whose at fault?

Author
Discussion

surveyor

Original Poster:

17,875 posts

185 months

Friday 26th July 2013
quotequote all


Other half had a collision today in the barge. No damage to barge, but a mark on the other car. I initially believed other-half to be in the wrong, but on reflection am not so sure.

On the picture she was the red, other car the blue. At some point on the bend the collision occurred. She was as close to the left curb as she could be. Car is quite long. My suspicion is the blue car was not so close to her curb.

I think it's pretty clear that one of them should have stopped. As neither did, they both contributed to this and it could be 50/50?

Not comfortable now waiting to see if ambulance chaser gets involved or not...

Thoughts?

surveyor

Original Poster:

17,875 posts

185 months

Saturday 27th July 2013
quotequote all
Many thanks. We shall see what happens.

I'm told that it did not look like the other car was badly damaged. Might have a wander around the Close tomorrow with the dog and see if I can see it. Hopefully they will just go away.

If my car is damaged, it's on a bit of trim that had already been scraped so I'm not bothered. I like having these old cars...

surveyor

Original Poster:

17,875 posts

185 months

Saturday 27th July 2013
quotequote all
nails1979 said:
dibblecorse said:
50/50 and you'll both have fault claims on your record, without clear liability in one direction the ambulance chasers won't touch it.
Not so. You can still claim for personal injury you just get half. Any passengers would get full. Certain companys would also supply credit hire on those circumstances.
They had one passenger. If I need to even it up can a dog claim whiplash smile

surveyor

Original Poster:

17,875 posts

185 months

Saturday 27th July 2013
quotequote all
grayme said:
surveyor said:
Other half had a collision today in the barge. No damage to barge, but a mark on the other car. I initially believed other-half to be in the wrong, but on reflection am not so sure.

On the picture she was the red, other car the blue. At some point on the bend the collision occurred. She was as close to the left curb as she could be. Car is quite long. My suspicion is the blue car was not so close to her curb.

I think it's pretty clear that one of them should have stopped. As neither did, they both contributed to this and it could be 50/50?

Not comfortable now waiting to see if ambulance chaser gets involved or not...

Thoughts?
How are you sure your other half was as close to the left curb she could be?
Because she said she was, as she was trying to avoid the other car... I can only go on what I was told.

surveyor

Original Poster:

17,875 posts

185 months

Saturday 27th July 2013
quotequote all
thetrash said:
Which parts of the car hit each other?
front bumper corner of other car hit rear passenger door of my car. Did find some marks on mine and they literally wiped off.