Top Gear TV gains McGuinness and Flintoff
BBC confirms presenter switch-up as Matt LeBlanc stands down and Rory Reid moves onto Extra Gear exclusively
Just as Top Gear TV felt like it was getting back into its stride, another major change has been instigated in its presenter line-up. Matt Le Blanc's replacement - or rather replacements - have been announced as comedian Paddy McGuinness and cricketing legend Andrew Flintoff. Hands up who saw that coming?
The duo will fill Le Blanc and Rory Reid's roles, with the former standing down so he can spend more time back home and the latter moving to focus on BBC Three's Extra Gear. There is some continuity, though, with the incumbent Chris Harris remaining - which, we're sure, most here will agree is very good news.
What does the shakeup mean for Top Gear's future? It's a shame that we'll lose the on-screen rapport built up between Le Blanc and Harris, don't you think? The last season in particular saw these two, both genuine car enthusiasts from vastly different backgrounds, producing some truly excellent television, engaging and entertaining in a seemingly unchoreographed way. Their chemistry was starting to feel more natural than the caricatured on-screen relationships of Clarkson, Hammond and May, it was like Top Gear TV had found its stride again, although this time it was more mature. And more about cars.
That the announcement of McGuinness and Flintoff as the new lead presenters has been met with a mixed response is therefore unsurprising. You have to question if this 'entertainment show' will be able to remain consistently smart and in-depth enough with its new line-up to appeal to petrolheads, whilst still entertaining the masses the BBC so desperately wants to cling onto. Either way, the upcoming 26th series will mark the close of a short but sweet high point in Top Gear TV's turbulent recent history. Whether the seasons that come next will be able to build on that legacy, we'll have to wait and see.
PHers are already discussing the new Top Gear presenters in the forums here.
I’m not saying Chris Harris should go back to YouTube but I wish he had his own show or own thing, maybe with 1 presenter and he’d be the main focus. I’d always watch top gear on the iplayer and fast forward any part without Chris Harris.
I’m not saying Chris Harris should go back to YouTube but I wish he had his own show or own thing, maybe with 1 presenter and he’d be the main focus. I’d always watch top gear on the iplayer and fast forward any part without Chris Harris.
At the beeb he is forced to appeal to the lowest common denominator in the interest of not boring the audience to tears about steering feel, and discussion on suspension etc.
I appreciate he gets a nice steady paycheck vs YouTube but his content between the two really are worlds apart.
Come back to youtube monkey!
And there are other car guys out there who would be entertaining and know what they're talking about. Jason Plato and Guy Martin would have been my pick.
The whole TV format is drifting it seems, plenty of content online which is actually decent. Watching things like Harry's Garage and 44 Teeth is the norm for me now, although Top Gear, Fifth Gear, Gran Tour etc are always fun to have around.
I hope McGuinness isn't as bad as I fear, I am sure they'll be a cull if the ratings nose dive.
At the beeb he is forced to appeal to the lowest common denominator in the interest of not boring the audience to tears about steering feel, and discussion on suspension etc.
I appreciate he gets a nice steady paycheck vs YouTube but his content between the two really are worlds apart.
Come back to youtube monkey!
I can see Flintoff already running around trying to pull paddy’s trousers down and doing a cheeky chappy northern monkey thing in front of cars he has no clue about.
Bring back Chris Evans if not LeBlanc, at least he had an interest in cars (I can’t believe I have just written that).
That’s the coffin firmly nailed on TG.
It may be that I have not seen the better / 2nd series episodes, but I don’t think a change of presenters will be much of an improvement in terms of the TG show format, but fail to see how the presenters can be less of a team than the ones they replace.
For me, TG with Clarkson and Co was about that camaraderie / rivalry that seemed to exist between the presenters, scripted or not it was entertaining at times.
I’m not saying Chris Harris should go back to YouTube but I wish he had his own show or own thing, maybe with 1 presenter and he’d be the main focus. I’d always watch top gear on the iplayer and fast forward any part without Chris Harris.
At the beeb he is forced to appeal to the lowest common denominator in the interest of not boring the audience to tears about steering feel, and discussion on suspension etc.
I appreciate he gets a nice steady paycheck vs YouTube but his content between the two really are worlds apart.
Come back to youtube monkey!
He started on YouTube years ago, how is it, someone like Shmee is milking the game, flying like 100 times a year to different launches and press reviews and what not while appearing to make good money out of it.
I mean of course, time is what it is and he does a family but I can’t help but think, somewhere along the line, he missed a trick in the YouTube game, his content was brilliant and drew millions of views, what went wrong
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff