320d flood water damage
320d flood water damage
Author
Discussion

colin arpet

Original Poster:

2 posts

152 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
Hi

During recent floods in Gloucestershire I drove thro a lane where a stream had burst it's banks in a nine month old 320d Sport Touring. I'd seen two other cars drive thro and assessed that there was little or no risk. Did the right things - first gear, walking pace, no bow wave etc. Got to the middle and stopped dead. Managed to get pushed out by the guys behind me. In the two hours I waited for recovery over a hundred other vehicles got thro ok except an aged Rover 75 which attempted the feat at 20 mph.
Log book states if driven carefully wading depth is 250mm, I videoed the AA who recovered me crossing the water, 150mm depth maximum. Sent a copy DVD and covering letter to BMW UK who are pretty dismissive and my local dealers just don't want to know but admit there are currently six cars waiting to be assessed by insurers with similar damage.
Anybody else in the same boat (excuse the pun)?

kiethton

14,668 posts

211 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
I can only think that an insurance claim (on your own policy) is the only way to go TBH

There is no point in writing to BMW as although you were only driving slowly and the depth (when undisturbed) was 150mm when moving this is likely to have been increased - there will always be a bow wave....

Suck it up (well your insurers anyway) would be my advice - I avoid all puddles in my E39 as i did in my E92 - the GF is even worse than me for it in her E46....they weren't built to ford flooded roads.

roofer

5,136 posts

242 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
The air intake snout is very low at the top of the kidneys. Once its sucked water in, its fekked, unless no attempt to start it was made, you might have a chance, but the bores will need drying and the air filter will be wet. Unfortunately, my girl never heeded advice and snapped a rod, needing an engine change. Insurance co paid out, and we bought the salvage.

8Tech

2,221 posts

229 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
You will need to do an accident claim through your insurance I'm afraid. You will have sucked water into the airbox and hydraulically locked the engine, almost certainly bending the rod/s.

Even at slow speeds, the front panel will cause a bow wave to rise over it, straight into the intake.

I hope you have a decent insurers because they could dismiss the "accident" as negligence and refuse to pay.

Dealers are currently repairing the engines rather than replacing them.

colin arpet

Original Poster:

2 posts

152 months

Thursday 6th March 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for the comments guys. Churchill Insurance accepted the claim some two weeks ago, we're waiting for a new engine from the fatherland so that the dealers can fit it all back together again. I was maybe naively hoping that somewhere a precedent had been set with BMW UK accepting responsibility - arf, arf. I did send a polite begging letter and without compromising their stand they have offered me a goodwill gesture of £172 towards out of pocket expenses. Mug punter - six beemers and I've had a serious issue with five of them!

pdr10

1 posts

152 months

Friday 7th March 2014
quotequote all


Here is a photo of what happens to (generally one of) your conrods!

I don't know exactly what depth of water my car was driven through - I bought this 2010 118d Msport with 23K miles as a Cat D write-off and rebuilt the engine myself.



S7Paul

2,103 posts

265 months

Friday 7th March 2014
quotequote all
My boss had a similar experience in a 330d coupe. He approached a ford where all the cars in front drove through and continued on their way. He drove through and the engine promptly stopped. Ended up having a new engine fitted, which I think was around £9-10K. Lucky it was a company car! It's made me very cautious in my 320d.

Panda76

2,583 posts

181 months

Saturday 8th March 2014
quotequote all
Too much risk wading in cars.
Anything higher than half way up the wheel is too deep for me personally. Too many electrics and other gubbins to get wet. The charge air pipe sits low on these cars to, as does the turbo.
Half way up the wheel is probably too deep. I have turned round loads of times.

Years back when I had my defender even that wasn't wading proof from factory spec. To go deep wading ( over the bonnet stuff) that had to have extended breathers on the gearbox and axles. Go deeper than the wheel arch on defenders and you risk sucking water into the either of those. Safari snorkel, silicone sealed joints everywhere had to be regularly checked to keep water out. Pulled loads of cars out of flooded roads in years gone by, all conked out with locked engines. Wate almost to the top of my big muds (tyres) on the defender, why put a car through it is anyones guess.

Wading, fording in cars ?
No thanks.

paranha

633 posts

273 months

Saturday 8th March 2014
quotequote all
LooK on some German BMW sites--and postUp-they will give advice on their Dealer treatment from flooding.