The economic consequences of Brexit (Vol 3)

[Tankrizzo]

ElectricSoup said:

Jesus this is hard work. The post-vote recession was averted by swift Bank of England action immediately after the stty result came through. Had they not acted, the Remain campaign would, in all likelihood, have been proven right. But, rightly, nobody wanted that, so Plan B was devised. The BoE acted. Recession averted. We are where we are now. Which is a bit worse off than we would otherwise have been with a Remain vote due to lost growth. Which is a shame.

Of course, we haven't left yet. We've just kicked the worst down the road.

How many times does this have to be said? "Look Look we were right!! It was all Project Fear!!!" Conveniently missing out the vital information from the desired Leavist narrative, of course and conveniently never acknowledging that the lies of the Leaveist Project Fear about Turkey joining the EU, the Superstate and the EU Army and all that schemozzle hasn't happened and won't happen.

Sick of it all. Bullstters, everywhere. You're not going to get away with it.

Alright Rambo

[wst]

amgmcqueen said:

I've never read such deluded tripe!

Are you gonna attempt a cogent rebuttal for those of us who like to see well reasoned thoughts?

[Tuna]

wst said:

amgmcqueen said:

I've never read such deluded tripe!

Are you gonna attempt a cogent rebuttal for those of us who like to see well reasoned thoughts?

Mr Soup doesn't seem too hot on actually backing up his comments, he's been asked questions before.

The big one here is what exact 'swift action' did the Bank of England take to avert the recession we were meant to have, and why was that apparently not an option when the predictions of recession were being made?

[Tuna]

jjlynn27 said:

andymadmak said:

Actually growing faster than expected...

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-42831655

"expected" is not a universal term for all people, as it could mean recession for some, and modest growth for others. However growth at 0.5% in Q4 2017 will confound some and pleasantly surprise others. It is unexpected ( which for some, means Emergency)

same article said said:

• However, the Office for National Statistics (ONS) said the broader picture was "slower and more uneven" growth.
• In 2017 as a whole, growth was 1.8% compared with 1.9% in 2016 - the slowest since 2012

Same old jj - 50% insults with weird obsessions and 50% flat out denial.

Slowest since 2012 eh? And how does that compare to what might have happened if there wasn't a Brexit? If you claim to have a robust answer, I don't think I'll be the only one to call you a liar.

[anonymous-user]

Tuna said:

wst said:

amgmcqueen said:

I've never read such deluded tripe!

Are you gonna attempt a cogent rebuttal for those of us who like to see well reasoned thoughts?

Mr Soup doesn't seem too hot on actually backing up his comments, he's been asked questions before.

Yet writing "I've never read such deluded tripe!" is the perfect response ?

[sidicks]

amgmcqueen said:

ElectricSoup said:

Jesus this is hard work. The post-vote recession was averted by swift Bank of England action immediately after the stty result came through. Had they not acted, the Remain campaign would, in all likelihood, have been proven right. But, rightly, nobody wanted that, so Plan B was devised. The BoE acted. Recession averted. We are where we are now. Which is a bit worse off than we would otherwise have been with a Remain vote due to lost growth. Which is a shame.

Of course, we haven't left yet. We've just kicked the worst down the road.

How many times does this have to be said? "Look Look we were right!! It was all Project Fear!!!" Conveniently missing out the vital information from the desired Leavist narrative, of course and conveniently never acknowledging that the lies of the Leaveist Project Fear about Turkey joining the EU, the Superstate and the EU Army and all that schemozzle hasn't happened and won't happen.

Sick of it all. Bullstters, everywhere. You're not going to get away with it.

I've never read such deluded tripe!

What about the majority of his other posts?

[StottyGTR]

ElectricSoup said:

Jesus this is hard work. The post-vote recession was averted by swift Bank of England action immediately after the stty result came through. Had they not acted, the Remain campaign would, in all likelihood, have been proven right. But, rightly, nobody wanted that, so Plan B was devised.

Do you not see how ridiculous this statement is?

I don't know if it is correct or incorrect, irregardless do you not see the gigantic void of logic with your statement?

[Tuna]

Ghibli said:

Yet writing "I've never read such deluded tripe!" is the perfect response ?

