Hybrid commuter for 1k - what would you go for?

Hybrid commuter for 1k - what would you go for?

Author
Discussion

272BHP

Original Poster:

5,182 posts

238 months

Monday 13th May
quotequote all
In the market for a new hybrid bike. The bike will be my only bike so needs to be multi-functional - shopping/commuting/fitness/tow paths etc.

From a cursory look around I am drawn to the Canyon Roadlight range as they seem hard to beat spec wise. Must be a 1 x chainring setup.

Any other contenders?

BOR

4,724 posts

257 months

Monday 13th May
quotequote all
I've been commuting on a Roadlite for a few years now.

About 100km per week summer /winter.

It's covered in a layer of grey grime, gets occasionally washed when I feel guilty, but hasn't missed a beat.

Mine is a 2x but I run it as a 1x and will probably remove the front mech at some point.

It's a more sporting bike than a commuter, but with mudguards on, it does everything.

I would buy another if it got stolen.

272BHP

Original Poster:

5,182 posts

238 months

Monday 13th May
quotequote all
BOR said:
I would buy another if it got stolen.
High praise indeed! - thanks

troc

3,789 posts

177 months

Monday 13th May
quotequote all
Maybe a cube editor (over budget 11 speed hub but awesome - I use one for commuting) or a cube Hyde (8 speed hub gears and right around your budget)

These have an in gear hub so a little heavier and less efficient than a well-maintained derailleur but need practically no maintenance through the winter.

272BHP

Original Poster:

5,182 posts

238 months

Monday 13th May
quotequote all
troc said:
Maybe a cube editor (over budget 11 speed hub but awesome - I use one for commuting) or a cube Hyde (8 speed hub gears and right around your budget)

These have an in gear hub so a little heavier and less efficient than a well-maintained derailleur but need practically no maintenance through the winter.
My son has a nexus hub bike that has been nothing but trouble so I am wary about different drive systems.

Contemplating cycle2work scheme but my company only does Evans scheme and they have nothing of interest for me hybrid wise. Toying with the idea that now is the time to jump to electric for even greater versatility.

272BHP

Original Poster:

5,182 posts

238 months

Monday 13th May
quotequote all
Master Bean said:
That looks a bit too entry level.

Described as light in the description and it is 14.5kg?

OutInTheShed

7,941 posts

28 months

Monday 13th May
quotequote all
272BHP said:
..... Toying with the idea that now is the time to jump to electric for even greater versatility.
Surely you need to decide that before anything else?

If you will use an e-bike more, then I'd say 'do it'.

troc

3,789 posts

177 months

Monday 13th May
quotequote all
272BHP said:
troc said:
Maybe a cube editor (over budget 11 speed hub but awesome - I use one for commuting) or a cube Hyde (8 speed hub gears and right around your budget)

These have an in gear hub so a little heavier and less efficient than a well-maintained derailleur but need practically no maintenance through the winter.
My son has a nexus hub bike that has been nothing but trouble so I am wary about different drive systems.

Contemplating cycle2work scheme but my company only does Evans scheme and they have nothing of interest for me hybrid wise. Toying with the idea that now is the time to jump to electric for even greater versatility.
Fair enough but I live in Holland where almost everyone owns at least one nexus or Alfine equipped bike (and usually a couple other ones too) for their day to day commuting and stuff and they are mostly all fine. We have 3 nexus (3 and 7 speed) and one alfine here and haven’t had any issues in 20 years that were due to the hub.
Hub gears are the norm here.

Rustybanger

38 posts

6 months

Monday 13th May
quotequote all
Bought a Planet X London Road https://www.planetx.co.uk/products/planet-x-london... a few years ago for commuting to the station - seemed decent enough. Short journey though only c 5 miles. c£1k

Took it down a few firm tracks and it was fine with that as well - but mostly road commuting


272BHP

Original Poster:

5,182 posts

238 months

Monday 13th May
quotequote all
OutInTheShed said:
Surely you need to decide that before anything else?

If you will use an e-bike more, then I'd say 'do it'.
I already use a bike for most trips and rarely use the car anymore. In theory an e-bike could also grab those use cases where on some days a destination is just a little too far for bike. This would leave the car solely for long journeys and heavy weather.

I had been exploring various add on electric kits so maybe something lightly assisted like a Specialized Vado SL would be a really flexible solution going forward. But then again it does add more complexity, a lot more cost and is very attractive to bike thieves.

I dunno, I will mull it over.

272BHP

Original Poster:

5,182 posts

238 months

Monday 13th May
quotequote all
Rustybanger said:
Bought a Planet X London Road https://www.planetx.co.uk/products/planet-x-london... a few years ago for commuting to the station - seemed decent enough. Short journey though only c 5 miles. c£1k

Took it down a few firm tracks and it was fine with that as well - but mostly road commuting
That looks a good deal for the money but drop handle bars are a no no. I want a hybrid for city riding.