RE: ?100K Garage: Matt Bird

RE: ?100K Garage: Matt Bird

Saturday 18th March 2017

£100K Garage: Matt Bird

Matt opens the batting for the latest £100K Garage challenge!



Name: Matt Bird
Previously owned: Rover 25 (a Cat D disaster), Ford Focus Mk1 (a dropped valve disaster; still think it was clocked), Honda Civic VTI (a rusty, revvy little joy), Peugeot 306 Rallye (oh, so they do lift-off oversteer...)
Currently owned: Nothing, awaiting pay rise to address this...
On the shortlist: Caterham 7, BMW M3, Lotus Esprit, Honda Integra Type R, Nissan Skyline, Renaultsport Megane, Dodge Challenger, Porsche Cayman, maybe a Mustang - there's lots to choose from!

UK: Caterham Seven
Cost
: £15,995
Balance: £84,005
Why I chose it: "Probably the easiest choice of these five to make. An Elise was tempting but I adore the sheer intensity of a Seven; despite having been fortunate enough to drive a few now, they still make me smile for being like nothing else and the better for it. As so many cars seek to distance you from their workings, to be so intimately and viscerally involved is fantastic.

"This Seven appears to tick a lot of boxes for my dream Seven for not all that much money: I'd like a limited-slip diff and 13-inch wheels instead of 14s, but to have a lairy colour and a 160hp K-Series for £15K is very appealing. I would say this is the dedicated track car, although you'll see the other garage choices are fairly focused!"


Germany: Porsche 911 (996.I) GT3
Cost
: £44,995
Balance: £39,010
Why I chose it: "I'm sure I'll get some stick for this - it wasn't my original choice, honest! I quite fancied an early Cayman, a V8 M3 saloon or perhaps a C63, with an even split of c. £20K for each country. Then this GT3 came up at £15K less than the other RHD cars (its mileage is relatively high) and I couldn't say no! Highlights include an enthusiastic seller, a bit more power, a Club Sport flywheel and loads of history. Lovely."

Europe: Renaultsport Megane 250 Cup
Cost
: £10,995
Balance: £28,015
Why I chose it: "This is what I meant about the garage being fairly focused! That being said I think the Megane would be my everyday car, albeit with some 18-inch wheels fitted with the leftover budget. If you're going for the purist's hot hatch then may as well go the whole hog...

"I prefer the looks of the later cars but, once more, the budget wouldn't allow. Perhaps the Porsche wasn't such a wise idea! This car had the Recaros, the Cup chassis, a recent cambelt and a full Renault service history - I can't think of a better way to spend £10K."


Japan: Nissan Skyline GT-R (R32)
Cost: £19,995
Balance: £8,020
Why I chose it: "Japan is the country I agonised most over. As a kid who spent too much time on Midfield Raceway rather than, you know, outside, there was a whole host of JDM specials immortalised by Gran Turismo to deliberate over.

"I drove an Integra Type R recently and it was sensational, the GT86 I ran as a long-termer was excellent and that's before thinking about various Spec C Imprezas and RS Evos. I could spend £100K entirely on Japanese stuff and be very, very content. In the end I settled for this GT-R, surely one of the last standard (alright, bar the exhaust) R32s available for less than £20K. I love the look, I love the motorsport history and I love the legendary status GT gave it. I just hope it drives as well as I think it does!"

USA: Chrysler 300C V8
Price: £6,995
Balance: £1,025
Why I chose it: "The sensory deprivation chamber for when the others get a bit too much! A big car with a big V8 and an auto 'box should make it far more relaxing than any of the others. I suppose there should be something moderately practical in the garage somewhere. Fortunately I happen to think the 300C still looks pretty cool as well, and £7K looks like an absolute bargain with 55,000 miles and one owner."



Author
Discussion

griffgrog

Original Poster:

705 posts

246 months

Saturday 18th March 2017
quotequote all
Love the Caterham Matt. It's got to be the foundations for any petrolheads collection. GT3 is also a great choice. Not sure about the others though....

What are the rules these days??

samoht

5,703 posts

146 months

Saturday 18th March 2017
quotequote all

Great picks, lots of diversity in engine type and drivetrain layout, and each one sounds like one of the best of its type.

Matt Bird

1,450 posts

205 months

PH Reportery Lad

Saturday 18th March 2017
quotequote all
griffgrog said:
Love the Caterham Matt. It's got to be the foundations for any petrolheads collection. GT3 is also a great choice. Not sure about the others though....

