Audi A4 vs BMW 3 Series Convertible

[junglie]

I would like to get a 4 seat convertible as a 'weekend' car for the family (2 small children). I think I have narrowed it down to an Audi A4 3.2 FSI of an E46 330ci. Both will be convertible, manual, 2006 / 07 (aware of tax implications) and standard spec including heated seats and sat nav.

Performance is broadly similar as is space etc and price is £6500.

The car will be used for trips out for the day with 4 so does need some boot space but thrashing around corners is not the top priority (unfortunately!).

Does anybody have any advice on either?

[junglie]

Audi is Quattro and manual so less issues than the other options.

Love the sound of the BMW engine, same as my E39 but sounds totally different.

[junglie]

This isn't helping!

I was hoping for a landslide victory one way or another.

[junglie]

Will definitely be a manual as I am not a massive fan of auto boxes even though they have come on massively over the years.

[junglie]

Lamboman - now that's funny! Had not thought in those terms.

[junglie]

I just don't know which way to go.

[junglie]

The obvious answer here is it just zip it up and get an E46 M3!

[junglie]

I have always been a fan of the E46 and still think it looks fresh many years after its birth.

I have not driven either in convertible form but would just think the Audi would be more refined but am basing that on absolutely no evidence!

[junglie]

The only issue I know of the 3.2 FSI engine is the coking problem that can affect some that have not been given a regular 'Italian tune up'. Is there anything else?

[junglie]

I knew that the B6 / 7 S4 was prone to cam chain stretch but thought the updated 3.2. (The non A3 version) was solid but it appears that it suffers the can chain stretch and the issues surrounding direct injection.

I know that only the horror stories appear on the internet but I am not sure I wish to risk it.

Looks like the venerable 330ci may be the way ahead then.

[junglie]

Phoned up about a couple if BMW 330ci Convertibles, both M Sport spec, but both had just sold. Love the idea of an M3 but feel the reality may be a bind if things go wrong.

Ringing the Audi chap today to discuss.

[junglie]

Thanks to rubber duck for your comment's.

The Audi A4 that I saw is not available until 6 May 14 when the seller returns from Europe. I am still looking at a 2004 BMW 330ci Convertible with 128k on the clock but 4 new tyres, new clutch and starter motor, 12 months MOT and 6 months tax for approx £4000 which may be a fun car.

That said, I am still tempted by a Z4M!

The other option is to get a cheaper 4 seat convertible (up to £5000) and a Z4 3.0 (£6000) but maybe too similar!