Well, if he is a hit and run poster, then it might get his attention more than politely asking him to justify his deluded tripe..

[jjlynn27]

Tuna said:

Same old jj - 50% insults with weird obsessions and 50% flat out denial.

Slowest since 2012 eh? And how does that compare to what might have happened if there wasn't a Brexit? If you claim to have a robust answer, I don't think I'll be the only one to call you a liar.

LOL.

My reply was a smiley + quote from the same article. Btw, what's with you and insults? Did you count them again or something?
Yes, slowest since 2012. Per article. That someone else quoted. You can call me whatever you like. When I call you a liar I've provided the evidence. When you tried that gambit last time, I asked you for the same. Provide the evidence. You refused.

Now, jog on.

[anonymous-user]

Tuna said:

Ghibli said:

Yet writing "I've never read such deluded tripe!" is the perfect response ?

Well, if he is a hit and run poster, then it might get his attention more than politely asking him to justify his deluded tripe..

Maybe Mr Soup is talking about the real world.

I would imagine that the Bank of England was doing something after the referendum.

The following is Carney's speech on the 24th June 2016. I'm sure he has a better idea of what is going on than random blokes on the internet.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-36618560

[sidicks]

Ghibli said:

Maybe Mr Soup is talking about the real world.

I would imagine that the Bank of England was doing something after the referendum.

The following is Carney's speech on the 24th June 2016. I'm sure he has a better idea of what is going on than random blokes on the internet.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-36618560

That says what they can do, if circumstances require. What action did they actually take?

[anonymous-user]

sidicks said:

That says what they can do, if circumstances require. What action did they actually take?

If you know you are welcome to tell me.

[sidicks]

Ghibli said:

sidicks said:

That says what they can do, if circumstances require. What action did they actually take?

If you know you are welcome to tell me.

Shouldn’t we ask the person who is making the claims about what occurred?

[anonymous-user]

sidicks said:

Shouldn’t we ask the person who is making the claims about what occurred?

And what claim have I made other than Carney has a better idea than random blokes on the internet.

You could always drop Carney a message.

[sidicks]

Ghibli said:

sidicks said:

Shouldn’t we ask the person who is making the claims about what occurred?

And what claim have I made other than Carney has a better idea than random blokes on the internet.

Were you the person who made the claim? I think not!

Ghibli said:

You could always drop Carney a message.

Why bother, when Electric Soup already has the information?

[anonymous-user]

sidicks said:

Ghibli said:

sidicks said:

Shouldn’t we ask the person who is making the claims about what occurred?

And what claim have I made other than Carney has a better idea than random blokes on the internet.

Were you the person who made the claim? I think not!

Ghibli said:

You could always drop Carney a message.

Why bother, when Electric Soup already has the information?

If you are not asking me questions don't quote my posts. It will make life easier

HTH

[sidicks]

Ghibli said:

If you are not asking me questions don't quote my posts. It will make life easier

HTH

I wa replying to your post. Perhaps learn to read or get someone to help you - it will make your life easier. HTH

[anonymous-user]

sidicks said:

Ghibli said:

Maybe Mr Soup is talking about the real world.

I would imagine that the Bank of England was doing something after the referendum.

The following is Carney's speech on the 24th June 2016. I'm sure he has a better idea of what is going on than random blokes on the internet.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-36618560

That says what they can do, if circumstances require. What action did they actually take?

Now let me think, is this question directed at me or someone else who has not been mentioned?

[sidicks]

Ghibli said:

Now let me think, is this question directed at me or someone else who has not been mentioned?

Thinking would be good:

This question was directed at you, it was a direct response to your post.

sidicks said:

What action did they actually take?

This question was directed to you, but not about you, hence the reference to a third party (‘the person’)

sidicks said:

Shouldn’t we ask the person who is making the claims about what occurred?

HTH

[anonymous-user]

sidicks said:

Ghibli said:

Now let me think, is this question directed at me or someone else who has not been mentioned?

Thinking would be good:

This question was directed at you, it was a direct response to your post.

sidicks said:

What action did they actually take?

This question was directed to you, but not about you, hence the reference to a third party (‘the person’)

sidicks said:

Shouldn’t we ask the person who is making the claims about what occurred?

HTH

And here we are again.

The PH Brexit dream and you JAQing off again.