Solar Panels?

Author
Discussion

No ideas for a name

2,222 posts

87 months

Friday 3rd May
quotequote all
AdamV12V said:
Are you guys just making this up??? confused

Just done a spot check

  • As best I can see, a Givenergy 8.2Kw battery is £2600-2800 on google search.
  • Solar Edge 8kw is £2750 on google search.
The prices I have been quoted for the 8kw Sigenergy battery is £2800 (fitted) and £2100 (fitted) for the 5kw version.

Hardly double, indeed I would say, pretty much exactly the same....
When you say battery... do you mean just the battery, or are you including the inverter/charger?
Fogstar want £1050 for their 5kWh unit (battery only).

I have just bought 13.4 kWh of cells direct from the factory for about £1200 - and I think a large chunk of that is shipping.
NOTE: Cells, not a 'battery'.




AdamV12V

5,072 posts

178 months

Friday 3rd May
quotequote all
No ideas for a name said:
AdamV12V said:
Are you guys just making this up??? confused

Just done a spot check

  • As best I can see, a Givenergy 8.2Kw battery is £2600-2800 on google search.
  • Solar Edge 8kw is £2750 on google search.
The prices I have been quoted for the 8kw Sigenergy battery is £2800 (fitted) and £2100 (fitted) for the 5kw version.

Hardly double, indeed I would say, pretty much exactly the same....
When you say battery... do you mean just the battery, or are you including the inverter/charger?
Fogstar want £1050 for their 5kWh unit (battery only).

I have just bought 13.4 kWh of cells direct from the factory for about £1200 - and I think a large chunk of that is shipping.
NOTE: Cells, not a 'battery'.
A battery module... You can add up to 6 batteries per stack. (watch the video I linked). The price Ive been quoted includes shipping AND installation. The sigenstor controller/inverter is needed at the top of each stack. They can be either 1phase or 3phase and each stack can have 1-6 batteries of either 5kw or 8kw (any mix is fine), so min 5kw, max 48kw per stack.

Some tech specs on the batteries and various models of inverters for anyone actually interested: https://www.sigenergy.com/uploads/en_download/1693...

Fogstar wasnt one of the makes in the question though was it... There's always somebody who is very cheap in any market. Sigengery certainly isn't pitching to be the cheapest, its USP's lie in the tech stack (again watch the videos), but it doesn't appear to me to be twice the cost of the two brands actually enquired about above.

OutInTheShed

7,816 posts

27 months

Friday 3rd May
quotequote all
No ideas for a name said:
AdamV12V said:
Are you guys just making this up??? confused

Just done a spot check

  • As best I can see, a Givenergy 8.2Kw battery is £2600-2800 on google search.
  • Solar Edge 8kw is £2750 on google search.
The prices I have been quoted for the 8kw Sigenergy battery is £2800 (fitted) and £2100 (fitted) for the 5kw version.

Hardly double, indeed I would say, pretty much exactly the same....
When you say battery... do you mean just the battery, or are you including the inverter/charger?
Fogstar want £1050 for their 5kWh unit (battery only).

I have just bought 13.4 kWh of cells direct from the factory for about £1200 - and I think a large chunk of that is shipping.
NOTE: Cells, not a 'battery'.
The Fogstar battery probably contains a 'BMS' as well as a bunch of cells?
Plus you get more support and some warranty, so it's not a baad price.
A link to the cell source would be interesting please!

No ideas for a name

2,222 posts

87 months

Friday 3rd May
quotequote all
OutInTheShed said:
The Fogstar battery probably contains a 'BMS' as well as a bunch of cells?
Plus you get more support and some warranty, so it's not a baad price.
A link to the cell source would be interesting please!
For clarity - yes, the Fogstar does seem a decent price. It does indeed include the BMS and is a consumer plug and go package.
When I said 'battery only' - that was to differentiate between batteries and inverter/chargers.

The cell price was just for reference... not suitable for an end user.
PM sent with more details.

ETA: Ah, your account doesn't accept emails.. PM me and I can give you some more detail if you like.


Edited by No ideas for a name on Friday 3rd May 19:00

silentbrown

8,875 posts

117 months

Friday 3rd May
quotequote all
AdamV12V said:
Hardly double, indeed I would say, pretty much exactly the same....
Yes. doesn't look that expensive to me.
SolarEdge price looks wrong, Their stuff is usually cripplingly expensive.
(The GivEnergy 8.2 is largely obsolete, I think. The 9.5 is normally used now)

Fogstar stuff is cheap (and reputable), but you may struggle to find an installer, as they won't make much margin on them. They're mostly used for DIY installs.

dmsims

6,555 posts

268 months

Friday 3rd May
quotequote all
Givernergy 5.2kWh is £1249 - soon addes up..................

Fogstar 15kWh is £2500

AdamV12V said:
The prices I have been quoted for the 8kw Sigenergy battery is £2800 (fitted) and £2100 (fitted) for the 5kw version.

Hardly double, indeed I would say, pretty much exactly the same....

AdamV12V

5,072 posts

178 months

Friday 3rd May
quotequote all
dmsims said:
Givernergy 5.2kWh is £1249 - soon addes up..................

Fogstar 15kWh is £2500

AdamV12V said:
The prices I have been quoted for the 8kw Sigenergy battery is £2800 (fitted) and £2100 (fitted) for the 5kw version.

Hardly double, indeed I would say, pretty much exactly the same....
£1249 delivered and fitted??? Just so we are comparing like for like here…

Google says £1550-£1800 ish just for the kit, so not sure where your buying it and whose delivering and fitting it for £1249.

https://www.google.com/search?q=Givernergy+5.2kW&a...

