a curate's egg - ecoboost S550

a curate's egg - ecoboost S550

Author
Discussion

irocfan

Original Poster:

40,431 posts

190 months

Wednesday 21st November 2018
quotequote all
Well I managed to snag myself an S550 convertible for 2/3s of my holiday and was quite chuffed.

Initial impressions are good comfortable with a reasonable amount of luggage space, good toys (heated/cooled seats, decent radio, various driver modes to play with) and quite a nice feel (in all honesty prefer my camaro, but it's closer than I thought it would be). Then I started it up - dear Lord!! What a hateful, agricultural sounding lump it has frown

The next surprise was the 10sp auto, fine in theory but in usage it's (IMHO) no better, if not worse, than the 6 speed in my SS Camaro or the 7 in my SLK.

The final shock for me was the fuel economy, having driven from Florida to Washington I expected to get some decent figures but I was flabbergasted to find that my old Camaro returned similar figures (I've not had my 2013 long enough to return any mileage figures).

In fairness this is a rental with 16k on the clock, but I'm definitely underwhelmed and am interested in seeing how the V8 fares in comparison

mfp4073

1,946 posts

174 months

Thursday 22nd November 2018
quotequote all
I have never driven the Eco boost Mustang, but the V8 is very impressive straight out the show room. My brother has just had a full exhaust fitted including headers and it felt like a different car, as the standard system is woefully poor.
As for the Camaro, I really don't like the 2019 face lift, but prior to that I love the overall look and stance, it's very " Muscle car". I also think the LS engines are probably the best V8's around. They are very simple compared to the Ford V8 which will be a bonus when they are out of warranty.
If you own a Camaro, I doubt it it would be worth the cost to change as they are both great cars.