Theresa May (Vol.2)

Author
Discussion

JagLover

42,381 posts

235 months

Sunday 27th January 2019
quotequote all
chris watton said:
I think they just live inside their own narrow bubble of like minded people and advisors, and also think that Twitter is the be all and end all of what the general public think.

I think this is why they're so shocked and confused when the general public never vote the way they think, or what their equally narrow minded advisers told them what the public think.
Twitter is indeed part of it as that is usually the only way they see public reactions outside focus groups etc. London based politicians/media think it represents the public, but, as Cummings pointed out, it is a "metropolitan" phenomenon.

SpeckledJim

31,608 posts

253 months

Sunday 27th January 2019
quotequote all
JagLover said:
chris watton said:
I think they just live inside their own narrow bubble of like minded people and advisors, and also think that Twitter is the be all and end all of what the general public think.

I think this is why they're so shocked and confused when the general public never vote the way they think, or what their equally narrow minded advisers told them what the public think.
Twitter is indeed part of it as that is usually the only way they see public reactions outside focus groups etc. London based politicians/media think it represents the public, but, as Cummings pointed out, it is a "metropolitan" phenomenon.
Once Twitter is a fair reflection of general opinion, we’re all completely doomed.

Almost everyone and everything on Twitter is mad.

RichB

51,527 posts

284 months

Sunday 27th January 2019
quotequote all
AlexS_LDN said:
... it seems an election is around the corner...
The only person to whom it seems an election is round the corner is Corbyn. He's tried and failed miserably.

Burwood

18,709 posts

246 months

Sunday 27th January 2019
quotequote all
RichB said:
AlexS_LDN said:
... it seems an election is around the corner...
The only person to whom it seems an election is round the corner is Corbyn. He's tried and failed miserably.
He's delusional. The Turkey's won't be voting for Christmas. I now firmly believe TM will get some concessions on the Back Stop such that she can push her deal through. The reasons are relatively clear. The EU want their 39B not just because it would be inconvenient not to. The implications are dire. Who will fund the shortfall. Whilst Germany and France can pay, the fallout will be French riots etc. The EU do not want a no deal situation. Their economy is tepid to say the least and WTO will hurt everyone. The EU do not want a Labour Govt.

wc98

10,375 posts

140 months

Sunday 27th January 2019
quotequote all
chris watton said:
I think they just live inside their own narrow bubble of like minded people and advisors, and also think that Twitter is the be all and end all of what the general public think.

I think this is why they're so shocked and confused when the general public never vote the way they think, or what their equally narrow minded advisers told them what the public think.
spot on. still a few bubbles to burst yet.

davepoth

29,395 posts

199 months

Sunday 27th January 2019
quotequote all
Burwood said:
RichB said:
AlexS_LDN said:
... it seems an election is around the corner...
The only person to whom it seems an election is round the corner is Corbyn. He's tried and failed miserably.
He's delusional. The Turkey's won't be voting for Christmas. I now firmly believe TM will get some concessions on the Back Stop such that she can push her deal through. The reasons are relatively clear. The EU want their 39B not just because it would be inconvenient not to. The implications are dire. Who will fund the shortfall. Whilst Germany and France can pay, the fallout will be French riots etc. The EU do not want a no deal situation. Their economy is tepid to say the least and WTO will hurt everyone. The EU do not want a Labour Govt.
He doesn't want an election. He (or to put it more sensibly, Seamus Milne) has calculated that advocating for an election doesn't force him to come down on either side of the Brexit fence. He can continue to offer succour to both sides of his party without having to actually do anything until after the deal is done, and then the entire Labour party will be united in "We could have done it better, but it can't be unpicked now".

Burwood

18,709 posts

246 months

Sunday 27th January 2019
quotequote all
davepoth said:
Burwood said:
RichB said:
AlexS_LDN said:
... it seems an election is around the corner...
The only person to whom it seems an election is round the corner is Corbyn. He's tried and failed miserably.
He's delusional. The Turkey's won't be voting for Christmas. I now firmly believe TM will get some concessions on the Back Stop such that she can push her deal through. The reasons are relatively clear. The EU want their 39B not just because it would be inconvenient not to. The implications are dire. Who will fund the shortfall. Whilst Germany and France can pay, the fallout will be French riots etc. The EU do not want a no deal situation. Their economy is tepid to say the least and WTO will hurt everyone. The EU do not want a Labour Govt.
He doesn't want an election. He (or to put it more sensibly, Seamus Milne) has calculated that advocating for an election doesn't force him to come down on either side of the Brexit fence. He can continue to offer succour to both sides of his party without having to actually do anything until after the deal is done, and then the entire Labour party will be united in "We could have done it better, but it can't be unpicked now".
I agree with you with the exception that he does want an election. It's just that he knows he won't get one and even if he did the polls would say he loses, again. His refusal to talk to TM is exactly as you say. He thinks he will emerge blameless (wrong) coupled with the fact he is a clueless moron. The tank is empty on ideas. We all know post Brexit, Labour will be crowing and finger pointing leading into 2022.That is all they are good at. And if they do prevail they can then blame Brexit for fking the economy. Not their policies.

