HDD Replacement - is there something better?

HDD Replacement - is there something better?

Author
Discussion

C.A.R.

Original Poster:

3,967 posts

189 months

Wednesday 24th June 2015
quotequote all
My storage drive has given up in my desktop pc (1TB) and needs replacement.

The OS is running off the primary HDD which is a 4-year-old 500gb Western Digital item.

I was thinking of getting something newer and upgrading the primary to a 1TB drive as I run a lot more games than I originally intended to! Then using the existing 500gb HDD as a storage drive - I barely used 150gb of space on the one which has just given up the ghost.

I was talking to a mate and he said that you can get 2TB for less than £60 these days. But I wondered about performance at this price point and one thing I can't stand is waiting for file transfers and reading music from disk. I don't know a great deal about this area but the performance figures for write-read speed and cache seem better on the higher-end 1TB drives than the more budget-looking 2TB.

I've spotted this -
Western Digital 1TB Caviar Blue

And it seems pretty good, whilst being under my initial £60 budget. They do a performance model under the 'Caviar Black' label but this is exponentially more expensive still.

I want decent performance at a decent price and can't see the benefit in going up to 2TB unless it makes financial sense.

Am I missing anything? Is there a better HDD for my casual gaming / media storage PC at this price point?

Thanks in advance for any guidance.

C.A.R.

Original Poster:

3,967 posts

189 months

Wednesday 24th June 2015
quotequote all
Currently-

1TB storage drive (broken, keeps doing file check on startup) - 150gb used
500gb primary drive - 450gb used up (have to keep deleting large files to keep it usable)

I think with the 500gb as a storage drive I'll only really need a 1TB primary so my thought process was to go for performance over capacity.

I know SSDs get mentioned on here an awful lot but I didn't know if they used conventional leads / cases or if a more modern computer / motherboard was required (also not sure what capacity I'd get - pressumably not much - at my price point).

C.A.R.

Original Poster:

3,967 posts

189 months

Wednesday 24th June 2015
quotequote all
I've just noticed this one too which has similar specs but is from Seagate and has a 2TB capacity-

Seagate Barracuda 2TB

C.A.R.

Original Poster:

3,967 posts

189 months

Friday 3rd July 2015
quotequote all
LiquidKnome - that's precisely my current problem, my old motherboard isn't SATA3 - so it kind of killed this idea already. The advice received is to start over, basically frown

C.A.R.

Original Poster:

3,967 posts

189 months

Thursday 9th July 2015
quotequote all
Sorry for the late response - thanks for the advice.

So just to clarify, I can still plug an ssd into my SATA 2 motherboard, despite the ssd being labelled SATA 3? It'd be backwards compatible so to speak?