Do you have to sit in the police car?
Do you have to sit in the police car?
Author
Discussion

texaxile

3,819 posts

181 months

Sunday 4th October
quotequote all
Penny Whistle said:
How about the response "No thank you but you're very welcome to come and sit in my car"

No, not serious
How about the response "No thank you but you're very welcome to come and sit in my car, where the seats recline, ma'am" *

FTFY.

  • Note: This reply will probably get you arrested.

Bigends

6,196 posts

159 months

Sunday 4th October
quotequote all
vaud said:
BlackTails said:
I think if I were pulled over on the hard shoulder of a busy motorway, I would rather chat behind the Armco than in the back seat of a police car sitting on the hard shoulder.

Cold and rainy as that might be for everyone.
Do many police cars with full lights on get hit by HGVs?
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-tayside-central-48463970
https://www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/news/great...
https://www.lancs.live/news/lancashire-news/m57-dr...

BlackTails

4,040 posts

86 months

Sunday 4th October
quotequote all
vaud said:
BlackTails said:
I think if I were pulled over on the hard shoulder of a busy motorway, I would rather chat behind the Armco than in the back seat of a police car sitting on the hard shoulder.

Cold and rainy as that might be for everyone.
Do many police cars with full lights on get hit by HGVs?
How many people standing on the grass behind the Armco get hit by a vehicle?

It’s relative risk. Some vs next to none, I’d guess.

bentley01

1,201 posts

167 months

Sunday 4th October
quotequote all
vaud said:
Do many police cars with full lights on get hit by HGVs?
I guess if a truck has a blow out it doesn’t matter how well lit the police car is. We are constantly told don’t stay in a vehicle on the hard shoulder and be behind the barrier. I am not antagonistic and I have always passed the attitude test but I’m not sitting in the back of a car on the motorway.

vaud

60,040 posts

186 months

Sunday 4th October
quotequote all
Bigends said:
vaud said:
BlackTails said:
I think if I were pulled over on the hard shoulder of a busy motorway, I would rather chat behind the Armco than in the back seat of a police car sitting on the hard shoulder.

Cold and rainy as that might be for everyone.
Do many police cars with full lights on get hit by HGVs?
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-tayside-central-48463970
https://www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/news/great...
https://www.lancs.live/news/lancashire-news/m57-dr...
So not many in 7 years and none by HGVs, which was my question. Some minor injuries, no fatalities. I'll take the risk in a police car, if they allowed me to put on my seat belt wink

Bigends

6,196 posts

159 months

Sunday 4th October
quotequote all
vaud said:
Bigends said:
vaud said:
BlackTails said:
I think if I were pulled over on the hard shoulder of a busy motorway, I would rather chat behind the Armco than in the back seat of a police car sitting on the hard shoulder.

Cold and rainy as that might be for everyone.
Do many police cars with full lights on get hit by HGVs?
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-tayside-central-48463970
https://www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/news/great...
https://www.lancs.live/news/lancashire-news/m57-dr...
So not many in 7 years and none by HGVs, which was my question. Some minor injuries, no fatalities. I'll take the risk in a police car, if they allowed me to put on my seat belt wink
Plenty more online. Behind the Armco is the safest place for all

The OP's question can also apply to non motorway stops too so declining a seat may not just be for safety issues but being more comfortable being dealt with on neutral territory outside the car maybe

Edited by Bigends on Sunday 4th October 22:48

fourthpedal

198 posts

35 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
But why are they stopping people on the motorway in the first place - I've seen footage of police tailing someone until they're off the motorway for a stop precisely to avoid stopping on the hard shoulder. In other countries I've seen police use "follow me" signage to bring them off at the next junction. Can't most hard shoulder stops be avoided (at least when the driver is being compliant, which you presumably are or else you wouldn't be being "invited" to the police car in the first place).

loskie

7,150 posts

151 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
Courser said:
xx99xx said:
That's a fail on the attitude test straight away.
The very fact that there is some sort of attitude test is disgusting and explains a lot of what is wrong with policing.
Or peopling.

I laugh at the YT videos when the police ask "are you an auditor sir". There's no such thing. Don't give the knobs credibility they don't deserve,

The HONEST answer from the "auditor" would be "No. I'm just an annoying dhead with a camera".


vikingaero

13,591 posts

200 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
The officer needs to process you/give a ticket to you or give words of advice to you. Do people forget how fking noisy the hard shoulder can be. I remember one using a motorway telephone and putting my head inside the tiny box to try and hear!

donkmeister

13,152 posts

131 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
If worried, sit in the back but leave the door open, claiming you have horrific flatulence.

That way you are being polite, and the officer probably doesn't want to be Dutch ovened in his place of work so won't object.

