poster:

2,186 posts

221 months

Friday 3rd July 2009
quotequote all
Ah ha yes I did miss the icon, I was genuinely surprised at how well it worked and once the bolts were tightened how firm it all became and how little the wood seems to flex, it's hardwood so fairly inflexible and the fact that it works so well seems to imply that the wood isn't bending when loaded up in a corner.

hewlett

Original Poster:

2,186 posts

221 months

Tuesday 23rd February 2010
quotequote all
Good news, an aluminium strut brace is on it's way from Germany following this successful 'trial'. Pics to follow.

hewlett

Original Poster:

2,186 posts

221 months

Tuesday 23rd February 2010
quotequote all
Been pining for one for ages, tempted to leaf it as is...