RichB

51,527 posts

284 months

Sunday 27th January 2019
quotequote all
Burwood said:
davepoth said:
Burwood said:
RichB said:
AlexS_LDN said:
... it seems an election is around the corner...
The only person to whom it seems an election is round the corner is Corbyn. He's tried and failed miserably.
He's delusional. The Turkey's won't be voting for Christmas. I now firmly believe TM will get some concessions on the Back Stop such that she can push her deal through. The reasons are relatively clear. The EU want their 39B not just because it would be inconvenient not to. The implications are dire. Who will fund the shortfall. Whilst Germany and France can pay, the fallout will be French riots etc. The EU do not want a no deal situation. Their economy is tepid to say the least and WTO will hurt everyone. The EU do not want a Labour Govt.
He doesn't want an election. He (or to put it more sensibly, Seamus Milne) has calculated that advocating for an election doesn't force him to come down on either side of the Brexit fence. He can continue to offer succour to both sides of his party without having to actually do anything until after the deal is done, and then the entire Labour party will be united in "We could have done it better, but it can't be unpicked now".
I agree with you with the exception that he does want an election. It's just that he knows he won't get one and even if he did the polls would say he loses, again. His refusal to talk to TM is exactly as you say. He thinks he will emerge blameless (wrong) coupled with the fact he is a clueless moron. The tank is empty on ideas. We all know post Brexit, Labour will be crowing and finger pointing leading into 2022.That is all they are good at. And if they do prevail they can then blame Brexit for fking the economy. Not their policies.
Very good points

Durzel

12,258 posts

168 months

Monday 28th January 2019
quotequote all
It's weird to think that TM is basically in her position, the most senior political position in the country, by default.

No one in her party seriously wants the job as things stand right now, it's a poisoned chalice. Plenty waiting to pick up the pieces though.

With pretty much any other leader one would think that Labour would've have a decent shout of ousting the Conservatives. For all her hopelessness TM has expertly dunked on Corbyn by inviting the no-confidence vote. Corbyn just looks weak and Labour as a whole look rudderless.

The most important decision the country has known for decades and it's being marshalled by someone who won't listen to anyone and isn't competent enough to deliver it. Her "no deal is better than a bad deal" bad deal was everything the EU wanted, with nothing in our favour.

An utter shambles.

BlackLabel

13,251 posts

123 months

Tuesday 29th January 2019
quotequote all
So back to Brussels she goes.


dazwalsh

6,095 posts

141 months

Tuesday 29th January 2019
quotequote all
BlackLabel said:
So back to Brussels she goes.
with a sense of progress at least, to this time show the EU that the backstop is the main sticking point and to come up with a different plan.

I actually like the plan C that was hinted at today, add a year onto the WA, and failing that auto backstop is WTO rules.

johnxjsc1985

15,948 posts

164 months

Tuesday 29th January 2019
quotequote all
Its a pity that we have to have this brinkmanship negotiations but it is how the EU likes to do business whenever they are unable to rollover the other party. Hold fast keep the eye on the prize.

paulrockliffe

15,679 posts

227 months

Wednesday 30th January 2019
quotequote all
Watching PMQs, as much as she needs to move aside, I wish she would explain to the un-made bed opposite why a Customs Union without EU membership would suck his jobs-first jobs into the EU.

JagLover

42,381 posts

235 months

Wednesday 30th January 2019
quotequote all
paulrockliffe said:
Watching PMQs, as much as she needs to move aside, I wish she would explain to the un-made bed opposite why a Customs Union without EU membership would suck his jobs-first jobs into the EU.
As Rodgers said the politicians don't really understand trade. In any case Labour probably just want a customs union so they can say they are different to the Tories and seeking a "softer" Brexit.

Gribs

469 posts

136 months

Wednesday 30th January 2019
quotequote all
dazwalsh said:
with a sense of progress at least, to this time show the EU that the backstop is the main sticking point and to come up with a different plan.

I actually like the plan C that was hinted at today, add a year onto the WA, and failing that auto backstop is WTO rules.
Which won't be accepted by the EU as it requires a hard border in Ireland.

Blue Oval84

5,276 posts

161 months

Wednesday 30th January 2019
quotequote all
Gribs said:
Which won't be accepted by the EU as it requires a hard border in Ireland.
So will a No Deal, but the EU have said they aim not to have a hard border in the case of No Deal as they'll look to implement technological solutions instead... Something they said couldn't be done when the UK suggested it.

Slagathore

5,808 posts

192 months

Wednesday 30th January 2019
quotequote all
JagLover said:
As Rodgers said the politicians don't really understand trade. In any case Labour probably just want a customs union so they can say they are different to the Tories and seeking a "softer" Brexit.
May asked Corbyn what sort of Customs Union he wanted yesterday, and listed a few different types. He was flummoxed, and clearly doesn't even know what he's asking for. He turned to his front bench and May said something along the lines of 'you shouldn't be asking your staff" It even seemed to get a smirk from Starmer.

His answer was typical Corbyn - he didn't answer the question!

johnxjsc1985

15,948 posts

164 months

Wednesday 30th January 2019
quotequote all
He has been shown to be totally useless as a party leader and as leader of the opposition.
He seems totally out of his depth which of course he is the reality has hit him hard

paulrockliffe

15,679 posts

227 months

Wednesday 30th January 2019
quotequote all
His answer was that it would need to be negotiated. Delivered with smug satisfaction. I presume he meant negotiation within his party.

Fermit and Sexy Sarah

12,908 posts

100 months

Wednesday 30th January 2019
quotequote all
If history will remember Maggie as the Iron Lady, history will remember May as the B0llocks it up b1tch. The whole ste show is farcical.