Which Cayman 981 and best was to fund?

Which Cayman 981 and best was to fund?

Author
Discussion

matt21

Original Poster:

4,290 posts

205 months

Wednesday 27th July 2016
quotequote all
Hi all

Looking for your thoughts. I have always had a nice daily and have an old Passat at my disposal for the nasty stuff and airport runs, so will be doing about 10k per year in the new car. I get a company car allowance with no restrictions so expectation is I buy something half decent, which since my M135i went back I do not have

I recently bought a house and increased mortgage by an extra £20k to help me fund a car. I am over paying, mortgage is 1.99% and I am comfortable with this

I have a cash budget of £35k to buy something nice. No need to be practical as I have no kids and the Passat but nothing hardcore, I like my toys!

I am a BMW man, and nothing other than a Porsche would tempt me out when buying a car £30-50k. After going around the houses I have settled on a 640d which I can get fully loaded 18mths old for about £35k.

However, my father recently has purchased a 997.1 Turbo, and the Engineering quality has amazed me. I was thinking that getting into a Cayman may actually have a lower cost of ownership due to strong residuals.

Looking at Porsche approved you can get a 2014/5 Cayman for about £40k or an S which is a year older for £5k more.

Friends who have owned Porsches before always seem to upgrade and stay with the marque claiming that the cost to change was a "no brainer". They have always had PCP.

if I bought the Porsche I would probably pay £35k cash and finance the rest depending on APR. Yes, I understand spending hard cash on a depreciating asset is silly, but it typically still works out cheaper than financing it.

So my questions

The 640d will shed money, I accept that. In pure £ terms do you think a similar age Cayman will lose less over the next three years, and 30,000 miles?
Am I missing something with funding a Porsche? Am I best to finance to get stronger residual values? Or is cash still cheapest?
Cayman or Cayman S? Cayman S seems a lot more, is it really worth the extra? Or should I go bonkers and try and get a GTS?
Are there any other Porsches which Are fairly new (less than 5yrs), sub £50k which are likely to still have strong residuals in 3 years and an extra 30k on the clock? Cayman R?

Thanks all!

matt21

Original Poster:

4,290 posts

205 months

Wednesday 27th July 2016
quotequote all
Thanks for the feedback all. Regarding funding only debt is mortgage, so if I did PCP I would chuck an extra 30k into the mortgage, so my thought is buy for cash is better for me! The last BM I bought I got £1500 extra finance contribution for going PCP. I took it out and settled a few days later

Looking closely today it seems that to get decent spec on an S is nearer £50k. Call me soft but I would like nav, xenons and ideally Bose if I'm paying £40k plus. Maybe I get a 2.7, they are much better value and get good reviews! That said, it's the GTS or GT4 that I really want, but they are out of reach

The other curveball is the F-Type. I can get a cab S for early to mid 40s.

I am in no rush so will see what happens to prices into Autumn. Just want something nice ahead of winter

any more thoughts are much appreciated