Citizen vs. Tag vs. Omega?

Citizen vs. Tag vs. Omega?

Author
Discussion

Ikemi

Original Poster:

8,444 posts

205 months

Thursday 5th February 2009
quotequote all
Afternoon all! smile

I love browsing for the next watch, the buying experience accompanied with this and the satisfaction of wearing and appreciating said watch. I did have a small collection, which I am now downsizing, however all my watches are nowhere near the league of some owned by posters on here.

My latest watch is a Citizen Eco-Drive E81 in black ion covered stainless steel, which I purchased from F.Hinds a few days ago for £250 - I saw it and had to have it! smile It has perpetual calendar, alarm and chronograph functions. I should be content?

The thing is, whenever I buy a watch in my price range I can't help but see the Tag Heuer and Omega display cases ... It seems a lot of people own such watches on here too! At the moment they are a bit out of my price range for 'just a watch', but with some of my eBay items selling soon I could be in the market smile

I was just wondering whether someone could justify and/or explain why these watches cost so much i.e over £1K? I love the Omega Planet Ocean, Tag Aquaracer Automatic Chronograph and the Tag Link Automatic Chronograph ... Which would you go for? Does anyone have any real life pictures of the latter two? I've seen CommanderJ's Omega PO in orange, which looks rather tasty thumbup

I've also seen the Link Automatic Chronograph on US websites for just over £1K, rather than the UK RRP of nearer £2K. Good idea to import? Must be a bit less after customs? After-sales warranty issues?

I know I've written a fair amount with lots of questions, but any help is much appreciated! smile

Cheers!

Kris

Edited by Ikemi on Thursday 5th February 12:50

sparkyhx

4,151 posts

204 months

Thursday 5th February 2009
quotequote all
like a lot of things you are buying into a brand so things like 'value for money' start to become relative.

When you buy one of these brands you are generally :-
paying for the brand and the marketing that goes with it
paying for the fact that it is a mechanical watch
paying for lack of economies of scale
paying for better materials e.g. 316L steel, sapphire crystal's greater standard of waterproofing
paying for the case finish
paying for the fact that they are probably more labour intensive
paying for higher quality control standards.

all these add up especially the labour part e.g. a base ETA movement is about £40 a SOPROD version of exactly the same is about £500 - the difference is the SOPROD is taken apart and rebuilt with finer tolerances, some decoration is added and probably some parts changed, but the vast part of the difference is down to the labour costs.

With the exception of the branding many of these things can be had for less than than a TAG or Omega from many smaller companies eg Stowa. There are also brands out there that offer very little above the likes of Omega, but cost way more e.g. Panerai

Enjoy your Citizen


Edited by sparkyhx on Thursday 5th February 13:16

ShadownINja

76,352 posts

282 months

Thursday 5th February 2009
quotequote all
sparkyhx said:
paying for higher quality control standards.
Not according to the other thread.

alfabadass

1,852 posts

199 months

Thursday 5th February 2009
quotequote all
Sooner or later you'll want to jump.

It's never enough!

Went from Storm to Breil to Tag to Omega and next is Chopard.

CmdrBond

709 posts

199 months

Thursday 5th February 2009
quotequote all
I have a varied collection from a £22 Casio WaveCeptor (which is used to set my automatic watches by) to a limited edition 50th Anniversary Omega Speedmaster and various watches of different makes and values inbetween.

Enjoy the watches you have now, and if you see something which you like, then buy it as you will probably regret not doing it in the long run.

I have a Planet Ocean on my wishlist as well, but not quite as loud as Cmdr Jameson's one - the one I want is the black bezel with silver numbers - not sure which size to go for though.

CommanderJameson

22,096 posts

226 months

Thursday 5th February 2009
quotequote all
CmdrBond said:
I have a varied collection from a £22 Casio WaveCeptor (which is used to set my automatic watches by) to a limited edition 50th Anniversary Omega Speedmaster and various watches of different makes and values inbetween.

Enjoy the watches you have now, and if you see something which you like, then buy it as you will probably regret not doing it in the long run.

I have a Planet Ocean on my wishlist as well, but not quite as loud as Cmdr Jameson's one - the one I want is the black bezel with silver numbers - not sure which size to go for though.
It's not that loud.





Honest.

sparkyhx

4,151 posts

204 months

Thursday 5th February 2009
quotequote all
ShadownINja said:
sparkyhx said:
paying for higher quality control standards.
Not according to the other thread.
rolleyes

leginigel

428 posts

184 months

Thursday 5th February 2009
quotequote all
I like to buy 2nd hand then sell again to rebuy some I get to keep,some I think I will keep and sell sooner than I thought,enjoy what you got and move on!

had it about a year just sold it and a Omega speedmaster(rolex on Ebay,omega on PH) now hunting !

Seb d

613 posts

197 months

Thursday 5th February 2009
quotequote all
Omega>Tag>Citizen IMHO

Ikemi

Original Poster:

8,444 posts

205 months

Thursday 5th February 2009
quotequote all
Seb d said:
Omega>Tag>Citizen IMHO
Indeed, but I was wondering why a Tag is more expensive than a Citizen and why an Omega is more expensive than a Tag! smile