Which Model Cooper S

Which Model Cooper S

Author
Discussion

Spy

Original Poster:

1,306 posts

209 months

Friday 3rd November 2023
quotequote all
Another question, how reliable are the Auto boxes in the Gen 1 Cooper S R52/R53 cars ?

Si 330

1,299 posts

211 months

Monday 6th November 2023
quotequote all
We currently have a Clubman S had it coming up to a year no issues so far with the engine silly, run flats lots of problems!!!
Prior to that we had a 5dr hatch 1.5 cooper had that from new for 3 years needed a new clutch at 42000 miles. Then before that had a 1.6 countryman from new again had it for 3 years no issues.

The 1.5 was far less economical than the old 1.6.

andybirtles

24 posts

194 months

Saturday 18th May
quotequote all
Is it still for sale?

this one I have is for sale, 56,000 miles



there are potential problems for all generation versions, many of them past maintenance related (or lack of it)

this one came to me 3yrs ago for a new clutch, rear main oil seal, timing cover seals, sump gasket, front suspension top mounts and lower arm rear bushes and outer ball joints, rear suspension trailing arm front bushes, full alignment, insp2 service, charger oil change, and had had other stuff, tyres were done after that, rear pads and discs, exhaust was changed just prior iirc

the earlier car is a manageable thing as a DIY prospect more than any other, which evolved engine wise and electronically into significantly more complex cars, nice as they are, they will, and do, cost more to live with, there is more to fail, the later cars with fewer stories have it all to show later, and it won't ever be cheaper to deal with

the supercharged S is always going to be a cult car, sure it costs a bit to tax and is a bit fuel heavy but standard or tweaked they are engaging things and more Mini than any other MINI, imo.
[/quote]