2017 Election Result - a PH poll

2017 Election Result - a PH poll

Poll: 2017 Election Result - a PH poll

Total Members Polled: 395

Tory - agree with what stand for: 61%
Tory - wouldn't usually, only credible option: 14%
Labour - not put off by Corbyn, will be great: 4%
Labour - don't like Corbyn, can't vote others: 3%
UKIP - agree with what stand for: 2%
UKIP - don't trust May to deliver brexit: 1%
Lib Dem - agree with what stand for: 3%
Lib Dem - brexit protest, hope coalition: 8%
None of the above: 3%
Author
Discussion

Wobbegong

15,077 posts

169 months

Saturday 22nd April 2017
quotequote all
Conservatives because we need a PM with some backbone for Brexit. The other 'leaders' would simply ask the EU what they want. Just glad Cameron ran away, imagine the choice of PM then? eek

Brexit is happening whether we agree with it or not. What we cannot afford is a weak leader in negotiations.

confused_buyer

6,613 posts

181 months

Saturday 22nd April 2017
quotequote all
///ajd said:
You may well be right.

It will be interesting to see if the LibDems can coral an effective "anti-hard brexit" vote - they'll be held back by Farrons personality unfortunately.
I think they'll do OK but if the surveys are to be believed Bexit is only a defining issue with about 15% of the electorate and half of them will be for Leave.

They might lose seats as well. Take Southport as an example. They have a majority over the Tories of just 1322 votes but there were 7429 votes for UKIP. If they go to the Tories the LibDems may struggle to hold on. There is a similar story in Carshalton (LibDem majority of 1500 but 7000 UKIP votes) and even Norman Lamb in Norfolk may have a majority of 4000 but there are 8000 UKIP votes there as well.

Efbe

9,251 posts

166 months

Saturday 22nd April 2017
quotequote all
technodup said:
sidicks said:
Efbe said:
I vote almost entirely on what the parties will do for the NHS and Education. I bear no allegiance to any party.
I care not about taxation, or defense, or the policies aimed for the illiterate are retarded, i.e. immigration, religion, benefits etc
So in summary, you like "shiny things" but have no interest in whether (or by who) they can be paid for)?

You sound like the ideal Labour voter!!
Yep, possibly the most retarded view I've ever seen expressed here.

And I've read JawKnee.
"I care not about taxation" does not mean I don't like being taxed, it means I don't care if they increase the 40% rate, or reduce the threshold for it.

"I care not for taxation" would give the meaning you seem to be looking for.

Oilchange

8,452 posts

260 months

Sunday 23rd April 2017
quotequote all
more reading between the lines I think

RegMolehusband

3,960 posts

257 months

Sunday 23rd April 2017
quotequote all
There isn't an option for "none of the above" which is currently what I'm considering spoiling my voting slip with.

As a Conservative voter, they've now moved too far to the left for me with their tax increases. They no longer represent me.

I won't be able to claim mortgage interest as a cost on the house from which I get rental income, even though this isn't a BTL house but my ex-marital home. Yet somebody setting up a limited company to manage their BTL properties will be able to do so. Crazy.

Osborne changed the long-standing method by which my small company's dividends are taxed, costing me considerably more, and then the idiot Hammond extended this in the last budget whilst naively attacking the self-employed with his NI increase, which he had to back down from of course. The change in dividend taxation will also hit core Conservative voters amongst the retired who depend upon dividend income.

They have shown their colours and I believe they will tax these sectors further. At the moment, I couldn't bring myself to vote for them, and there are no viable options.



Edited by RegMolehusband on Sunday 23 April 10:30

///ajd

Original Poster:

8,964 posts

206 months

Sunday 23rd April 2017
quotequote all
RegMolehusband said:
There isn't an option for "none of the above" which is currently what I'm considering spoiling my voting slip with.

As a Conservative voter, they've now moved too far to the left for me with their tax increases. They no longer represent me.

I won't be able to claim mortgage interest as a cost on the house from which I get rental income, even though this isn't a BTL house but my ex-marital home. Yet somebody setting up a limited company to manage their BTL properties will be able to do so. Crazy.

