Liquid nitrogen powered cars - the future?
Discussion
There I was still thinking that the hydrogen cycle and fuel cells might be the ultimate solution to humanity's transportable energy problems, then I read this article and learnt that a new approach using the expansion of nitrogen as it flashes from liquid to gas is cheaper and more efficient!
http://www.economist.com/blogs/babbage/2012/10/nit...
They don't mention the risks inherent in dealing with cryogenic fluids at -165 degrees, but then it does have the benefit of not being flammable. I wonder if they can make a nitrogen engine sound good.....
http://www.economist.com/blogs/babbage/2012/10/nit...
They don't mention the risks inherent in dealing with cryogenic fluids at -165 degrees, but then it does have the benefit of not being flammable. I wonder if they can make a nitrogen engine sound good.....
"Weight for weight, liquid nitrogen packs much the same energy as the lithium-ion batteries used in ... electric cars. In terms of performance and range, then, a nitrogen vehicle is similar to an electric vehicle rather than a conventional one."
Great, another way to build overweight cars with very little range.
Forget it.
Great, another way to build overweight cars with very little range.
Forget it.
Ozzie Osmond said:
"Weight for weight, liquid nitrogen packs much the same energy as the lithium-ion batteries used in ... electric cars. In terms of performance and range, then, a nitrogen vehicle is similar to an electric vehicle rather than a conventional one."
Great, another way to build overweight cars with very little range.
Forget it.
Think of it as a battery without the nasty chemicals that can be fully recharged in a minute or so and never loses capacity with age.Great, another way to build overweight cars with very little range.
Forget it.
Ozzie Osmond said:
"Weight for weight, liquid nitrogen packs much the same energy as the lithium-ion batteries used in ... electric cars. In terms of performance and range, then, a nitrogen vehicle is similar to an electric vehicle rather than a conventional one."
Great, another way to build overweight cars with very little range.
Forget it.
Maybe, but the engine using the nitrogen is much cheaper! I was pleased to see that the scientist who came up with the means of vaporising the nitrogen directly in the engine cylinder is a Brit.Great, another way to build overweight cars with very little range.
Forget it.
CDP said:
Ozzie Osmond said:
"Weight for weight, liquid nitrogen packs much the same energy as the lithium-ion batteries used in ... electric cars. In terms of performance and range, then, a nitrogen vehicle is similar to an electric vehicle rather than a conventional one."
Great, another way to build overweight cars with very little range.
Forget it.
Think of it as a battery without the nasty chemicals that can be fully recharged in a minute or so and never loses capacity with age.Great, another way to build overweight cars with very little range.
Forget it.
Also a fair portion of any nitrogen you fuel your vehicle with will have to be vented as the car heats up. Plus if you leave your car in an enclosed space it will fill with nitrogen which can kill you pretty much instantenously.
Add to this the need for a completely new infrastructure and you have something which is even more mental than hydrogen and that is saying something!
Talksteer said:
CDP said:
Ozzie Osmond said:
"Weight for weight, liquid nitrogen packs much the same energy as the lithium-ion batteries used in ... electric cars. In terms of performance and range, then, a nitrogen vehicle is similar to an electric vehicle rather than a conventional one."
Great, another way to build overweight cars with very little range.
Forget it.
Think of it as a battery without the nasty chemicals that can be fully recharged in a minute or so and never loses capacity with age.Great, another way to build overweight cars with very little range.
Forget it.
Also a fair portion of any nitrogen you fuel your vehicle with will have to be vented as the car heats up. Plus if you leave your car in an enclosed space it will fill with nitrogen which can kill you pretty much instantenously.
Add to this the need for a completely new infrastructure and you have something which is even more mental than hydrogen and that is saying something!
Talksteer said:
Also a fair portion of any nitrogen you fuel your vehicle with will have to be vented as the car heats up. Plus if you leave your car in an enclosed space it will fill with nitrogen which can kill you pretty much instantenously.
Don't think breathing nitrogen will kill you instantly, you'd be dead right now if so. If you fill an enclosed space with it you will suffocate due to lack of oxygen though, but that's not instant.Also I wouldn't worry so much about a fuel leak freezing my tyres so much as explosive decompression of the nitrogen tank (assuming it's stored under pressure).
Flibble said:
Talksteer said:
Also a fair portion of any nitrogen you fuel your vehicle with will have to be vented as the car heats up. Plus if you leave your car in an enclosed space it will fill with nitrogen which can kill you pretty much instantenously.
Don't think breathing nitrogen will kill you instantly, you'd be dead right now if so. If you fill an enclosed space with it you will suffocate due to lack of oxygen though, but that's not instant.Also I wouldn't worry so much about a fuel leak freezing my tyres so much as explosive decompression of the nitrogen tank (assuming it's stored under pressure).
CDP said:
I don't think the pressure is that much of a problem as they can just take the lid off a nitrogen to lower samples into. Very weird but it doesn't suddenly boil off.
Exactly - storage is at atmospheric but container has to be heavily insulated.Good point about the boil off gas filling the garage. Effectively all parking places would need good forced ventilation to avoid dangerously low oxygen levels.
Note from the article that each car will have to carry water and methanol too. Problem will be stopping the Norwegians from trying to drink the methanol.....
Long term, the solution is to take the CO2 condensed from power stations etc (and currently planned to be pumped under the sea for storage) and apply a cheap energy source, such as equatorial solar power. With the assistance of water and some cunning chemistry, you can synthesise high energy density organic molecules. e.g. Diesel. Which is then easily tankered back to the rest of the world.
Money for thedespotic African dictators developing world, money for the oil companies which would run the system anyway, and an easy+fast fuel delivery system for vehicles with an already well developed technology.
Money for the
thinfourth2 said:
How you store energy in something exceedingly cold is somewhat puzzling to me.
I'd love to hear how this stores the energy
Also it looses the big plus side of electric cars
You can't recharge at home
It seems to me that the energy to run the car comes from the relatively warmer ambient conditions. By supplying liquid nitrogen you have just created an opportunity to exploit that. Doesn't mean that it is particularly efficient or necessarily a good idea.I'd love to hear how this stores the energy
Also it looses the big plus side of electric cars
You can't recharge at home
Edited by thinfourth2 on Thursday 18th October 07:04
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff