F10 M5 and rivals

F10 M5 and rivals

Author
Discussion

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

198 months

Monday 19th February 2018
quotequote all
Is the consensus that these really have to be run with a warranty?


These cars are getting older now lots trumptons is 6years old for example.

At what point is it safe to “risk it”?

Wills2

22,804 posts

175 months

Monday 19th February 2018
quotequote all
I would suggest the op tries another as it shouldn't be jittery.


lord trumpton

7,392 posts

126 months

Monday 19th February 2018
quotequote all
Welshbeef said:
Is the consensus that these really have to be run with a warranty?


These cars are getting older now lots trumptons is 6years old for example.

At what point is it safe to “risk it”?
It depends. Mine had been extended so I took that over.

Personally given the research very little goes wrong.

Mine had a few things sorted under warranty by prev owner - a replacement brake caliper as it was sticking, and some Idrive/transmission reflash.

I've got a car related business and am good friends with a BMW indy and from what he said they are very reliable indeed. Obviously I'd stay away from remapped cars and high owner cars just as a precaution.

Also FBMWSH a must if you want to take up a BMW warranty or get any goodwill contributions

ETA - of course make sure the RI service was done and on time!

Edited by lord trumpton on Monday 19th February 08:56

lord trumpton

7,392 posts

126 months

Monday 19th February 2018
quotequote all

snowley

183 posts

126 months

Monday 19th February 2018
quotequote all
I have also just jumped into F10 m5 ownership and am very impressed.

Looked at the main competitors, but kept coming back to the m5. The engine is astonishing the way it revs and builds power, and for a modern large car has decent steering feel.

I managed to negotiate 2 years warranty and some servicing as an AUC, so pretty happy with it.

My research tells me they are reliable cars, but the fear of a huge bill made me by AUC (and there isn't a large premium to go this route either at the moment).

Robbidoo

240 posts

167 months

Monday 19th February 2018
quotequote all
On a 4 year old car the AUC warranty can be extended for about £1,200, just to give some idea.

I just jumped on the F10 bandwagon also, on a facelift 2014 car. It has a couple of dings to be removed and alloys to be refurbished first so I won't be in it until the end of the month.


Welshbeef

49,633 posts

198 months

Monday 19th February 2018
quotequote all
Robbidoo said:
On a 4 year old car the AUC warranty can be extended for about £1,200, just to give some idea.

I just jumped on the F10 bandwagon also, on a facelift 2014 car. It has a couple of dings to be removed and alloys to be refurbished first so I won't be in it until the end of the month.
Is this the one for sale at Reading Cooper BMW?

Robbidoo

240 posts

167 months

Monday 19th February 2018
quotequote all
No, Park Lane. It's in Pure Metal Silver.

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

198 months

Monday 19th February 2018
quotequote all
Robbidoo said:
No, Park Lane. It's in Pure Metal Silver.
I’ve been looking from the 139k mike one for c£20k up to £40k so can see all these in detail - there are not many around.

Plus given Autocars video about it being £25k then there is going to be a lot of petrol heads pouring over these (same as myself).

tjlazer

Original Poster:

875 posts

174 months

Monday 19th February 2018
quotequote all
Well in answer to my own question, there really is only one answer...M5. Picking up next week, went AUC with the Dick Lovett's car. Got a great deal and with the mileage I do (5k ish) I doubt I'll lose much even if I trade in a couple of years. Realised I'd test driven the car in all out sport plus which explains alot. Looking forward to getting to know the M properly now. Already have some mods lined up, dechrome, exhaust flaps and reverse cam. They are subtle though, I sent a picture to my friend and he was very concerned I'd gone soft. Fortunately the engine bay says otherwise.

