Potential tyre sidewall damage on lease - new tyre needed?

[Thomas-7n5dy]

Hey guys,

hoping I can get some thoughts on the picture below as to whether you think on inspection they'd say I'd need a new tyre due to the damage shown. Caused by wife badly curbing the front left last week and car goes back in few months.

Trying to balance cost of new tyre at end of the lease as a penalty or just buying a part worn now or just before we had the car back.

Any thoughts welcome!

https://imgur.com/a/3bO355L#gG88jcl

Thanks

[Welshbeef]

Also the cost to refurb the alloy - if you think they will just ignore that damage i think you’d be extremely inlikely to get away with it

[Thomas-7n5dy]

I was always going to have alloy charge any way but only £36 so nothing really.

Just dont want whole tyre cost if I can avoid it.

[Dave.]

Just stick one of these on a few days before it goes back?

https://www.camskill.co.uk/m55b0s468p142370/Aoteli...

If they deem it damage and charge you for a new tyre, it'll be an expensive on, plus fitting, plus admin fee, etc.

[Nickp82]

Stick a part worn on it, that’s what I did with the Leon Cupra we leased.

[troika]

Put it this way, would you buy a car that looked like this? You bend it, you mend it.

[anonymous-user]

Ask the lease company for a copy of their acceptable wear and tear policy, it should all be in there. If not I’d ask them, they’re not there to catch you out.

That tyre would pass an MoT IMO, the damage is on the rim protector and isn’t a risk for water penetration or further damage so it’s probably ok but it will depend on the terms.

I know VWFS charge for tyre replacement at prevailing main dealer rates so definitely something to find out before it goes back if your lease company applies the same sort of policy.

Just ask them.

[Thomas-7n5dy]

charltjr said:

Ask the lease company for a copy of their acceptable wear and tear policy, it should all be in there. If not I’d ask them, they’re not there to catch you out.

That tyre would pass an MoT IMO, the damage is on the rim protector and isn’t a risk for water penetration or further damage so it’s probably ok but it will depend on the terms.

I know VWFS charge for tyre replacement at prevailing main dealer rates so definitely something to find out before it goes back if your lease company applies the same sort of policy.

Just ask them.

I’ve had a look at the details and just standard wording of “side wall damage” results in new tyre charge.
My challenge is would the damage shown be considered side wall damage because as you say it’s just the rim section of the tyre.

Think I’ll just do a part worn Pirelli. About 70 then finding a place to just swap the tyre out. The risk of VWFS charging us for the new tyre are retail costs and fitting etc.... will be north of £250 I reckon.

[FWIW]

I’m pretty sure that they would just charge for the tyre at the main dealer rate, which isn’t too bad ime; maybe 10% over what you could get elsewhere.

I would be inclined to chance it and argue the toss with them, technically it’s not sidewall damage, it’s rim protector damage.

[anonymous-user]

Just pick up the phone or send them an email and ask them.

[pavarotti1980]

troika said:

Put it this way, would you buy a car that looked like this? You bend it, you mend it.

Or just pay them the fee at the end of the term for the damage at £35 a wheel +/- tyre.

So "you bend it, you dont mend it"