BBMF Spitfire incident at Coningsby
Discussion
Simpo Two said:
Fuel blockage, engine lost power, pilot attempted to regain runway and stalled in. The same temptation has killed a great many pilots over the years.
To be fair the engine didn't lose all power at first, just enough to indicate something wasn't right. Then seems to have lost more power at a bad moment. There's a discussion on Pprune about how tricky a decision it is when an engine hasn't actually failed yet. Especially with the complication of being responsible for a historically significant aircraft.Austin Prefect said:
Simpo Two said:
Fuel blockage, engine lost power, pilot attempted to regain runway and stalled in. The same temptation has killed a great many pilots over the years.
To be fair the engine didn't lose all power at first, just enough to indicate something wasn't right. Then seems to have lost more power at a bad moment. There's a discussion on Pprune about how tricky a decision it is when an engine hasn't actually failed yet. Especially with the complication of being responsible for a historically significant aircraft.I think he said that if he had reacted to the first splutter he could have made the airfield, but it cleared, and the next splutter meant he was going down in a field.
borcy said:
It was interesting reading the difference between those flying them in WW2 and now regarding engine failure. Now it's more aimed at getting it back to an airfield, but then it was get it down in a field asap or bail out.
It makes me wonder whether it was an instinctive desire to get back to the runway, or the awareness that he was in something worth (according to Google) £2-4M and didn't want to damage it in a forced landing. Very little time to think and no second chance unfortunately.Simpo Two said:
borcy said:
It was interesting reading the difference between those flying them in WW2 and now regarding engine failure. Now it's more aimed at getting it back to an airfield, but then it was get it down in a field asap or bail out.
It makes me wonder whether it was an instinctive desire to get back to the runway, or the awareness that he was in something worth (according to Google) £2-4M and didn't want to damage it in a forced landing. Very little time to think and no second chance unfortunately.I guess the wartime calculation was simpler - we needed planes and pilots desperately but pilots were in shorter supply so there was no conflict even at the ££££ level. Saving pilots came before saving planes. Noone was sentimental about an individual Spitfire in 1940.
mac96 said:
Simpo Two said:
borcy said:
It was interesting reading the difference between those flying them in WW2 and now regarding engine failure. Now it's more aimed at getting it back to an airfield, but then it was get it down in a field asap or bail out.
It makes me wonder whether it was an instinctive desire to get back to the runway, or the awareness that he was in something worth (according to Google) £2-4M and didn't want to damage it in a forced landing. Very little time to think and no second chance unfortunately.I guess the wartime calculation was simpler - we needed planes and pilots desperately but pilots were in shorter supply so there was no conflict even at the ££££ level. Saving pilots came before saving planes. Noone was sentimental about an individual Spitfire in 1940.
There's even a recommendation based on this aspect.
The value of the aircraft should be irrelevant and it is here as literal new spitfires can be knitted around a serial number; the squishy flesh thing inside is much more easily damaged and the cemetery filled with pilots who thought they could turn back to the airfield they just left is very large.
pingu393 said:
Austin Prefect said:
Simpo Two said:
Fuel blockage, engine lost power, pilot attempted to regain runway and stalled in. The same temptation has killed a great many pilots over the years.
To be fair the engine didn't lose all power at first, just enough to indicate something wasn't right. Then seems to have lost more power at a bad moment. There's a discussion on Pprune about how tricky a decision it is when an engine hasn't actually failed yet. Especially with the complication of being responsible for a historically significant aircraft.I think he said that if he had reacted to the first splutter he could have made the airfield, but it cleared, and the next splutter meant he was going down in a field.
dr_gn said:
pingu393 said:
I recall something similar happened to a Spitfire pilot who belly landed in a field near Duxford.
I think he said that if he had reacted to the first splutter he could have made the airfield, but it cleared, and the next splutter meant he was going down in a field.
Pretty sure that was a Mustang. Sounds very similar.I think he said that if he had reacted to the first splutter he could have made the airfield, but it cleared, and the next splutter meant he was going down in a field.

hidetheelephants said:
The value of the aircraft should be irrelevant and it is here as literal new spitfires can be knitted around a serial number; the squishy flesh thing inside is much more easily damaged and the cemetery filled with pilots who thought they could turn back to the airfield they just left is very large.
You're absolutely right, but that requires crystal clear logical thinking, and when you're responsible for a multi-million pound irreplaceable aeroplane and the engine has just unexpectedly cut out after take-off, it's not an ideal time for it. That makes me think of the test pilot mentality, when you *expect* the engine might cut out and have a plan already formed to implement without thinking. The pilot here did have the brain space to send a Mayday call; we can all be armchair pilots of course but I think that bit of processing power would have been better spent getting down alive. 'Aviate navigate communicate' etc. But yes, we are all human, and this poor chap had only one chance and very few seconds to call it.I was at Stow Maries a few months ago; our guide described the fate of a WW1 pilot who experienced exactly the same thing, and to this day there's a gap in the trees.
Simpo Two said:
hidetheelephants said:
The value of the aircraft should be irrelevant and it is here as literal new spitfires can be knitted around a serial number; the squishy flesh thing inside is much more easily damaged and the cemetery filled with pilots who thought they could turn back to the airfield they just left is very large.
You're absolutely right, but that requires crystal clear logical thinking, and when you're responsible for a multi-million pound irreplaceable aeroplane and the engine has just unexpectedly cut out after take-off, it's not an ideal time for it. That makes me think of the test pilot mentality, when you *expect* the engine might cut out and have a plan already formed to implement without thinking. The pilot here did have the brain space to send a Mayday call; we can all be armchair pilots of course but I think that bit of processing power would have been better spent getting down alive. 'Aviate navigate communicate' etc. But yes, we are all human, and this poor chap had only one chance and very few seconds to call it.I was at Stow Maries a few months ago; our guide described the fate of a WW1 pilot who experienced exactly the same thing, and to this day there's a gap in the trees.
Yes it's not the same and there are less options left for the Spitfire pilot. But gliding experience always helps.
Simpo Two said:
hidetheelephants said:
The value of the aircraft should be irrelevant and it is here as literal new spitfires can be knitted around a serial number; the squishy flesh thing inside is much more easily damaged and the cemetery filled with pilots who thought they could turn back to the airfield they just left is very large.
You're absolutely right, but that requires crystal clear logical thinking, and when you're responsible for a multi-million pound irreplaceable aeroplane and the engine has just unexpectedly cut out after take-off, it's not an ideal time for it. That makes me think of the test pilot mentality, when you *expect* the engine might cut out and have a plan already formed to implement without thinking. The pilot here did have the brain space to send a Mayday call; we can all be armchair pilots of course but I think that bit of processing power would have been better spent getting down alive. 'Aviate navigate communicate' etc. But yes, we are all human, and this poor chap had only one chance and very few seconds to call it.I was at Stow Maries a few months ago; our guide described the fate of a WW1 pilot who experienced exactly the same thing, and to this day there's a gap in the trees.
One was aboard when the Lanc lost an engine a few years back. I remember talking to him in the bar a few days later. I can guarantee they are all accurately aware of what they are being entrusted with. It must go through any one of there minds when they are in an emergency situation. It’s impossible not to. I would bet Sqn Ldr Long would have been more concerned with destroying a spitfire than a typhoon.
Gassing Station | Boats, Planes & Trains | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff

