M135i or 435d xDrive?

[02joe]

Having a bit of difficulty between deciding on what car to go for next.

I like the idea of a more involving drive in the M135, but I also like the idea of laughable traction / performance all year round with the 435d...

Anyone lived with either and can report back on MPG, ownership experience etc?

[02joe]

It's a tough one. The reason why I eliminated the M235i is that I can't justify spending the extra money on a car which is essentially the same apart from the way it looks. There is hardly any support from BMW on the M235i whereas there are deals to be had on the M135. My thoughts for wanting the M135i is that it will be a great fun car and me being 23, now would be the time to enjoy a small fast hatchback. RWD and 300+BHP in a small car is a hoot. Part of me tempts me towards a manual for this car as well. That kind of power, manual 'box and RWD isn't common anymore.

Thinking behind the 435d is that I love the way it looks, I love the effortless performance, the fuel economy is a benefit but not a deciding factor. I took a 435d Luxury for a drive (i'd be going for an M Sport) and was really impressed by the car.

[02joe]

I had decided on the 435d and was hoping there might be a spec changable build slot between now and the end of the year.... I was being optimistic it seems. If I order it tomorrow they are saying Feb or March if I want to wait until the 15 plate.

Going to consider some options.