Calorie question

Author
Discussion

Gaz413823

Original Poster:

55 posts

123 months

Friday 21st September 2018
quotequote all
Out of a choice of breakfasts , which has the most calories and which can be considered the most healthy?
Option 1:
4 pieces of toast (wholemeal bread, usually how is super seeded) with margarine and jam.

Option 2:
Around 100-150 g of plain quark and a handful of plain simple granola mixed with raisins and nuts . Does adding dried fruit such as banana slices etc make much difference to the calorie count ?

Truckosaurus

11,278 posts

284 months

Friday 21st September 2018
quotequote all
I vote more calories in brekkie 2 as granola is surprisingly bad for you and full of sugar, as is dried fruit (compared to raw fruit).

zygalski

7,759 posts

145 months

Friday 21st September 2018
quotequote all
Erm why not just eat a no added sugar muesli?

cqueen

2,620 posts

220 months

Friday 21st September 2018
quotequote all
You're considerably better off with bacon & eggs.

Gaz413823

Original Poster:

55 posts

123 months

Friday 21st September 2018
quotequote all
Thanks , I had my suspicions about the granola and dried fruit. I mostly have the toast and jam and although i assume its a carb and sugar fest I find it fuels me well and I stay pretty lean . However I eat a lot of bread , potatoes , rice and pasta and was looking to cut down a little on these. I tried switching to the granola and found it left me looking a bit bloated and I could also run out of energy quite suddenly by mid afternoon.

bomb

3,692 posts

284 months

Friday 21st September 2018
quotequote all
cqueen said:
You're considerably better off with bacon & eggs.
This is correct. Eggs are quick and easy to prepare - Scrambled really quick in a microwave / Fried / poached / omelette. Mushrooms very low carb too, so an ideal breakfast if you want to avoid sugars and carbs.

Lozw86

874 posts

132 months

Friday 21st September 2018
quotequote all
Low kcal does not equal “healthy”, it’s just a unit to measure energy content

Look at the packaging if you want to know the kcal content of each option

227bhp

10,203 posts

128 months

Friday 21st September 2018
quotequote all
bomb said:
cqueen said:
You're considerably better off with bacon & eggs.
This is correct. Eggs are quick and easy to prepare - Scrambled really quick in a microwave / Fried / poached / omelette. Mushrooms very low carb too, so an ideal breakfast if you want to avoid sugars and carbs.
Bacon is processed meat which is not good for you.

Bill

52,747 posts

255 months

Saturday 22nd September 2018
quotequote all
Gaz413823 said:
Thanks , I had my suspicions about the granola and dried fruit. I mostly have the toast and jam and although i assume its a carb and sugar fest I find it fuels me well and I stay pretty lean . However I eat a lot of bread , potatoes , rice and pasta and was looking to cut down a little on these. I tried switching to the granola and found it left me looking a bit bloated and I could also run out of energy quite suddenly by mid afternoon.
Have you tried eating lunch?

ambuletz

10,734 posts

181 months

Saturday 22nd September 2018
quotequote all
Gaz413823 said:
Out of a choice of breakfasts , which has the most calories and which can be considered the most healthy?
Option 1:
4 pieces of toast (wholemeal bread, usually how is super seeded) with margarine and jam.

Option 2:
Around 100-150 g of plain quark and a handful of plain simple granola mixed with raisins and nuts . Does adding dried fruit such as banana slices etc make much difference to the calorie count ?
well it depends. so you're just going to have to download an app like myfitnesspal, scan the barcode and put in the weight/measurements of whatever you're eating and find out.

a slice of bread can very anywhere from 60-130 cals depending on it's size and thickness. so that's anywhere from 240-520cals. jam/butter is highly calorie dense so it depends on how much you put on.

taking a tub of asda fat free quark 100-150g works out as 68-102cals. handful of granola...we all have different opinions on what is a handful, so again, how much does that handufl weigh? dried fruit is again a calorie dense food, so it all depends.

As for which is healthy, that's largely subjective. healthy is too broad a term and depends on what your goals are.

Badda

2,668 posts

82 months

Saturday 22nd September 2018
quotequote all
227bhp said:
bomb said:
cqueen said:
You're considerably better off with bacon & eggs.
This is correct. Eggs are quick and easy to prepare - Scrambled really quick in a microwave / Fried / poached / omelette. Mushrooms very low carb too, so an ideal breakfast if you want to avoid sugars and carbs.
Bacon is processed meat which is not good for you.
There’s going to be a lot of keto types regretting their choice later in life I reckon.

OP - if you’re worried about calories, maybe don’t have FOUR slices of toast!

Gaz413823

Original Poster:

55 posts

123 months

Saturday 22nd September 2018
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies , some good poihts made , I think someone said why have four pieces of toast and ambuletz said it depends what your goals are.
I don’t really have any goals ,most days I’m at the gym , running , spinning or swimming . I have always been active but used to eat rubbish , changing my diet from takeaways , pizzas and cutting down on crisps , chocolate and fizzy drinks I’ve gone from nearly 15 stone to 10.5stone and have maintained this for a few years .
I find keeping the weight off , I have to be strict , I have to be disciplined, and I find it hard to eat enough to fuel the exercise and stay lean and just feel that it’s easy to pile junk down and so would like to find a few healthier options. My main meal on a night is usually a load of steamed veg , baked potato and a tin of tuna, through the day I have breakfast and a sandwich at 12:30 plus a banana at 8:ish and 4:30. Fridays and weekends tend be huge roast dinners and cake
To sum up , I find it hard to eat so that I’m not bloating and putting some timber on or flaking out exhausted , and feel that breakfast is a good place to start improving things