Osborne changed the long-standing method by which my small company's dividends are taxed, costing me considerably more, and then the idiot Hammond extended this in the last budget whilst naively attacking the self-employed with his NI increase, which he had to back down from of course. The change in dividend taxation will also hit core Conservative voters amongst the retired who depend upon dividend income.

They have shown their colours and I believe they will tax these sectors further. At the moment, I couldn't bring myself to vote for them, and there are no viable options.



Edited by RegMolehusband on Sunday 23 April 10:30
You're right, I forgot that. Added now. Probably too late though, can you change vote?

RegMolehusband

3,960 posts

257 months

Sunday 23rd April 2017
quotequote all
Unfortunately I can't vote in your poll now as I clicked "skip voting" biggrin

andy43

9,687 posts

254 months

Sunday 23rd April 2017
quotequote all
Wobbegong said:
Brexit is happening whether we agree with it or not. What we cannot afford is a weak leader in negotiations.
That sums up my view - we aren't voting for a PM, we're voting for somebody who can negotiate - with the current choices there is only one option.
Fallon/Corbyn look completely unsuitable, regardless of the bonus of extra bank holidays rolleyes

jmorgan

36,010 posts

284 months

Sunday 23rd April 2017
quotequote all
Gone for Coby. Dead cert. He will be great for the country.

anonymous-user

54 months

Sunday 23rd April 2017
quotequote all
andy43 said:
That sums up my view - we aren't voting for a PM, we're voting for somebody who can negotiate - with the current choices there is only one option.
Fallon/Corbyn look completely unsuitable, regardless of the bonus of extra bank holidays rolleyes
Surely no one actually believes that the British PM, whoever it is, will be the person sitting across the table day in, day out, negotiating the fine detail of our exit and ongoing relationship. The PM leads the team that sets the agenda, not the team that does the grunt work.

Pesty

42,655 posts

256 months

Sunday 23rd April 2017
quotequote all
RegMolehusband said:
There isn't an option for "none of the above" which is currently what I'm considering spoiling my voting slip with.

As a Conservative voter, they've now moved too far to the left for me with their tax increases. They no longer represent me.

I won't be able to claim mortgage interest as a cost on the house from which I get rental income, even though this isn't a BTL house but my ex-marital home. Yet somebody setting up a limited company to manage their BTL properties will be able to do so. Crazy.

Osborne changed the long-standing method by which my small company's dividends are taxed, costing me considerably more, and then the idiot Hammond extended this in the last budget whilst naively attacking the self-employed with his NI increase, which he had to back down from of course. The change in dividend taxation will also hit core Conservative voters amongst the retired who depend upon dividend income.

They have shown their colours and I believe they will tax these sectors further. At the moment, I couldn't bring myself to vote for them, and there are no viable options.



Edited by RegMolehusband on Sunday 23 April 10:30
the problem you have it seems to me is ( and I agree with you) if you don't vote for left wing Conservative party you get communist labour under Corbin which would be a disaster.


powerstroke

10,283 posts

160 months

Sunday 23rd April 2017
quotequote all
Greg66 said:
andy43 said:
That sums up my view - we aren't voting for a PM, we're voting for somebody who can negotiate - with the current choices there is only one option.
Fallon/Corbyn look completely unsuitable, regardless of the bonus of extra bank holidays rolleyes
Surely no one actually believes that the British PM, whoever it is, will be the person sitting across the table day in, day out, negotiating the fine detail of our exit and ongoing relationship. The PM leads the team that sets the agenda, not the team that does the grunt work.
I hope it will be elected people not a load of 3rd rate faceless gravy train riding pen pushers sorting this out !!!
people we can remove from office if they screw it up and land us with brexit light and a wooly deal that leaves us
still shackled to the EUSSR ....

