Proof that a manual is quicker than a PDK!!

[Trev450]

Shamelessly copied from Planet 9, this video puts Jason Plato and Marcus Gronholm in two 981 Caymans, one manual and the other PDK. The outcome, is unless you're chasing 0-60 stats, the manual is quicker.

Let the debate continue..................

http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedd...

[Trev450]

ORD said:

whereas I don't LFB in a manual.

Somewhat pointless anyway given that the ecu cuts engine power when this is attempted.

[Trev450]

TDT said:

Anyone that takes this single unscientific test as "PROOF that Manual is quicker that PDK" is very easily fooled,
A great thread to generate a discussion - But really is like a fart against the wind. More 'Proof Required' Must Try Harder.

The term 'proof' was said very much tongue in cheek when naming this post.

[Trev450]

VladD said:

My Boxster is currently showing 56 mpg. Beat that.

And you purchased a Porsche because....?

[Trev450]

mrdemon said:

Cmoose you have no chance with homerdog I am afraid ;-) it's much worse on PCGB where I am in the 20% of manual drivers :-(

Plenty of love for the manual over on Planet 9.

[Trev450]

Slippydiff said:

13 pages and counting, if this is still going strong at Christmas, will there be a truce on the day itself ? And if there is, do we get to meet up and drive each others cars ?

I guessed this topic would create a lively debate when I posted it, but didn't expect it to ramble on this long.

Edited by Trev450 on Sunday 30th November 14:22

[Trev450]

anonymous said:

[redacted]

Does that include maxing the top mounts in their slots? What's stock front camber anyway?

[Trev450]

anonymous said:

[redacted]

All I'll add to this is try downshifting in a lightweight, rwd car such as a Caterham or single seater without heel and toeing and you will end up facing the way you've just come quicker than you can blink an eye.

[Trev450]

That is a proper car. Superb.