Not that it really matters anyway. Sigenergy isnt positioning itself as the cheapest on the market, nor has my reseller/fitter ever said its the chepest. In fact he openly said there are cheaper options, but this is the best tech on the market right now for what I want.

If “cheapest” is your sole driver, then crack on buy it, but it isnt what I am looking for, and I suspect I may not be the only person who doesnt just want the absolute cheapest soln they can find.

DonkeyApple

55,594 posts

170 months

Saturday 4th May
quotequote all
No ideas for a name said:
Something potentially odd with SigEnergy?

https://www.sigenergy.com/en/about
mentiions they are Sigenergy Technology Co., Ltd.

Assuming that is a UK registration, it is a new company, not yet filed accounts, based in China - something odd with the appointments, based above a Sainsbury's local.

Web site list the UK contact as two mobile numbers.

General rule - beware the glossy web site.
It's standard ring fencing which is a pretty common activity in this sector. You'll have to wait for accounts to be filed to see whether any revenues are being passed through it but the normal purposes of the local corporate entity is for issuing the product warranties. It's a cheap way of putting a backstop on the risk in each local market.

Very many solar panel and battery consumer warranties are technically worthless because they're issued by an SPV rather than the parent so that in the event of a significant issue the parent business is completely safe, the SPV can default on its obligations as it has no means with which to meet them and the parent, if necessary can even quickly rebrand itself sales line, ditch all the SPVs and historic consumer risk.

There is a big retailer wheeze, especially used by Chinese factories which is to first use a reseller entity in China, this adds a brand and carries out the exporting and overseas contract work and serves as the first ring fencing act. These entities quite often are shut down every few years so as to bury liability risk periodically. These entities then set up SPVs in the local consumer market and these carry the local consumer risk such as warranties, legal compliance etc so can be shut down inside 24 hours if needs be.

And before I accidentally upset anyone by mentioning Chinese business tactics I ought to just add that if you happen to recognise this ring fencing practice it'll be because you do as the Chinese learned it from us and the US where it has always been used for selling stuff like double glazing and stuff sold in the back of comics etc.

The risk is that sometimes it's used because the factory is knowingly cutting corners or in some terrible cases fraudulently applying safety certifications.

We don't know precisely the specific scenario here but 167 City Road is an accountancy and nominee service provider so nothing at all to do with any of the Ltd that are registered under that address.

The sole director, MR YINGTONG XU resides overseas.

So what you are almost certainly looking at is an off the shelf Ltd purchased from the firm at 167 City Road who have also been hired to supply secretarial services and nowadays using nominee directors is generally not done as these U.K. service companies don't want to trigger AML alerts there will be one director put forward by the overseas parent company. In this case Mr XU.

The website talks about 500 employees etc. those will mostly be the factory workers, the work units bussed in each morning, beaten with sticks and then bussed back to the company accommodation dormitory (where the rent is mysteriously similar to their pay). And don't panic, this is another practice we invented here in Blighty and had e the world. We really perfected it when exploiting the Irish to build the railways. We'd force them to rent billets from their employer but leave just enough money left over to buy food from the company shop and beer from the company pub.

But it may be that those 500 employees aren't theirs as the website may be the brand agent in China not the actual factory.

While this all sounds dubious and poor form and potentially hugely dangerous to all the overseas consumers who might be hoodwinked by all this malarkey, we in the U.K. are absolutely fine as we invented it and gave it to the world. We took the medieval serf mechanism and rolled it into the Industrial Revolution and went out around the world teaching it and building a massive global empire. So what that means is that there is no one in the U.K. who doesn't know how and why this is done so no one in Britain is at any risk.

silentbrown

8,875 posts

117 months

Saturday 4th May
quotequote all
I haven't looked much at sigenergy, but one of the most important factors for me is the ability to control and monitor the system locally - ie, no reliance on a central server somewhere.

Also, decent network protocols and security. Givenergy network access is basically 'glued on' over older serial protocols and is far from reliable and robust.

Gareth79

7,717 posts

247 months

Saturday 4th May
quotequote all
silentbrown said:
Also, decent network protocols and security. Givenergy network access is basically 'glued on' over older serial protocols and is far from reliable and robust.
There's nothing inherently unreliable or not robust about that. Serial protocols/connections with separate controllers are an industry standard for control systems, likely hence why many devices use RS485/CAN. It means the system has a longer life too, since the controller can (in theory) be easily and cheaply replaced.


silentbrown

8,875 posts

117 months

Saturday 4th May
quotequote all
Gareth79 said:
There's nothing inherently unreliable or not robust about that. Serial protocols/connections with separate controllers are an industry standard for control systems, likely hence why many devices use RS485/CAN. It means the system has a longer life too, since the controller can (in theory) be easily and cheaply replaced.
In GivEnergy's case it's a hacked version of Modbus, using a generic TCP-to-serial device. It's fine until you have multiple TCP clients connected (e.g. phone app, and their server), at which point, every client receives every reply, and the likelihood of chaos increases. Changing settings in the web app can be very hit and miss.

2ono

562 posts

108 months

Tuesday
quotequote all
Does anyone have any recommendations for a company they have used that are Essex based, or anywhere based but willing to travel, looking for a relatively large install, up to 30 panels maybe and a decent sized battery and the other stuff that goes with it. Thanks in advance.

KTF

9,835 posts

151 months

Tuesday
quotequote all
Daryl at Light Renewables. Based on Maidstone but will travel anywhere.

Very competitive prices for Sharp brand panels and solar edge kit. On par price wise with the other installers who quote Chinese panels and entry/mid level brand kit.

https://www.lightrenewables.co.uk/

dobly

1,202 posts

160 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
Artisan Electrics, based in Cambridge seem a decent, professional outfit: https://www.artisanelectrics.co.uk/contact/

You might even get your house filmed for their YouTube channel!