Should I buy a pre LPG converted car instead of a tdi golf?

Should I buy a pre LPG converted car instead of a tdi golf?

Author
Discussion

da_murphster

Original Poster:

1,052 posts

248 months

Monday 19th April 2010
quotequote all
Right the 172 is going to make way for a mile muncher – missis does approx 20k a year and my mileage is likely to rocket as well.

I have about £5k and was looking at 320td, fabia vrs and golf 150 tdi’s

Just read a thread about LPG and thought maybe I should consider this.

I once bough a 185k 156 v6 alfa with a rubbishly done ‘self installed’ LPG kit….to say it didn’t really work out was an understatement – car needed huge amounts of TLC, the lpg used to switch off over 70mph and alfas drink fuel!

Am I wrong to let this experience put me off lpg – can they work? I am looking for a hassle free car experience with lots of mpg (or decent mpg equivalent).

I have good access to LPG around me and am ‘competent’ with filling etc.

I have had a quick look around and E46 328 or 330’s pre converted are in my price range – if they genuinely got the equivalent of 45mpg, hassle free, I would be a happy man with one of those.

Is it too good to be true? Do they ever work ‘like petrol’?

da_murphster

Original Poster:

1,052 posts

248 months

Wednesday 21st April 2010
quotequote all
A bump for my quest for cheaper motoring (in a half decent car)

da_murphster

Original Poster:

1,052 posts

248 months

Wednesday 21st April 2010
quotequote all
I have spotted a BMW 330i with lpg - reckons to get equiverlent of 52mpg.

It does have 150k on the clock but these engines are supposed to be strong.

Good idea?

Sounds good to me - as long as it works!

You say you cannot praise it enough - it works flawlessly? Does not switch over to petrol on the m'way?

Is 85% of petrol mpg about right to work off for LPG?