Front wishbones and bushes just replaced on my E46 320i...

Front wishbones and bushes just replaced on my E46 320i...

Author
Discussion

the hack

Original Poster:

49 posts

153 months

Wednesday 24th August 2011
quotequote all
...the steering wheel had been vibrating between 50 and 60 mph and on braking. 95k miles on the clock at the mo, so the wear and tear to be expected I suppose. The car now handles beautifully!

It cost £540 incl VAT all in (at a BMW independent), so not too bad a price. smile

Edited by the hack on Wednesday 24th August 10:52

Sir_Dave

1,495 posts

211 months

Wednesday 24th August 2011
quotequote all
Wow, wow, wow.

FYI, next time it happens (in about 45k miles), the front wishbone rear bushes are £80 delivered from C3BMW and take about 45 minutes to fit for both sides.

Also, unless the actual wishbones were physically bent, there would have been nno reason for your indie to have replaced them. All the bushes can be purchased seperately.

kev b

2,715 posts

167 months

Wednesday 24th August 2011
quotequote all
The wishbones do not bend but the ball joint is an integral part of the wishbone, therefore the whole arm must be replaced if there is wear in the joint.

the hack

Original Poster:

49 posts

153 months

Wednesday 24th August 2011
quotequote all
kev b said:
The wishbones do not bend but the ball joint is an integral part of the wishbone, therefore the whole arm must be replaced if there is wear in the joint.
Yes, that's right - on the E46 the whole wishbone needs to be replaced. There was definitely a lot of 'play' in the joint and the steering wheel wobbles and vibration have now gone - so the diagnosis was correct.

With regards to cost, it's always possible to buy cheap (eg. Eurocarparts) parts, but that would have been a false economy IMHO. smile

tgr

1,134 posts

172 months

Wednesday 24th August 2011
quotequote all
BMW parts then (not Lemforder)?

the hack

Original Poster:

49 posts

153 months

Thursday 25th August 2011
quotequote all
tgr said:
BMW parts then (not Lemforder)?
Yep!

8Tech

2,136 posts

199 months

Thursday 25th August 2011
quotequote all
£180.00 labour still sound a bit steep for replacing the 2 arms and bushes when its only an hours job!

edc

9,238 posts

252 months

Thursday 25th August 2011
quotequote all
I was charged 1 hour (£60 + VAT) labour to change a pair of wishbone bushes. I didn't renew the whole arm.

Moar

5,484 posts

168 months

Thursday 25th August 2011
quotequote all
I assume he has an SE as Sport bones would be £450 ish.

For se I would pay :

135 + 135 + 65 + 90

So around £425 all in .