What’s the best career, being a Doctor or Pilot?

What’s the best career, being a Doctor or Pilot?

Author
Discussion

Routemaster93

Original Poster:

100 posts

88 months

Thursday 22nd February 2018
quotequote all
What is the best career choice between being a Doctor or Airline pilot?

I know the training for both is very expensive. At least £35,000 to train as a pilot and almost £50,000 to train as a Doctor (with nearly £10,000 tuition fees each year for 5 years).

Please give reasons as to which career is most rewarding.

randlemarcus

13,522 posts

231 months

Thursday 22nd February 2018
quotequote all
Honestly, neither.

Doctor is rapidly becoming teacher status, I.e. not hugely respected professional.

Commercial pilots, taxis with wings, and most salaries are less than you would want for a hundred grand investment.

Vet (longer training than a doctor, but no PI insurance), architect?

Monkeylegend

26,386 posts

231 months

Thursday 22nd February 2018
quotequote all
Flying doctor, best of both worlds, or maybe the worst.

m3jappa

6,425 posts

218 months

Thursday 22nd February 2018
quotequote all
cosmetic Dentist is the one. Open your own practice and watch the £ roll in. Well thats what it looks like to the layman anyway.

I asked my dentist why teeth implants are so expensive.

She said, 'well, you have to do a course, thats 40k, then my public liability will go up by at least another thousand a year'

I sat there as a paving company and thought, well my plant and equipment has cost me 60k, my public liability and other insurances are knocking on for over 3k a year.

It was at that moment i realised why i shouldn't have fked about in school, smoked loads of weed and basically treated it all as a joke. I don't do bad but I'm not earning anything serious. I also have a fked body after years of hard work, lots of general worries and stress too. They even charge to tell you how much they are going to charge to put new teeth in hehe

I know it takes several years to become qualified but thats no different to becoming a tradesman, it also takes years to gain experience which can warrant you charging any reasonable amount of money in order to make a living.

Im also very aware that the vast majority of dentists are more intelligent than the vast majority of trades but still, maybe i should have paid attention earlier on hehe

valiant

10,219 posts

160 months

Thursday 22nd February 2018
quotequote all
But you're staring into people's manky gobs all day, every day.

Hmmm, is that last night's curry I can smell Mr Smith? Nice!

No ta.

Badda

2,668 posts

82 months

Thursday 22nd February 2018
quotequote all
randlemarcus said:
Doctor is rapidly becoming teacher status, I.e. not hugely respected professional.
Biggest load of balls I've read on here for a while!

Ari

19,347 posts

215 months

Thursday 22nd February 2018
quotequote all
Perhaps I’m being naive, but I’d have thought both careers would require a keen interest and aptitude, rather than which pays best and has the best working conditions.

Surely careers like this are ones you choose out of a passion? It’s not like choosing to sell cars rather than mobile phones because you get a free demo. Or is it..?

BoRED S2upid

19,700 posts

240 months

Thursday 22nd February 2018
quotequote all
Badda said:
randlemarcus said:
Doctor is rapidly becoming teacher status, I.e. not hugely respected professional.
Biggest load of balls I've read on here for a while!
It’s bigger than that! It’s laughable the crap people post on here.

My mates a GP at 40 he’s semi retired works a few days a month the crap shiftsnobody wants 12hour shift in a walk in clinic in a hospital or covers at short notice when one calls in sick he’s living the dream.

That said I’m sure there are pilots out there living equal dreams working very few hours ferrying the rich around in their private jets. It’s not all easy jet stuff to Tenerife.

For both you have to start somewhere though it’s going to be a hard few years to get experience but that’s the same in most jobs.

I’d pick doctor though but I’m not clever enough I was in detention and in set 2 when my mate was in set 1 he’s probably never been thrown out of a class in his life.

m3jappa

6,425 posts

218 months

Thursday 22nd February 2018
quotequote all
valiant said:
But you're staring into people's manky gobs all day, every day.

Hmmm, is that last night's curry I can smell Mr Smith? Nice!

