997 Gen 1 or Gen 2 - what to buy?

997 Gen 1 or Gen 2 - what to buy?

Author
Discussion

c2mike

Original Poster:

421 posts

150 months

Saturday 19th November 2011
quotequote all
I'm 997 C2 shopping and need to decide on how new to go: Gen 1 or Gen 2. There's plenty of low mileage Gen 1s at good prices now (under £35k), but I'm attracted by the hopefully more robust new engine and better nav/bluetooth/ipod capability on the Gen2. However, that doesn't add up to £10k worth, which is about the extra £ required. Very few Gen 2 cars under £45K. Anybody got experience driving both generations?
BTW, my point of reference is a 3.4 996 C4 I owned several years ago. Loved the car, but it did suffer from some transmission wind-up (4WD related?), heavyish clutch and motorway road noise. What improvement can I expect with a 997 of either generation?

c2mike

Original Poster:

421 posts

150 months

Saturday 19th November 2011
quotequote all
I'm looking at buying in January - hopefully will show some more depreciation by then...

c2mike

Original Poster:

421 posts

150 months

Sunday 27th November 2011
quotequote all
I'm hoping to find a good Gen2 C2 for under £45k - preferably an S. Manual is OK for me - seems there is a premium for PDK. Surprised to see the last of the Gen 1s still being advertised at over £40k confused

c2mike

Original Poster:

421 posts

150 months

Monday 28th November 2011
quotequote all

c2mike

Original Poster:

421 posts

150 months

Saturday 3rd December 2011
quotequote all
It will be interesting to see if the Gen2 premium remains in 2 years time. Obviously will be smaller than it is now, but I think will still be significant with the more robust engine and a lot of improved details.

c2mike

Original Poster:

421 posts

150 months

Sunday 4th December 2011
quotequote all
Gen 2 engine is completely new. It is used in the turbo, so that should inspire confidence.
Front suspension was also changed - i remember reading about this when the Gen2 was launched (don't worry, i forget most other things in life rolleyes), but I don't know exactly what they did other than reduce the "bobbing", as stated above. Was it any more than the usual springs and damper facelift stuff?