What are the rules these days??
Hello!

New format decided yesterday, it's now five cars for £100K but from five countries - USA, UK, Germany, rest of Europe and Japan. Tricky but lots of fun, though I would say that... Look forward to reading more!

diluculophile

130 posts

251 months

Saturday 18th March 2017
quotequote all
On first thoughts, these new rules look fairly open. Until you actually try to work out what you'd have.
No E39 M5 and 911. The 'rest of Europe' is pretty much a French hot hatch - can't think of much else, except maybe a classic.
With the USA, it's pretty much chuck half the budget on something you actually want, or filler for the few grand you have left over...

I've looked at the K-Tec website a few times and noticed that Megane.


samoht

5,703 posts

146 months

Saturday 18th March 2017
quotequote all
diluculophile said:
On first thoughts, these new rules look fairly open. Until you actually try to work out what you'd have.
True, which I think encourages creative thinking and more interesting choices than just a 'my favourite vaguely affordable cars' list.

diluculophile said:
The 'rest of Europe' is pretty much a French hot hatch - can't think of much else, except maybe a classic.
You could also get a nice comfy barge in France, or an Alfa or Lancia in Italy, for a reasonable price. You could get a Leon Cupra or Octavia vRS, or even blow half the budget on a lesser Ferrari. And there's all manner of charming oddities like Panhards and Tatras and Alpines and DeLoreans and stuff...

diluculophile said:
With the USA, it's pretty much chuck half the budget on something you actually want, or filler for the few grand you have left over...
You might want one practical vehicle out of the five - a cheap Jeep might be handy when the 'snowpocalypse' hits, or for towing. Otherwise, there's some mouthwatering stuff if you filter to pre-1980s, and not all of it too expensive.



Louison

3 posts

85 months

Saturday 18th March 2017
quotequote all
Great pick,

r32 for Gran Turismo sake,
GT3 to save the 996's,
the mobster Chrysler,
iconic English and the best of France!


Turbobanana

6,262 posts

201 months

Saturday 18th March 2017
quotequote all
Cheap Polo
Cheap Micra
Cheap Rover 25
Cheap PT Cruiser

Have I spent £1000 yet?

...leaving c£99,000 for a Ferrari.

Edited by Turbobanana on Saturday 18th March 23:06

jwwbowe

576 posts

172 months

Saturday 18th March 2017
quotequote all
I think the new rules are good, not as good as no rules but better than the last rules (70s cars, really? 60s cars and earlier were much cooler, what were you thinking PH?). Everyone will have a expensive purchase, some will Pick a German for this (yawn), others a muscle car (smile) or something from these shores (smile) but don't underestimate the non-German European, lots of Maserati, retro Citroen, Renault Sport, maybe even something with a prancing horse of bull on can be bought for this.

Redwest

14 posts

174 months

Sunday 19th March 2017
quotequote all
Not a bad mix, but the Chrysler...really? Would rather walk.

diluculophile

130 posts

251 months

Sunday 19th March 2017
quotequote all
samoht said:
You might want one practical vehicle out of the five - a cheap Jeep might be handy when the 'snowpocalypse' hits, or for towing. Otherwise, there's some mouthwatering stuff if you filter to pre-1980s, and not all of it too expensive.
When I did have a look at what I'd have, the USA option was a Grand Cherokee - and a few quid left over to make it a bit more off road capable.

I did completely forget about the existence of Italy...

smilo996

2,783 posts

170 months

Sunday 19th March 2017
quotequote all
Hmm
Well, it is PH so there is usually a Porsche but spending nearly half on one that looks like it has had a cheap body kit fitted. Oh well not my cup of tea, nor the 300C. Better cars avaialble for the money.

Caterham, most fun you can have in a car without buying a motorcycle. Great choice.
R32, another goodie and in knightrider black. Cool
Sporty Renault, not as iconic as the williams but likely a much better buy.

smilo996

2,783 posts

170 months

Sunday 19th March 2017
quotequote all
So the decades one did not last long, will those be displayed or was it really just a fantasy?

Matt Bird

1,450 posts

205 months

PH Reportery Lad

Monday 20th March 2017
quotequote all
smilo996 said:
So the decades one did not last long, will those be displayed or was it really just a fantasy?
Hello,

I'm afraid not, it's happened with a couple where they've arrived at the same time as many others and by the time we've got to them cars have sold. I see many of yours are still available so it should have featured - apologies. If you'd like to do another one I promise we'll run it soon!


Matt