mini countryman ...good buy??

mini countryman ...good buy??

Author
Discussion

dirky dirk

3,013 posts

170 months

Monday 26th July 2021
quotequote all
we got given a mini 1.4 one,
every weekend theres a warning light or a drip of oil,
the other day it was the low tyre pressure, fixed that then the windscreen got a chip in it

gashart

123 posts

75 months

Tuesday 14th September 2021
quotequote all
Just weighing up the option of going desiel SD or petrol Cooper S on a first gen Countryman, just wondering how badly the petrol engines are effected with the change to E10 fuel?

E-bmw

9,186 posts

152 months

Tuesday 14th September 2021
quotequote all
gashart said:
just wondering how badly the petrol engines are effected with the change to E10 fuel?
The earlier engines are E10 compatible, so I would expect them to be also, you can always check online.

SHIFTY

889 posts

236 months

Tuesday 14th September 2021
quotequote all
Should be a sticker on the back of the filler opening, wife's Mini has E5, E10 and E25.

gashart

123 posts

75 months

Wednesday 15th September 2021
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies, we brought a Cooper SD last night, seems in very good nick and low milage, so misses well happy

bennno

11,584 posts

269 months

Wednesday 15th September 2021
quotequote all

Buy one with as small wheels as possible as the ride is awful.

XMified

676 posts

72 months

Tuesday 21st September 2021
quotequote all
My wife seems set on a Countryman of some sort. Definitely mk1 as these are in budget. Auto only.

As it will be mostly shorter journeys I am pushing for a petrol.

There's been some good advice here, is the fuel pump issue that common with the Cooper S?

My wife is the sort that reacts to those types of issue as a sign of "unreliability" (maybe she's right) so I am trying to (gently) educate her on these automotive facts of life biggrin.





XMified

676 posts

72 months

Tuesday 21st September 2021
quotequote all
bennno said:
Buy one with as small wheels as possible as the ride is awful.
Really that bad? Do tell.

bern

1,262 posts

220 months

Tuesday 21st September 2021
quotequote all
We're away in our cooper D for a few nights. It's a good car in many ways, tons of interior space for starters, but the engine is a complete anchor of a thing. And the gear change is ste. A mini should be fun to drive above all else, unfortunately the drivetrain in ours ruins it.

Still, it looks pretty funky and my wife likes it!


peter2704

Original Poster:

237 posts

208 months

Tuesday 21st September 2021
quotequote all
got he wife a cooper S countryman ,as she felt the freelander 2 was getting to big for her.
the fuel pump and clutch had been done by the previous owner,the timing chain i got replaced as a precaution (the old one was fine).so i pray for trouble free motoring for a while,ride is harsh on runflats ,my 3 series was the same, so these will be changed in the future.As a family car its great and looks cool,not the most economical but we dont do long journeys,just keep an eye on the oil levels,they are tricky to check correctly,ours was burning oil but oil stems seals replaced under warranty

bennno

11,584 posts

269 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2021
quotequote all
XMified said:
bennno said:
Buy one with as small wheels as possible as the ride is awful.
Really that bad? Do tell.
It’s truly awful, on runflat 18’s it’s about as crashy and unrefined as cars get. Fine for Europe less good for our roads.

A shame as it could have long travel suspension and glide given its high riding stance. However it’s a standard mini underneath.

Mr Peel

478 posts

122 months

Friday 24th September 2021
quotequote all
My 2012 S is on 18s. Swapped the runflats for Pilot Sports which has helped the ride a bit and stopped it tramlining. Still very much an old-school Mini in terms of ride quality though.

Mine is also lowered 30mm on Eibach springs, which gives it a much more Mini-lke stance.

These are good family cars - and a decent drive when sorted - but definitely need to be thought of as a big Mini, not a comfy crossover.

bennno

11,584 posts

269 months

Friday 24th September 2021
quotequote all
Mr Peel said:
My 2012 S is on 18s. Swapped the runflats for Pilot Sports which has helped the ride a bit and stopped it tramlining. Still very much an old-school Mini in terms of ride quality though.

Mine is also lowered 30mm on Eibach springs, which gives it a much more Mini-lke stance.

These are good family cars - and a decent drive when sorted - but definitely need to be thought of as a big Mini, not a comfy crossover.
Agreed. Its a big miss from mini on that basis, nothing to stop it going well but riding well with longer travel suspension to boot.

XMified

676 posts

72 months

Sunday 26th September 2021
quotequote all
Thanks all- she has gone for a R55 Clubman- actually has relatively elegant proportions and big tyres on 15" wheels. I am relieved that the Countryman phase was only that.

gashart

123 posts

75 months

Wednesday 29th September 2021
quotequote all
As mentioned before, the wife brought a 2011 countryman Cooper SD, its on 18" wheels, but luckily Not run flats.
So had it a week or so, she loves it, I drove it for a 200 mile round trip for a family get together on Sunday, 4 up with the surprisingly large boot also full. Everyone was very comfortable, rode well, and handled very well i thought, mpg was about mid 50's and generally big thumbs up from us.