Does it matter which direction you lay laminate flooring?
Does it matter which direction you lay laminate flooring?
Author
Discussion

Big Worm 1

Original Poster:

537 posts

182 months

Friday 14th December 2012
quotequote all
I bought some laminate flooring with the intention of laying it myself at some point. However, the OH thought she would surprise me by getting her brother-in-law to make a start on it today while i was at work.

So i've come home today to find that the hallway has been finished, but........has laid it across the hallway instead of lengthways.

Now everything i read, or have seen on youtube said that the flooring should be laid lengthways towards the light source. So if the front and back rooms are laid in the same way as the hall, that will go against what i've been told as the flooring won't be going towards the windows.

The OH thinks that the hall looks good, but i think it looks like piano keys because it's going across our narrow hallway instead of lengthways.

So it looks like my options are, get the other two rooms done the way I had seen them done online, and then re-do the hallway, or just do the rooms the same way as the hall.

What are your thoughts, and is there any reason why it should be done lengthways towards the windows instead of across?

Thanks

ATTAK Z

16,150 posts

207 months

Friday 14th December 2012
quotequote all
You are right ... I would rip it up and do it properly but that's just me ... you may wish to be more diplomatic

TwigtheWonderkid

47,025 posts

168 months

Friday 14th December 2012
quotequote all
If the room is square, lay it facing the biggest window, the main light source. But if the room is rectangle, lay it lengthways, so parallel to the longest wall, if that makes sense. Regardless of light source. Sounds like your hall has been laid wrongly.

It's an optical illusion thing. Laying it lengthways in a room will stretch the room and make it look longer and wider. Laying it widthways makes it look shorter and narrower.

If your wife thinks it looks fine now, it's because she has nothing to compare it too. It'll look much better when laid correctly.

V8RX7

28,982 posts

281 months

Friday 14th December 2012
quotequote all
As above it only "matters" in that most people will think it looks better the other way.

I sure as hell wouldn't do a job badly to match an already poor job.

But then again if you / your wife prefer it that way - fine.

Personally I'd redo it but diplomacy was never my forte.

RevHappy

1,840 posts

180 months

Friday 14th December 2012
quotequote all
Add a few black inlays and start to reenact the sequence in "Big". Then rip it up and start again.

stevensdrs

3,256 posts

218 months

Friday 14th December 2012
quotequote all
Should have been layed lengthways with the underlay the opposite way. I would change it as looking at it everyday would annoy me no end.

Happy82

15,078 posts

187 months

Friday 14th December 2012
quotequote all
From what I read laminate flooring should either be laid end to end along the longest section, or if the room is square it should be towards the light source.

Don't think I would be too happy with a piano keys style either, would look a bit silly IMO.

nails1979

631 posts

159 months

Friday 14th December 2012
quotequote all
My hallway is quite long and whilst it's not narrow, it looks narrow because of the length. I laid my flooring left to right rather than length ways. People said I was doing it wrong but once it was finished it looks fine. I'd say I also depends on the finish of the wood. Mine is almost seamless joints so only see the grain.

Ray Luxury-Yacht

8,918 posts

234 months

Saturday 15th December 2012
quotequote all
An interesting take on this that I really liked - a mate of mine, who was a chippy, did his lounge with laminate diagonally - i.e. from one corner to the opposite corner.

I thought it looked great. He didn't have any subsequent problems with it either.


Dr Mike Oxgreen

4,352 posts

183 months

Saturday 15th December 2012
quotequote all
The real problem now is that by laying it across the room he will have cut a lot more of the planks than he would have done laying in lengthways. So when you take it up and start again, you may find that too many of the planks are now useless to you because they've had the interlocking tongue-and-groove ends cut off.

What a nightmare! If you do it again properly, you'll be committing a real snub against your wife and brother-in-law, who thought they were doing you a big favour. I wouldn't know what to do in your situation.

Pints

18,448 posts

212 months

Saturday 15th December 2012
quotequote all
You'll have to re-lay.
If you've got a reasonable relationship with BiL, just explain the error of his ways (for next time, ya see) in the nicest way possible.
If you don't get on with him, just crack on and, if he questions you, tell him he couldn't lay a prostitute.

russ_a

4,705 posts

229 months

Saturday 15th December 2012
quotequote all
The world won't end if you leave it a couple of years and do it again.


anonymous-user

72 months

Saturday 15th December 2012
quotequote all
russ_a said:
The world won't end if you leave it a couple of years and do it again.
I dunno, with christmas coming along and some boozy all day drinking, I predict the OPs dissatisfaction will grow into seething anger and it will erupt into a massive family feud. Everyone will tell each other some home truths and the OP and his Mrs will fall out as she sides with her bd sideways floor laying brother.

It will be really sunny on Christmas day and the floor will just not look right. It's all going to kick off.

mattdaniels

7,360 posts

300 months

Saturday 15th December 2012
quotequote all
It needs re-laying.

OP, seriously, best of luck with this one. beer

Fort Jefferson

8,237 posts

240 months

Saturday 15th December 2012
quotequote all
Big Worm 1 said:

So I've come home today to find that the hallway has been finished, but........has laid it across the hallway instead of lengthways.
Take it up and do it properly.


chr15b

3,467 posts

208 months

Saturday 15th December 2012
quotequote all
Don't say he did it wrong, say you prefer it the other way.

Pints

18,448 posts

212 months

Saturday 15th December 2012
quotequote all
chr15b said:
Don't say he did it wrong, say you prefer it the other way.
But he did it wrong. If he's not set right, how will he learn?

OldSkoolRS

7,019 posts

197 months

Saturday 15th December 2012
quotequote all
el stovey said:
I dunno, with christmas coming along and some boozy all day drinking, I predict the OPs dissatisfaction will grow into seething anger and it will erupt into a massive family feud. Everyone will tell each other some home truths and the OP and his Mrs will fall out as she sides with her bd sideways floor laying brother.

It will be really sunny on Christmas day and the floor will just not look right. It's all going to kick off.
Thanks for giving me a laugh this morning...the worrying thing is with families this could well happen. smile My ex FIL used to like to take over jobs on my behalf and it drove me crackers as he wouldn't do it the way I would (whatever the job was). It got that I would have to plan jobs in secret so that he wouldn't comes round when we were at work and start before I had chance. furious

Big Worm 1

Original Poster:

537 posts

182 months

Saturday 15th December 2012
quotequote all
Well i told the OH last night that it needs to be changed. I explained that as i had spent that sort of money on the flooring, i want it done the way i want, and that all the experts online said how it should be done.

So i will do the other two rooms the correct way, then see what i can salvage from the hall for when it gets re-done.

I know they were trying to help and do it as a surprise, but now i need to fork out more money to replace the flooring that has been used! frown

Roo

11,503 posts

225 months

Saturday 15th December 2012
quotequote all
Big Worm 1 said:
but now i need to fork out more money to replace the flooring that has been used! frown
That's another downside to it.

I did my hallway a couple of months ago. Not only does laying the flooring lengthways look better it was a hell of a lot easier as you lay more complete planks.