Opinion on buying Mk1 or Mk2 ?
Discussion
Hi there, Ive been a member on these forums for many years now, originally as a schoolboy fan of the Tuscan. Now I am in the privileged position to actually consider buying one! (Big smile on my face even just typing that). This is something on the 'bucket list' that has to be done before my wife and I think about having a second child.
I have had a look on the forums at the buying guides (although the one at the top of the forum doesnt link directly to the sections like Interior etc??) and now having a real tussle about what to think about buying. Basically, I have always loved the look of the Mk1 Tuscan, thats the car I promised myself I would buy but the Mk2 has developed interior but the looks dont catch my eye as much as the Mk1.
I know that the general rule is that the cars got better the later they were made (and obviously the TLC that the owner gives) but my question is should I opt for the Mk1 and fulfil the schoolboy crush or Mk2 which sounds like it drives better overall? The car would be a 3rd vehicle for weekend fun. With values pretty strong just now, Im guessing as long as its condition and history is good then it should be a winner, but I keep wondering how different and noticable the drive would be between the two? Ive only driven a Mk1 once for about 3 mins at city centre crawl so not a true test.
Any advice on Mk1 v Mk2? thanks very much from an excited potential owner.
I have had a look on the forums at the buying guides (although the one at the top of the forum doesnt link directly to the sections like Interior etc??) and now having a real tussle about what to think about buying. Basically, I have always loved the look of the Mk1 Tuscan, thats the car I promised myself I would buy but the Mk2 has developed interior but the looks dont catch my eye as much as the Mk1.
I know that the general rule is that the cars got better the later they were made (and obviously the TLC that the owner gives) but my question is should I opt for the Mk1 and fulfil the schoolboy crush or Mk2 which sounds like it drives better overall? The car would be a 3rd vehicle for weekend fun. With values pretty strong just now, Im guessing as long as its condition and history is good then it should be a winner, but I keep wondering how different and noticable the drive would be between the two? Ive only driven a Mk1 once for about 3 mins at city centre crawl so not a true test.
Any advice on Mk1 v Mk2? thanks very much from an excited potential owner.
Edited by Imran_M on Tuesday 29th September 11:21
Walford said:
Some Facts
Most people want to buy a car with a TVR Power or Straight6 engine
Most people run aftermarket coilovers (i like nitrons)
No cars are on the geo settings they left the factory with,
(setup has a massive effect on how a Tuscan feels)
So your down to the dash and the grill, good luck
When you mention a straight6 engine, are you meaning Str8six the company? As in the rebuild that they do?Most people want to buy a car with a TVR Power or Straight6 engine
Most people run aftermarket coilovers (i like nitrons)
No cars are on the geo settings they left the factory with,
(setup has a massive effect on how a Tuscan feels)
So your down to the dash and the grill, good luck
ukdj said:
Have first hand knowledge that the Str8Six warranty is only any good if the company honour it, and can point you in the direction of several very unhappy customers - two sides to every story and all of that, knowing what I do now I would not pay the premium prices they charge for the "peace of mind" the warranty is supposed to provide.
I'm not saying dont touch a str8six rebuild, just dont pay over the odds for or rely on a warranty as a security blanket.
And to answer your original question, mk1 for me purely based on the styling - but it is what you want from the car that matters, so only you can weigh up the pros and cons offered here and make an informed decision.
I am assuming the warranty that is provided by these places is only valid for that particular garage? Ie You couldnt claim a warranty issue at Hexham for a car bought from Str8Six?I'm not saying dont touch a str8six rebuild, just dont pay over the odds for or rely on a warranty as a security blanket.
And to answer your original question, mk1 for me purely based on the styling - but it is what you want from the car that matters, so only you can weigh up the pros and cons offered here and make an informed decision.
Edited by ukdj on Wednesday 30th September 09:21
I'd like to say a big thanks to everyone for their helpful points of view, some good opinions on some of the pros and cons between both models. It's pretty clear to me that both are pretty astonishing cars really.
After much thought, I've decided I will likely be satisfying the craving that I had since school, and look for a nice Mk1. In fact,
I found one that I REALLY liked and planned to go and see it tomorrow for a closer look and test drive, but found out somebody had literally put a deposit down the day before! Heartbroken
Ah well that particular car wasn't to be but I'm going to keep my eyes peeled for a good condition and good history model... If any of you guys some across some nice examples please let me know. The search continues...
After much thought, I've decided I will likely be satisfying the craving that I had since school, and look for a nice Mk1. In fact,
I found one that I REALLY liked and planned to go and see it tomorrow for a closer look and test drive, but found out somebody had literally put a deposit down the day before! Heartbroken
Ah well that particular car wasn't to be but I'm going to keep my eyes peeled for a good condition and good history model... If any of you guys some across some nice examples please let me know. The search continues...
davidsc said:
Gotta be Mk1, that grill and open lights. Not to mention the high level indicators 
As plenty have said most MK1's are sorted now with new suspension, geo, rack spacers etc so they are a lot less frightening to drive.
What's your budget?
Mines in the classifieds if you'd like to have a look
I agree, the Mk1 is my original schoolboy crush so think it will probably be that model. Just seen your car, it's lovelyAs plenty have said most MK1's are sorted now with new suspension, geo, rack spacers etc so they are a lot less frightening to drive.
What's your budget?
Mines in the classifieds if you'd like to have a look
Edited by Imran_M on Friday 16th October 11:46
Gassing Station | Tuscan | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff