98RON or 95RON

Author
Discussion

solidstatelogic

Original Poster:

345 posts

169 months

Thursday 3rd June 2010
quotequote all
They say 98RON is recommended - is this what everyone is using?

I've been filling up with 95RON fuel and the car runs quite fine (Boxster S 987). Just wondered if the 98RON really made a big enough difference to warrant the higher cost?

Bill Stein

1,595 posts

210 months

Thursday 3rd June 2010
quotequote all
solidstatelogic said:
They say 98RON is recommended - is this what everyone is using?

I've been filling up with 95RON fuel and the car runs quite fine (Boxster S 987). Just wondered if the 98RON really made a big enough difference to warrant the higher cost?
Yes its octane and the engine is set up to run on what porsche specify. What does it say on your filler cap flap? Dont be tight, bet you would'nt run to well on cheap T-Bags would you!

Sunnysidebb

1,373 posts

168 months

Thursday 3rd June 2010
quotequote all
Absolutely.

Your Car is set up for 98 ron from the factory . Use Shell V power its the only one that is 98. ESSO & BP are 97 ron.

Your Ecu will have adapted its self to 95 and will have set the timing accordingly to stop any detonation so you wont notice the difference at first. Eventually the ECU will adapt to the 98 Octane but its going to take a very long time( 100 engine cycles I think corect me if i'm wrong). So long as you know your radio/ PCM code disconnect the battery with the key in position 1 ( stops alarm sounding) and the ECU will re-set the adaption values to the factory setting. You will notice a difference then.

Frank

baptistsan

1,839 posts

211 months

Thursday 3rd June 2010
quotequote all
V-Power is actually 99 RON. So even better.

Wills2

22,961 posts

176 months

Thursday 3rd June 2010
quotequote all
I use V-power my car really doesn't like 95 or 97 ron fuel for that matter.

SIIX TT

484 posts

185 months

Thursday 3rd June 2010
quotequote all
vpower

Roadrunner996

208 posts

177 months

Thursday 3rd June 2010
quotequote all
I read somewhere that higher octane fuel 'burns hotter' so you get more miles to the gallon compared to the cheaper stuff (no litres please, we're British). Somebody will correct me if I'm wrong.........

anonymous-user

55 months

Thursday 3rd June 2010
quotequote all
Tesco SUL 99 is the juice of choice for me - just smashing

davek_964

8,844 posts

176 months

Thursday 3rd June 2010
quotequote all
I've been using Tesco 99 since buying the car - but when getting the 964 serviced last month I was told the turbo would prefer Shell v-power and that after a few tanks I'd notice the difference.

I was pretty unconvinced, but did switch to v-power to give it a try. Much to my surprise, there is a noticeable difference - the car seems significant more urgent when I'm in a hurry. MPG is also improved - although I suspect Tesco 99 is still the economical choice.

I didn't expect much difference considering Tesco is 99 anyway - but I won't be going back to Tesco.

majordad

3,602 posts

198 months

Thursday 3rd June 2010
quotequote all
Whats 100 engine cycles ? Living in Ireland we only have 95 RON, when I visit the UK and onward to mainland Europe ( say a 2000 mile trip ) driving style and speed the same, but get the same MPG and no noticable power increase from 98 RON.

Diesel130

1,549 posts

213 months

Thursday 3rd June 2010
quotequote all
Shell V-Power all the way.

In Germany and Norway you can get it in 101 Octane too! :-) :-)

Nano2nd

3,426 posts

257 months

Thursday 3rd June 2010
quotequote all
Sunnysidebb said:
Absolutely.

Your Car is set up for 98 ron from the factory . Use Shell V power its the only one that is 98. ESSO & BP are 97 ron.

Your Ecu will have adapted its self to 95 and will have set the timing accordingly to stop any detonation so you wont notice the difference at first. Eventually the ECU will adapt to the 98 Octane but its going to take a very long time( 100 engine cycles I think corect me if i'm wrong). So long as you know your radio/ PCM code disconnect the battery with the key in position 1 ( stops alarm sounding) and the ECU will re-set the adaption values to the factory setting. You will notice a difference then.

