How long will Rooney be Birmingham manager?

How long will Rooney be Birmingham manager?

Author
Discussion

Gary29

4,170 posts

100 months

Tuesday 2nd January
quotequote all
Bin off ETH and get Rooney in at Man Utd now biglaugh

Challo

10,226 posts

156 months

Tuesday 2nd January
quotequote all
mickk said:
Sycamore said:
5th when he took over, now 20th after 83 days. Prick hehe

I've no idea how the clown show of some of these ex-England stars get these jobs. Clubs just attracted to the name?

Rooney, Gerrard, Lampard, Neville - All have made awful managers.
Gerrard is stinking the place out even in Saudi, wasn't he tipped to be the next Liverpool manager?
Neville is the exception as he did Peter Lim a favour in taking over at Valencia, but he also was dog st.

The others seem to have got jobs based on their names. Rooney has been terrible at all his clubs, Lampard didn't pull up tree's with Derby but somehow got the Chelsea and Everton job. Now unemployed which says alot.

Gerrard had to go to Saudi to get a job, and looks poor there as well.

Must be loads of great managers in the lower divisions crying out for jobs, that would be far more qualified but owners over look them.

Muzzer79

10,127 posts

188 months

Tuesday 2nd January
quotequote all
Sycamore said:
5th when he took over, now 20th after 83 days. Prick hehe

I've no idea how the clown show of some of these ex-England stars get these jobs. Clubs just attracted to the name?

Rooney, Gerrard, Lampard, Neville - All have made awful managers.
'Prick' is a bit unnecessary IMO.

I thought he did OK at Derby, considering. Gerrard did very well at Rangers.

If anything, I think they move to top tier management too soon and should spend more time learning the craft in lower leagues. Difficult to refuse a PL side if they come calling though.

Sycamore

1,814 posts

119 months

Tuesday 2nd January
quotequote all
In part of Rooneys statement:

"Football is a results business - and I recognise they have not been at the level I wanted them to be. However, time is the most precious commodity a manager requires and I do not believe 13 weeks was sufficient to oversee the changes that were needed".

Mr Rooney, you were the change that sent everything down the pan....


ALTO77

313 posts

143 months

Tuesday 2nd January
quotequote all
Muzzer79 said:
'Prick' is a bit unnecessary IMO.

I thought he did OK at Derby, considering. Gerrard did very well at Rangers.

If anything, I think they move to top tier management too soon and should spend more time learning the craft in lower leagues. Difficult to refuse a PL side if they come calling though.
Gerrard winning one trophy out of a possible nine, in a two team league, isn't what I would describe as doing very well.

Cobnapint

8,638 posts

152 months

Tuesday 2nd January
quotequote all
They'd have been better off with his missus.
Seriously.

fiatpower

3,059 posts

172 months

Tuesday 2nd January
quotequote all
mickk said:
Gerrard is stinking the place out even in Saudi, wasn't he tipped to be the next Liverpool manager?
Only tipped due to his name. I'm thankful he screwed up at Villa and now Saudi as that appears to have killed off his chances.

V8covin

7,369 posts

194 months

Tuesday 2nd January
quotequote all
Rooney was in discussions with his coaches on the touchline during a recent match.He sat there with a blank look on his face while his coaches did all the talking.He hasn't got a clue, it's the same with his after match interviews,comes across as more than a bit thick, he's not cut out to manage/coach

SydneyBridge

8,674 posts

159 months

Tuesday 2nd January
quotequote all
The odd top player will become a decent manager, but not many

'In total, Rooney has won 39 of his 137 games as a manger, earning him a career win record of 27.7%. Rooney has drawn a further 34 matches and lost 64'

Driver101

14,376 posts

122 months

Tuesday 2nd January
quotequote all
It was a very odd decision by Birmingham to appoint Rooney in the circumstances they did. It has backfired like everyone predicted.

AC43

11,509 posts

209 months

Tuesday 2nd January
quotequote all
Driver101 said:
It was a very odd decision by Birmingham to appoint Rooney in the circumstances they did. It has backfired like everyone predicted.
It was ridiculous. I though Eustace was going a great job. He was until recently assistant coach at my club QPR and was well respected. He looked like he'd made the step up well.

Oh well, owners getting drawn to big names.....seen it over and over at QPR with predictable stty results.

Gargamel

Original Poster:

15,022 posts

262 months

Tuesday 2nd January
quotequote all
Sycamore said:
5th when he took over, now 20th after 83 days. Prick hehe

I've no idea how the clown show of some of these ex-England stars get these jobs. Clubs just attracted to the name?

Rooney, Gerrard, Lampard, Neville - All have made awful managers.
Hoddle

Cobnapint

8,638 posts

152 months

Tuesday 2nd January
quotequote all
V8covin said:
Rooney was in discussions with his coaches on the touchline during a recent match.He sat there with a blank look on his face while his coaches did all the talking.He hasn't got a clue, it's the same with his after match interviews,comes across as more than a bit thick, he's not cut out to manage/coach
Yep. You can usually tell from the body language and expression on a manager's face as to whether the lights are on or not.
Lampard was the same, and so 'is' ETH at Man Utd.

Robdabank

77 posts

136 months

Tuesday 2nd January
quotequote all
Let's face it, Rooney only went to Birmingham because of a misunderstanding... someone had mentioned there were plenty of cheap naans!

Muzzer79

10,127 posts

188 months

Tuesday 2nd January
quotequote all
ALTO77 said:
Muzzer79 said:
'Prick' is a bit unnecessary IMO.

I thought he did OK at Derby, considering. Gerrard did very well at Rangers.

If anything, I think they move to top tier management too soon and should spend more time learning the craft in lower leagues. Difficult to refuse a PL side if they come calling though.
Gerrard winning one trophy out of a possible nine, in a two team league, isn't what I would describe as doing very well.
Aside from the Scottish cup which they won in the season he left, they've only won one league cup trophy since and are currently 8 points adrift (albeit with two games in hand)

Look, I'm not claiming that he's Pep Guardiola's scouse cousin, but stopping Celtic's 9-championship run deserves some credit.

JNW1

7,812 posts

195 months

Tuesday 2nd January
quotequote all
SydneyBridge said:
The odd top player will become a decent manager, but not many
Very true. Pep's the obvious example of someone who's enjoyed success at the highest level as both a player and a manager but he's very much the exception not the norm; Carlo Ancelotti and Kenny Dalglish are others who spring to mind but the list isn't a very long one!


Downward

3,639 posts

104 months

Tuesday 2nd January
quotequote all
mickk said:
Sycamore said:
5th when he took over, now 20th after 83 days. Prick hehe

I've no idea how the clown show of some of these ex-England stars get these jobs. Clubs just attracted to the name?

Rooney, Gerrard, Lampard, Neville - All have made awful managers.
Gerrard is stinking the place out even in Saudi, wasn't he tipped to be the next Liverpool manager?
I said at the time if he does get the Liverpool job after Villa then great because that means he would have done a good job.

Radec

3,869 posts

48 months

Tuesday 2nd January
quotequote all
Let's see what Wayne had to say about it.


Pitre

4,609 posts

235 months

Tuesday 2nd January
quotequote all
Being a fantastic player certainly doesn't indicate potential as a competent manager. Another example is (was) Vieira...