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

198 months

Monday 19th February 2018
quotequote all
tjlazer said:
Well in answer to my own question, there really is only one answer...M5. Picking up next week, went AUC with the Dick Lovett's car. Got a great deal and with the mileage I do (5k ish) I doubt I'll lose much even if I trade in a couple of years. Realised I'd test driven the car in all out sport plus which explains alot. Looking forward to getting to know the M properly now. Already have some mods lined up, dechrome, exhaust flaps and reverse cam. They are subtle though, I sent a picture to my friend and he was very concerned I'd gone soft. Fortunately the engine bay says otherwise.
Why do people de Crome a vehicle? It certainly then looks unusual as in modified vs OEM which unless you knew looks like so many other 5 series Cars.

Lol exhaust flaps - watch out if you have an early start as it will disturb the neighbours ( what DB are these when modified in that way?)

Wills2

22,804 posts

175 months

Monday 19th February 2018
quotequote all
M5 looks good de chromed, grilles are available from the M performance range and the supplying dealer will match the side gills if you ask they just remove and unpick the chrome trim and spray gloss black.

Looks smart.

tjlazer

Original Poster:

875 posts

174 months

Monday 19th February 2018
quotequote all
Welshbeef said:
tjlazer said:
Well in answer to my own question, there really is only one answer...M5. Picking up next week, went AUC with the Dick Lovett's car. Got a great deal and with the mileage I do (5k ish) I doubt I'll lose much even if I trade in a couple of years. Realised I'd test driven the car in all out sport plus which explains alot. Looking forward to getting to know the M properly now. Already have some mods lined up, dechrome, exhaust flaps and reverse cam. They are subtle though, I sent a picture to my friend and he was very concerned I'd gone soft. Fortunately the engine bay says otherwise.
Why do people de Crome a vehicle? It certainly then looks unusual as in modified vs OEM which unless you knew looks like so many other 5 series Cars.

Lol exhaust flaps - watch out if you have an early start as it will disturb the neighbours ( what DB are these when modified in that way?)
Black is best. Chrome makes me think of gold taps and st like that. Hate any silver bits personally and I think gloss black and Silverstone will look rather tasty and, as it will be my car, that's all that matters! I have an unbaffled motorbike I used for my commute but at least I can wheel it down the road, they'll just have to enjoy the morning rollcall when I take the M!

Patrick Bateman

12,180 posts

174 months

Monday 19th February 2018
quotequote all
Are running costs not quite e60 levels of scary?

Wills2

22,804 posts

175 months

Monday 19th February 2018
quotequote all
Patrick Bateman said:
Are running costs not quite e60 levels of scary?
It's thirsty and likes tyres but not much else brakes are expensive I guess.

Patrick Bateman

12,180 posts

174 months

Monday 19th February 2018
quotequote all
To clarify, I wasn't meaning general wear and tear maintenance.

More the god-tier levels of bork the S85 and SMG can dish out.

lord trumpton

7,392 posts

126 months

Monday 19th February 2018
quotequote all
Patrick Bateman said:
To clarify, I wasn't meaning general wear and tear maintenance.

More the god-tier levels of bork the S85 and SMG can dish out.
According the Munich legends comments in the EVO buyers guide I linked earlier in the thread they are as good as gold

Patrick Bateman

12,180 posts

174 months

Monday 19th February 2018
quotequote all
lord trumpton said:
According the Munich legends comments in the EVO buyers guide I linked earlier in the thread they are as good as gold
It's interesting that you don't often hear about major DCT issues, certainly nothing like a lot of the SMG gearboxes.

All handy to know though when they're worth half of what they are now...

Wills2

22,804 posts

175 months

Monday 19th February 2018
quotequote all
Patrick Bateman said:
To clarify, I wasn't meaning general wear and tear maintenance.

More the god-tier levels of bork the S85 and SMG can dish out.
Very robust powertrain engine is unstressed at 560 from a twin turbo 4.4. DCT is strong I've done over 100k with that box with zero issues same with the electronically controlled LSD.


anonymous-user

54 months

Monday 19th February 2018
quotequote all
I had a minor DCT issue in the F80 M3. It took two BMW dealers to diagnose and both the techs said they get lots of issues on bits and pieces, but the DCT boxes give little or no hassle.