No ta.
not that it happens every day but i see what the proceeds of last nights dinner look like when we deal with their drainage hehe

I would always prefer first hand to second hand :haha:

alorotom

11,939 posts

187 months

Thursday 22nd February 2018
quotequote all
GP world is changing drastically I wouldn’t recommend this at all

Pilot or Vet are good calls but the former you need to be prepared to work for crappy airlines in Malaysia etc... to get your hours in before getting a shot at a decent role with a decent airline

glazbagun

14,279 posts

197 months

Thursday 22nd February 2018
quotequote all
Might be an urban legend, but isn't dentistry the worst profession for suicides?

m3jappa

6,425 posts

218 months

Thursday 22nd February 2018
quotequote all
glazbagun said:
Might be an urban legend, but isn't dentistry the worst profession for suicides?
Maybe, the very pretty young woman dentist was visibly repulsed when she had to endure looking into my mouth the other day hehe Im not sure she could take much more as i was swiftly ushered out.

pushthebutton

1,097 posts

182 months

Thursday 22nd February 2018
quotequote all
I think that the top Doctors - private cosmetic (?) - would significantly out earn the top earning pilots. However, the average may favour being a pilot and, potentially, there is the opportunity to earn a greater amount at a younger age. That's all anecdotal so could easily be rubbish.

In terms of being non-financially rewarding, I can only speak about being a pilot and if you treat it as a job and embrace the positive aspects, then it's great. If you're looking for it to define your being and give your life a sense of purpose then it'll fall short. I've seen, and continue to see, people become bitter and cynical as they're unable to maintain a sense of perspective and have too much emotion invested in the vocation.

LosingGrip

7,818 posts

159 months

Thursday 22nd February 2018
quotequote all
Surely the best career is one that you enjoy? I don't like blood/sick people, so a doctor would be hell for me. I also don't like heights. I'm fine in a plane if I can't see out, but flying the thing? Nah I'll pass.

mattnovak

335 posts

102 months

Thursday 22nd February 2018
quotequote all
An acquaintance is a pilot, and my wife is a Doctor. Medicine for the win.

dingg

3,989 posts

219 months

Thursday 22nd February 2018
quotequote all
Mates son is a pilot now working for dragon airline in hk , don't think its 'all that' tbh and he had to work for eastern for quite a while on not too good money before he got the far east post , suppose he's on better than average salary for a 34 year old and its only going to get better.

my wifes bil is a neurosurgeon , just qualified to consultant level at 40 , been a long road on not tremendous money and all sorts of mental shift hrs working , a very long slog to get where he is but should turn out well.

Pilot pips it for me , less stress , quicker progression , otoh it must be good to be able to help people through traumatic times but most of the times he's dealing with brain injuries which are life changing for the patient and family (depression could be a real concern)

Yipper

5,964 posts

90 months

Thursday 22nd February 2018
quotequote all
Civil pilot = staring out the window while the plane flies itself.

Doctor = sticking your finger up someone's rusty badge at 9am on a rainy Monday.

Dentist = poking around in blood and pus 6 hours a day.

A judge is a good shout. You're almost always the top man and don't do a massive amount of hours once you have your feet under the table.

Badda

2,668 posts

82 months

Friday 23rd February 2018
quotequote all
Yipper said:
Civil pilot = staring out the window while the plane flies itself.

Doctor = sticking your finger up someone's rusty badge at 9am on a rainy Monday.

Dentist = poking around in blood and pus 6 hours a day.

A judge is a good shout. You're almost always the top man and don't do a massive amount of hours once you have your feet under the table.
ttbot's usual uneducated but highly opinionated bks!

Yipper, why don't you tell us how to become a judge then...and how much it pays..

HOGEPH

5,249 posts

186 months

Friday 23rd February 2018
quotequote all
Pilot career dependent on passing a medical every six months.

LimaDelta

6,520 posts

218 months

Friday 23rd February 2018
quotequote all
If you have to ask, then probably neither.

For me personally, I spend a lot of my own money living out my fighter pilot fantasies, while on the other hand you could not pay me enough to be a Doctor (unless in a very unusual role which didn't involve any contact with the general public).

Two very different vocations to which you are either called, or not.