wc98

10,378 posts

140 months

Sunday 23rd April 2017
quotequote all
i voted none of the above . will probably vote for a local independent candidate. was on the brink of voting conservative due to them being the least worse of the most incompetent self serving group of politicians the uk has ever had ,imo. fortunately i came to my senses due to a post by another ph'er in another forum that reminded why i tend to dislike the self centred mindset of many (not all)that rise to the the upper echelons of the tory party.

anonymous-user

54 months

Sunday 23rd April 2017
quotequote all
powerstroke said:
Greg66 said:
andy43 said:
That sums up my view - we aren't voting for a PM, we're voting for somebody who can negotiate - with the current choices there is only one option.
Fallon/Corbyn look completely unsuitable, regardless of the bonus of extra bank holidays rolleyes
Surely no one actually believes that the British PM, whoever it is, will be the person sitting across the table day in, day out, negotiating the fine detail of our exit and ongoing relationship. The PM leads the team that sets the agenda, not the team that does the grunt work.
I hope it will be elected people not a load of 3rd rate faceless gravy train riding pen pushers sorting this out !!!
people we can remove from office if they screw it up and land us with brexit light and a wooly deal that leaves us
still shackled to the EUSSR ....
I can pretty much guarantee that no one who's been elected to anything will be at the coal face of the negoatiations, because they will not have the skill set required for the job.

It is often said that the best compromise of an acrimonious negoition is an outcome that neither side is happy with. So prepared to be disappointed...

fido

16,796 posts

255 months

Sunday 23rd April 2017
quotequote all
jmorgan said:
Gone for Coby. Dead cert. He will be great for the country.
Have I missed a 'whoosh' parrot? laugh

jmorgan

36,010 posts

284 months

Sunday 23rd April 2017
quotequote all
fido said:
jmorgan said:
Gone for Coby. Dead cert. He will be great for the country.
Have I missed a 'whoosh' parrot? laugh
I will have you know I will not belittle our future leader. His transport subs based on old Trident subs is a stroke of genius to alleviate the transport to work crisis. Doubly so because the people will glow in the dark and not need safety clothing at night in the winter when the trudge to the docks.

Biker 1

7,724 posts

119 months

Sunday 23rd April 2017
quotequote all
The Spruce goose said:
can you add The Green Party to poll.
Why on earth would anybody in their right mind vote for that lot??????

Halb

53,012 posts

183 months

Sunday 23rd April 2017
quotequote all
Tough. MY current MP is a moron, I have talked to her a few times. She is labour, but I like JC...however I support Parliamentary democracy so I won't vote for the clot. I'll take a look at the rest, but most 'parties' are gangs of thugs. I don't see anyone reasonable getting through, I hope there is a decent independent.

Halb

53,012 posts

183 months

Sunday 23rd April 2017
quotequote all
FN2TypeR said:
It's gonna be an interesting one, that's for sure!
Deffo, it's all part of the shove. Expect the marginals to get flooded by the roving gangs.

Hackney

6,828 posts

208 months

Sunday 23rd April 2017
quotequote all
powerstroke said:
Hackney said:
CaptainSlow said:
User33678888 said:
I'm constantly amazed at the people rooting for a hard brexit regardless of consequence.
Do you not realise quite how fked we'd be economically if we couldn't trade with 27 of our biggest partners for just a year?
Perhaps you're all too young to remember the 3 day week.
This country is populated by morons.
Why can't we trade? Are you one of the morons?
It appears you are. Maybe not "can't trade", but going from free trade to who knows what kind of restrictions with our biggest trading partners. How on earth does that make any kind of sense?
Makes me laugh ... trade in hard goods are vastly in europe's favour , but don't let facts get in the way of the sky will fall
remain narrative ...
About 44% of UK exports in goods and services went to other countries in the EU in 2016
53% of our imports into the UK came from other countries in the EU in 2016

Some of that UK>EU trade is made up of non EU companies (Nissan, Toyota to name a couple) who "manufacture" in the UK as a way into the EU. Nissan's backhanders aside how will this continue? What will be the impact on those companies' suppliers?

A company I did some work for recently has already bought a production site in the EU in order to avoid potential tarifs and barriers to trade, but how many UK manufacturing companies can do that?