Car choice - TT RS or B7 RS4 or R8 V8?

Car choice - TT RS or B7 RS4 or R8 V8?

Author
Discussion

mk1fan

Original Poster:

10,520 posts

225 months

Sunday 23rd December 2012
quotequote all
Ignoring cost, who would choose what out of those three?

mk1fan

Original Poster:

10,520 posts

225 months

Monday 24th December 2012
quotequote all
Yes it's a serious question.

Hhmmmm R8.

Getting an R8 would necessitate having a second car - not really an issue but a consideration.

Getting either an RS4 or a TTRS would not. I think I could cope with the TT as a daily driver - biking requirements may be a bit of a push. The RS4 would cover all the bases so to speak. The only issue would be mpg for a daily driver.

The first reply was very helpful.

mk1fan

Original Poster:

10,520 posts

225 months

Monday 24th December 2012
quotequote all
I'll still have the Beast, turning up for a survey in an R8 doesn't project the right image.

I like to keep my cars for a while. I keep flopping between the three. Oddly enough, from my point of view / how I expect things to go, the TT is the least practical.

I'll get some insurance quotes, they may focus the mind!

mk1fan

Original Poster:

10,520 posts

225 months

Monday 24th December 2012
quotequote all
Wait for it. Prepare to be amazed;

It's a '99 VW Bora. With an 8v 2.0l n/a engine churning out a rip snorting 120bhp.

You know it be true man.

Bit of a ratter at the moment. Front wing was re-designed by a fellow tenant at work. The rear spoiler needs spaying to match the actual colour as do the Polo wing mirrors.

Still, this year will be the 10th year of ownership and she's never let me down. The only item I've had to buy outside of maintenance items has been a battery. Did a track day at Oulton Park last month and she loved it. Booked another for the 1st of March.

Her current function is to act as Builder's van, business vehicle, bike transporter and Le Mans transport.

mk1fan

Original Poster:

10,520 posts

225 months

Friday 28th December 2012
quotequote all
Been thinking about this in the quiet moments over the last few days.

I'm struggling to see how I'd get to use an R8 'regularly'. Trip to Le Mans - yes. Track days - yes. Riding trips in the Alps / Europe - no space for the bikes and kit. I don't have time for 'showing off' at social events as I don't go to any weeping. Still want one though. There's an early silver one in the Audi dealership at the end of my road which is loverly.

RS4 (either saloon or avant) would do everything.

TTRS would do everything until spawn appear (I refuse to struggle with getting child seats in the back of a 2/3-door car). 5-cylinder sound reminds me of the 80s Quattro and Coupes (my dad had one and it sounded great).

Regardless of which, I would most likely keep the Beast for builder's van duties - had 20 bags of sand in it a few months back.

mk1fan

Original Poster:

10,520 posts

225 months

Friday 1st February 2013
quotequote all
Bit of a resurection.

Having spent the week driving the Beast with a broken fuel pressure regulator valve and getting 11-17mpg I won't be getting an RS4 as a do it all car. I don't do a lot of mileage but having now experienced that sort of mpg - no thanks.

R8 and a diesel A2 spin

mk1fan

Original Poster:

10,520 posts

225 months

Sunday 10th February 2013
quotequote all
I'd say so. Went in one last year and it had five of use plus overnight bags without issue - felt more spacious than the 1-Series the SiL has that seems to struggle with five.

So two people and no rear seats should be doable in the A2.

mk1fan

Original Poster:

10,520 posts

225 months

Monday 14th October 2013
quotequote all
How life ticks by!

Right, quick update. Ended up getting a Touran diesel for biking / building duties. The Beast is having a 'refresh' and is going to be dedicated business use.

As for the 'fun' one. Still undecided. R8 V10 manual still up there but a couple of TVR's have raised their heads.

Insurance seems to be the ball ache. R8, no problem. 911, no problem. TVR, err, have you got experience of such a car???? Weird. TGhe quotes I have got for a TVR are twice that of an R8 V10. confused

Anywho, given the spare time I have at the moment it may well be December before I get a toy sorted. Just in time for the snow and ice bounce

mk1fan

Original Poster:

10,520 posts

225 months

Monday 14th October 2013
quotequote all
Oh and not forgetting the great mk1 GTi restoraton thread. Hhhhmmmmm. mk1 GTi with G60 engine.

mk1fan

Original Poster:

10,520 posts

225 months

Monday 28th October 2013
quotequote all
Well, having starting things off with the thoughts of an R8 and an A2 I've ended up with a Touran and a non-VAG based fun car. Will post up some pics when Tamy arrives in a few weeks.

mk1fan

Original Poster:

10,520 posts

225 months

Tuesday 29th October 2013
quotequote all
Currently putting together the mods for the Touran.

mk1fan

Original Poster:

10,520 posts

225 months

Wednesday 30th October 2013
quotequote all
ChrisRS6 said:
A Touran??
Instead of the A2 yes.

Tamy instead of the R8. Deposit paid today. Other commitments mean collection is delayed for a few weeks. Can't wait.

Although dropping some money at Darkside Developments is a welcome distraction.