Which is better a 06:supercharged jcw or a 08 turbo jcw

[cejsmith]

Which do people think is more fun and also more reliable?

[cejsmith]

I'm only going to use it as a fun play thing for me and my daughter , if it will do 2k a year that will be it.

[cejsmith]

I had a cooper s convertible some time ago , it was a great little car, but I had aggro with the roof and got rid of it. That was about 10 years ago.