Penny Whistle

7,756 posts

201 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
loskie said:
I laugh at the YT videos when the police ask "are you an auditor sir". There's no such thing. Don't give the knobs credibility they don't deserve,
Many many years ago my answer would have been "Yes, would you like me to assess your practice and procedures for compliance to ISO9000 ?"

donkmeister

13,152 posts

131 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
Penny Whistle said:
loskie said:
I laugh at the YT videos when the police ask "are you an auditor sir". There's no such thing. Don't give the knobs credibility they don't deserve,
Many many years ago my answer would have been "Yes, would you like me to assess your practice and procedures for compliance to ISO9000 ?"
hehe

I used to have a job where they would roll me out in front of the ISO 9000 auditors because we spoke the same language.

People acted like getting audited was terrible, and difficult. I liked getting audited because it was the only recognition I ever received for doing my job properly. hehe

vikingaero

13,591 posts

200 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
Shirley sitting in a police car gives you the opportunity to counter/reason/give your side of the story/view the onboard footage etc.

If you say nope, not getting out, then I as a copper would think, fk it, he can have the ticket.

alscar

10,091 posts

244 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
Rich1973 said:
Watching motorway cops, police interceptors etc, whenever anyone is pulled, they are always 'invited' to take a seat in the back of the police car.

Considering the news items of police tazering a 92 year old dementia patient etc, if I ever find myself in the position of being pulled I would far rather stand outside where passing witnesses can see me. I've seen how the police are in various programs and truth be told dont particularly trust them.

My question is - can you refuse to sit in the back of the police car?
The vast majority of those invites seem to be to those that are already “ obviously “ guilty but why on earth would you refuse the invite if you had ( in your eyes ) done nothing wrong ?
Mind you it’s the same vast majority that usually meekly get into the back anyway.

vaud

60,040 posts

186 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
donkmeister said:
hehe

I used to have a job where they would roll me out in front of the ISO 9000 auditors because we spoke the same language.

People acted like getting audited was terrible, and difficult. I liked getting audited because it was the only recognition I ever received for doing my job properly. hehe
Did you ensure that the audited material was labelled. And the chair. And the stapler. wink

Plus4Four#

309 posts

12 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
I was running QA in our factory and was an accredited auditor. Audits were more like regular checks but some formal. Having to deal with HMRC was fun! They did an annual audit but they were a breeze as our systems were spot on. Simple and straight forward. Watching their eyes glaze over when explaining details was fun. Avoiding terminology and using simple terms.

Countdown

49,578 posts

227 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
Plus4Four said:
I was running QA in our factory and was an accredited auditor. Audits were more like regular checks but some formal. Having to deal with HMRC was fun! They did an annual audit but they were a breeze as our systems were spot on. Simple and straight forward. Watching their eyes glaze over when explaining details was fun. Avoiding terminology and using simple terms.
Apologies if stupid question - why would HMRC do QA audits? The only audits I've ever known them to do were to make sure we were paying the right amount of tax (Payroll, Expenses, VAT). I thought QA audits would be done by the body awarding the certification....

Cats_pyjamas

1,974 posts

179 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
Having had a blow out on the m62 and having had to ring breakdown I can confirm it is hellish noisy standing on the side of a motorway, too noisy to have a comfortable conversation. Just have a chat in the car.

xx99xx

3,082 posts

104 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
vikingaero said:
Shirley sitting in a police car gives you the opportunity to counter/reason/give your side of the story/view the onboard footage etc.

If you say nope, not getting out, then I as a copper would think, fk it, he can have the ticket.
So basically to have an argument? That'll end well.

LotsOfLaughs

386 posts

46 months

Tuesday 6th October
quotequote all
I'd look at this from several different angles.

1.) You've been a very naughty boy and you're definately going to jail. You can sit yourself in the police car, or you can refuse and the officer and his or her collegues will force you into the police car. You won't be compensated for any injuries you sustain from failing to comply with police.

2.) You've been a tad silly, caught red-handed driving at a speed that his majesties government deems to be rather too brisk. If the officer finds you to be a good chap, he or she may be inclined to let you off with a few choice words of advice. If the officer decides you're a bit of a problem customer, you'll recieve a letter in the post demanding some money, and a digital stamp on your license which magically means the lovely people at the insurance companies may help themselves to an awful lot more of your money, should you continue to bother with insurance, of course.

3.) You know you've done absolutely nothing wrong, you're clean as a whistle, and you feel like reminding the officer that you like having civil rights. Note that you better be damn sure of those rights, and what you are actually required to do by law. Judging by the fact that you needed to ask this question, you don't know the law well enough to be a smartarse.

That does raise the question though, if one was a litigious prick, could you earn a living by winding the police up until they smash the car window and drag you through it, and then sue them for personal injury?