Frank
are your sure? so if you use one tank of 95ron coz they've sold out of v power u need to start you engine 100 times before it goes back to 98ron mode? that sounds like horse **** to me

Neilpeel59

279 posts

220 months

Thursday 3rd June 2010
quotequote all
Diesel130 said:
Shell V-Power all the way.

In Germany and Norway you can get it in 101 Octane too! :-) :-)
Your Porsche is optimised to run on 98 RON, using anything higher will not make any difference whatsoever (unless you up the compression ratio) Using lower ie. 95 RON the knock sensor will retard the ingition slightly and you'll lose some performance.
Tesco is (claim) 99 RON because it contains the max allowable bio ethanol (5%) which comes with it's own potential problems

Edited by Neilpeel59 on Thursday 3rd June 21:58

graemel

7,035 posts

218 months

Thursday 3rd June 2010
quotequote all
I think the best example of this was when the missus had her first smart car mk1 1998. They only had a very small tank something like 22 litres. Her words. It's really strange. I get about 250 miles to a tank on unleaded but nearer 300 when I use super unleaded. That sold it to me. I'll let you do the math but her new Brabus Smart averages about 35mpg. WTF

richterswil

872 posts

192 months

Thursday 3rd June 2010
quotequote all
solidstatelogic said:
They say 98RON is recommended - is this what everyone is using?

I've been filling up with 95RON fuel and the car runs quite fine (Boxster S 987). Just wondered if the 98RON really made a big enough difference to warrant the higher cost?
I only ever use Shell V Power in my 997 - I am amazed that someone so obsessed with the reliability of Porsche engines would use a fuel with a lower rating than the manufacturers recommend.

Seems odd to me.

solidstatelogic

Original Poster:

345 posts

169 months

Thursday 3rd June 2010
quotequote all
I might have to go for 98 stuff then. I use 95 because there is an ASDA petrol station on my way to work and they don't have anything higher. The car runs ok but I like the T-bag analogy...

mayes911

5,219 posts

186 months

Thursday 3rd June 2010
quotequote all
my cayman s loves shell v power there is no subsitute for your porsche!

Sunnysidebb

1,373 posts

168 months

Thursday 3rd June 2010
quotequote all
Nano2nd said:
Sunnysidebb said:
Absolutely.

Your Car is set up for 98 ron from the factory . Use Shell V power its the only one that is 98. ESSO & BP are 97 ron.

Your Ecu will have adapted its self to 95 and will have set the timing accordingly to stop any detonation so you wont notice the difference at first. Eventually the ECU will adapt to the 98 Octane but its going to take a very long time( 100 engine cycles I think corect me if i'm wrong). So long as you know your radio/ PCM code disconnect the battery with the key in position 1 ( stops alarm sounding) and the ECU will re-set the adaption values to the factory setting. You will notice a difference then.

Frank
are your sure? so if you use one tank of 95ron coz they've sold out of v power u need to start you engine 100 times before it goes back to 98ron mode? that sounds like horse **** to me
Read up on the ECU and adaptivity also check out what 100 cycles means and it not starting the car 100 times either.
Its up to you, you wont harm the car using 95 ron it will look after its self but don't think it will restore any timing that it has pulled as soon as you put 98 in the tank. Its not even going to loos megga horse power but you wont get the best fuel consumption and it wont pull quite as well. I have some Millers octane improver just in case I cant get 97 super up in the highland and islands.
As I have said have a read up on the topic, better still have a chat with your Porsche dealer. They can also reset the nominal Factory values. However they wont condone using 95 octane fuel.

Edited by Sunnysidebb on Thursday 3rd June 23:01

rt911

689 posts

204 months

Thursday 3rd June 2010
quotequote all
Shell V power, always

although today I paid 1.71 euro (£1.49) / litre ..... ouch, this was in Milan though!

Back in Switzerland tonight and filled up again 1.68 CHF (£0.99)!!!!

50p a litre difference..... who says Switzerland is expensive!

KO993c4s

104 posts

173 months

Thursday 3rd June 2010
quotequote all
Shell V-Power all the way ... Long Live 99 RON...