Login | Register
SearchMy Stuff
My ProfileMy PreferencesMy Mates RSS Feed
2 3 4
Reply to Topic
Author Discussion

white_goodman

Original Poster:

1,309 posts

76 months

[news] 
Friday 13th July 2012 quote quote all
My wife would probably like an SUV or an MPV as our family car but I would much rather drive an estate. Just as much space, better looking and cheaper to run but which estate is the best? On which criteria do you decide?

I would suggest:
Alfa 156/159 (best looking)
Audi RS2/RS4/RS6 (coolest)
Volvo (most practical? - although I gather the newer Volvo estates i.e. V50/V60 aren't that large)

Does anything combine these qualities better? An old-shape Legacy estate perhaps? I know this is a bit subjective but what's the best estate car out there, old or new?

SWoll

4,921 posts

143 months

[news] 
Friday 13th July 2012 quote quote all
Define best..

I would suggest that probably the best estate car for a mixture of performance, driving experience, quality, practicality and economy is the BMW 535D M-Sport Touring.

'Looks' and 'Coolness' are too subjective to get a real consensus.

I'm sure others will disagree though. smile

Dusty964

6,095 posts

75 months

[news] 
Friday 13th July 2012 quote quote all
Classic range rover

TTwiggy

4,639 posts

89 months

[news] 
Friday 13th July 2012 quote quote all
I may be a little biased, but I'd plumb for the S/RS Audi Avants - practical, fast, 4WD for when it turns nasty and (until the most recent incarnations at least) very subtle and 'Q-carish'.

MattGTA

389 posts

57 months

[news] 
Friday 13th July 2012 quote quote all
MX5

getmecoat
Advertisement

Mermaid

17,533 posts

56 months

[news] 
Friday 13th July 2012 quote quote all
BMW 330DM Touring

il sole

253 posts

29 months

[news] 
Friday 13th July 2012 quote quote all
My mate bought a 2.0 twin spark 156 estate 2 years ago when the had their first baby. His wife loves it! it's also been 100% reliable even though it had done 120k miles...
although, the boot's tiny...

The previous generation A4 Avant was good and very well built, so long as it wasn't a 1.8T...

devnull

1,052 posts

42 months

[news] 
Friday 13th July 2012 quote quote all
W124 E320 Estate. Not exactly a slouch, carved from granite, though they are getting on quite a bit!

superlightr

6,922 posts

148 months

[news] 
Friday 13th July 2012 quote quote all






Best estate car out there. Even if Im biased.

Edited by superlightr on Friday 13th July 17:04


Edited by superlightr on Friday 13th July 17:05

TIGA84

3,575 posts

116 months

[news] 
Friday 13th July 2012 quote quote all
Legnum VR4

but I'm biased of course!

Mr E

15,327 posts

144 months

[news] 
Friday 13th July 2012 quote quote all
il sole said:
My mate bought a 2.0 twin spark 156 estate 2 years ago when the had their first baby. His wife loves it! it's also been 100% reliable even though it had done 120k miles...
although, the boot's tiny...
We had a 156SW with the V6 lump. Nice place to be, drove pretty well, had that engine. Not big.
Replace it with a hulking great Saab, which is pretty big.

UnderTheRadar

495 posts

58 months

[news] 
Friday 13th July 2012 quote quote all
There are loads of bear traps in this. I've been the owner of a Passat estate, a Mondeo estate, an Isuzu Trooper, a Landcruiser and a large MPV. A relative of mine owns an RS4 Avant.

Firstly lets dispell the size = space myth. The LC and the MPV have similar external dimentions. The LC has ground clearance and a bulky 4x4 transmission so internal hight is much less, coupled with a huge bonnet covering a longitudinal engine so the cabin is shorter than the MPV's (and the estate's) transverse layout. (The LC is for off-road work and towing stuff)

If, as the OP states, running costs are a consideration (especially fuel) the RS4 is ruiness. Of all the estates it seems to have least usable space of the bunch, although not awful. Some SUVs have extremely small usable space.

IMO I'd go for a large MPV if what you need is a child-carrier. Huge internal space designed for the job, not expensive to buy or run (as long as you steer clear of the Voyagers) The handling is better than you'd expect but the image is less good - depending on what type of person you want to impress.

dave stew

1,502 posts

52 months

[news] 
Friday 13th July 2012 quote quote all
I've got a P2 Volvo V70 T5. Does pretty much what I need for a family car - capacious, comfortable and tough/reliable.

It's never going to be an exciting steer, but you need to think WHY you need an estate - its not to lap the 'Ring, is it?

Personally, I'd err towards a big wagon as I don't see the point of having to 'suffer' a wagon but struggle to get stuff in it! My long suffering V70 has had no end of stuff in it - new kitchens, old kitchens to the tip, you get the drift.

Flying machine

653 posts

61 months

[news] 
Friday 13th July 2012 quote quote all
You might need to define a budget. Are you looking at ropey old bangers or flash high end monsters? If you can afford it then either an RS4 or 535d sound like very nice choices!

Matt UK

9,279 posts

85 months

[news] 
Friday 13th July 2012 quote quote all
Budget?

white_goodman

Original Poster:

1,309 posts

76 months

[news] 
Saturday 14th July 2012 quote quote all
Matt UK said:
Budget?
No budget, just speculating!

Trevor450

838 posts

33 months

[news] 
Saturday 14th July 2012 quote quote all
E Class.

lexusboy

933 posts

28 months

[news] 
Saturday 14th July 2012 quote quote all
Stagea

Dave Hedgehog

7,136 posts

89 months

[news] 
Saturday 14th July 2012 quote quote all
superlightr said:






Best estate car out there. Even if Im biased.
even as a massive RS fanboi that merc is lovely sperm

Jasandjules

50,758 posts

114 months

[news] 
Saturday 14th July 2012 quote quote all
I am quite happy with our Passat Estate. I will get the 170BHP version in time though.. I know it's an oil burner but I get 50mpg on a run quite easily. And she is comfy, and has plenty of gadgets, air con etc..
2 3 4
Reply to Topic