Would you still buy a diesel now?

[Monty Python]

So here's the dilemma - I have 2 cars in mind - an 18-month old 340i and a 12-month old 330d X-drive, both almost identical in terms of colour, spec and price. The 340i has more power (but poorer fuel economy), while the 330d can be remapped to the same power as the 340i while giving better economy (plus the extra traction from AWD).

Question is, with all the focus on diesel emissions, would you still buy one today?

[Monty Python]

It's mainly a daily commute of 30 miles, 2/3 on motorways.

[Monty Python]

wemorgan said:

That's only 600miles per month. Any diesel efficiency gains are going to be modest savings.
If you want to save money consider the depreciation instead.

Sorry - 30 miles each way, so ~300 miles per week.

[Monty Python]

Well, the decision has been made, and petrol it is.