RE: SOTW: BMW 318is

Friday 3rd June 2011

SOTW: BMW 318is

Garlick's chosen a BMW (and not a Merc). How very odd...



Once again Riggers is out of the office 'working', and so Shed returns to my desk once more and the weekly hunt for a £1000 PH-worthy car is down to me.

As regular devotees of SOTW will probably know, I have three criteria when searching for a Shed of the Week - it must be limo-sized, it must be an auto and it has to be a Merc. But something changed this week, because I've cheated on Mercedes for a dabble with its deadliest rival. I feel dirty.

Back in 1996 we had a fairly new BMW 318is on the used forecourt at the dealer where I worked. It was black with grey cloth and, to be honest, we hadn't had much interest in it, but I rather liked it. At that time I'd never driven an 'is' before and seized the opportunity to take this one out once my boss had gone home for the evening. It wasn't taxed, so trade plates were attached and I was off (after jump-starting it if I recall correctly).

I remember how much I liked the way the car involved the driver, how the dash wrapped around you and how good the four-pot sounded. I was selling Mercs at the time and we didn't offer anything as focussed; we certainly didn't offer anything with a manual box as smooth either and (rather reluctantly) I was seeing the appeal of the blue-and-white roundel.


It was shortly after this thought that my inexperience let me down and the back end stepped out as a result of ham-fisted gear changes and a boot of throttle. As it stepped out I lifted off (foolishly) and performed a graceful pirouette, before coming to a stop facing the wrong way. Fortunately the road was quiet, but I had come to rest only a few feet from a lamppost. I blame being only 23 at the time and having only just started at the dealer a year ago (after owning nothing feistier than a 1.1 Fiesta). I was hardly the expert. I liked the BMW, though...and I'm sure the new owner did too.

Today these cars are worth a grand - and that's not bad is it? For your money you'll be getting the rather beautiful E36 coupe body, containing a 140bhp, 1800cc engine (though this car could just possibly be a later car featuring the 1900cc M44 engine that also saw service in the Z3) that gives over 130mph and a 0-60mph time of 10.2secs.

For a fairly small four-banger you get a reasonable 132lb ft of torque, too, and when it's wrapped up in a chassis as tight as only BMW know how, you'll find that's more than enough to get into trouble (just don't drive one like I did).


When new, the earlier cars were offered with the M Power styling kit as an option (it became standard in the run-out models) and, although I prefer the purer look of the unadorned coupe, this week's Shed comes with all the M stuff glued to it. It's in-keeping though, and doesn't look out of place, especially when teamed up with the BBS split rims and silver paintwork

Looking at the advert this car seems in very good health, is versions of the E36 regularly fall into shed budget but they don't always look like this, especially not with tax and test thrown in. Tempted? I think you should be, I know I am. This needs to be bought.

Advert is reproduced below:

1996 BMW 318is, 124,000 miles, £1000

BMW 318is for sale, this cars is in great condition, runs perfect without any problems. It is surprisinly good on fuel aswell. It has 17 inch bbs split-rims which are in ok condition but could do with a re-furb at some point to be perfect. The car has a factory fitted m-tec boby kit all round. Also has red carpets and red seats and red door card trim. It has electric windows and sun roof. It has tax for five months and mot till august. The tyres are all in legal condition with one tyre new. This car is great and i will be sorry to see it go, but due to me finishing uni for the summer very shortly i need the money to see me through.£1000.

Author
Discussion

johnpeat

Original Poster:

5,328 posts

266 months

Friday 3rd June 2011
quotequote all
Back in 2000 I worked with a guy who was hunting for a company car to replace his (privately owned and much cherished) Civic 1.6 VTi...

He'd all-but signed for a Prelude (5th gen) when he was invited to a BMW company car driver test-drive event. When he arrived the only car left was a 318iS which was probably all his budget would stretch to anyway and so he headed-out in it.

He (as I would have) assumed that it would be a bit limp and lifeless - not a patch on the hot hatches/coupe's he'd been eyeing-up - but when he came back he'd decided it was the car for him! When I questioned this, he pressed the keys into my hands within a couple of days of getting it and told me to see for myself.

At the time I had a Civic 1.8 VTi which I hated for a raft of reasons, so I might have been slightly clouded in my judgement but 4 hours behind the wheel on motorways, country roads, town centres etc. left me nothing less than impressed. It did nothing amazing - it wasn't a "hot hatch" - it's performance was 'adequate" - but you got out feeling like you'd just gotten-in - it was a lovely car...

If I had a complaint, it's that for some reason no-one let you out of junctions/lanes on the motorway wink

It wasn't red inside tho!!!!

Edited by johnpeat on Friday 3rd June 02:00

johnpeat

Original Poster:

5,328 posts

266 months

Friday 3rd June 2011
quotequote all
Oddball RS said:
Four pot BMW = Huge fail, i'd rather walk its quicker.
Clearly you've never driven one OR you walk at one hell of a speed...

Taking a "oh, it's not the most powerful engine, so it's crap then" attitude is like rejecting a meal in a restaurant because it doesn't weigh enough - it shows ignorance of the true purpose of the thing...


johnpeat

Original Poster:

5,328 posts

266 months

Friday 3rd June 2011
quotequote all
Robmarriott said:
It is a 1.8, not the later 1.9
Will the extra 1 ft/lb and 0 hp really matter that much in a car under £1000? smile

johnpeat

Original Poster:

5,328 posts

266 months

Friday 3rd June 2011
quotequote all
EDLT said:
As others have said, I'd rather save up some more and get a six cylinder one.
I'd rather have a DECENT 6 cylinder, but I'd take this over the same period 320 which had a tiny bit more power/torque and a lot more bits to go wrong/a much heavier thirst...

I'd really rather not have that kit and wheels tho - it's trying too hard, really.

johnpeat

Original Poster:

5,328 posts

266 months

Saturday 4th June 2011
quotequote all
Am I right in thinking that E36 Compacts actually don't have the Z Axle rear suspension - so are, in effect, the earlier 3-series model (E28?) in terms of suspension and thus handling?

johnpeat

Original Poster:

5,328 posts

266 months

Saturday 4th June 2011
quotequote all
Kawasicki said:
Here we go again. Yes you are correct, no z axle in the E36 compact. The compact has the same basic rear suspension design as the original (E30) M3 so it has superb handling and it's a real drivers car!
I wasn't knocking it - just asking smile

johnpeat

Original Poster:

5,328 posts

266 months

Saturday 4th June 2011
quotequote all
GBB said:
Interesting hearing people's comments on values - with 190K on it (and FSH) then mine's technically worth peanuts (circa £200 according to WBAC) but it performs as well as anything cost 10 to 20x that amount.
No car is worth just £200 unless it has no tax and test - a "lottery ticket" rather than a car then smile

Anything with a ticket and no obvious faults is worth at least £400-500 these days - add on a bit for remaining tax - add on a bit more if the car is interesting - knock a bit off if it does 20mpg smile

The days of getting a runnable car for £200 are gone tho - I spend a fair bit of time looking at/dealing with cheap cars and that market just doesn't exist anymore (not least because most bangers cost over £200 a year to tax!!)

Once a car reaches a certain age (6+ years or so) you stop caring about mileage anyway - it's ALL about actual condition. If you car has no obvious problems, no looming expensive maintenance, 6+ months ticket and some tax you'd easily get £400+ from someone.

Let's be honest, any less than that and it's worth more as loose tyres, wheels, interior, other bits and some fuel!!