Student strike for climate change
Discussion
https://www.theguardian.com/education/2019/feb/10/...
Apols if we already have a thread on this. Heard one of the leaders on Today this AM. Is this widely known about? My kids hadn't heard.
Hearts are the right place but not sure what impact this will have apart from a a LOT of detention
M
Apols if we already have a thread on this. Heard one of the leaders on Today this AM. Is this widely known about? My kids hadn't heard.
Hearts are the right place but not sure what impact this will have apart from a a LOT of detention
M
Stupid thing to do. Especially when considering the fact you can be fined for taking your child out of school to go on holiday and all the guff you get about attendance.
Poor brainwashed kids. School kids striking? They all destined to work in the rail industry?
Are they actively doing anything to minimise their impact on the environment too? Or are they going to carry on with their lifestyle and just moan about it?
Poor brainwashed kids. School kids striking? They all destined to work in the rail industry?
Are they actively doing anything to minimise their impact on the environment too? Or are they going to carry on with their lifestyle and just moan about it?
gareth_r said:
ReallyReallyGood said:
I don't really understand it. Why do they need to 'strike' rather than just protest outside of school hours?
The thread title was factually incorrect. Correction below.mikees said:
Be interesting to see how much the education sector contributes to “climate change”. Huge facilities taking up lots of land/using lots of energy, thousands of students flown in for courses (as well as regular trips home), environmental destruction during garp yarrrr tours, students travelling abroad for courses, foreign exchange trips...I imagine the average student creates a lot of evil carbons
esxste said:
ReallyReallyGood said:
I don't really understand it. Why do they need to 'strike' rather than just protest outside of school hours?
Isn't that a bit like "why don't workers strike outside of working hours?"esxste said:
ReallyReallyGood said:
Well workers have a grievance against their employer. Do the students think the schools are to blame for climate change? That's the bit I don't understand.
to create a bigger media impact. Kids missing school to strike usually gets prominent coverage. It’s pretty dumb really and badly named as a ‘strike’. A protest organised outside of school time would have been far more sensible and quite possibly would have attracted more people and attention.
Kids can’t strike. The very word implies damaging another party which these kids can’t do; they’re just hurting themselves and giving the staff, who are in the end employed by the kids’ parents, an easy day.
Risible, in reality.
Grauniad said:
One would-be striker, Anna Taylor, 17, from north London, said her school had given her “mixed messages”.
“I chucked up a notice – ‘school strike in a few weeks’ – on the noticeboard in the common room and they wiped it off, said ‘you can’t actively publicise it in schools’ and ‘we’ll give you an unauthorised absence and detention if you strike’, but then they said ‘you can spread it by word of mouth and we do support your cause’.”
Detention for 17 year olds? At the same time we are being told that they should be given the vote? Making education compulsory up to 18 seems to have driven the infantilisation of this age group.“I chucked up a notice – ‘school strike in a few weeks’ – on the noticeboard in the common room and they wiped it off, said ‘you can’t actively publicise it in schools’ and ‘we’ll give you an unauthorised absence and detention if you strike’, but then they said ‘you can spread it by word of mouth and we do support your cause’.”
otolith said:
Grauniad said:
One would-be striker, Anna Taylor, 17, from north London, said her school had given her “mixed messages”.
“I chucked up a notice – ‘school strike in a few weeks’ – on the noticeboard in the common room and they wiped it off, said ‘you can’t actively publicise it in schools’ and ‘we’ll give you an unauthorised absence and detention if you strike’, but then they said ‘you can spread it by word of mouth and we do support your cause’.”
Detention for 17 year olds? At the same time we are being told that they should be given the vote? Making education compulsory up to 18 seems to have driven the infantilisation of this age group.“I chucked up a notice – ‘school strike in a few weeks’ – on the noticeboard in the common room and they wiped it off, said ‘you can’t actively publicise it in schools’ and ‘we’ll give you an unauthorised absence and detention if you strike’, but then they said ‘you can spread it by word of mouth and we do support your cause’.”
As to the article... I'd be keen to hear the solutions the would be strikers have for the climate change problem.
otolith said:
Detention for 17 year olds? At the same time we are being told that they should be given the vote? Making education compulsory up to 18 seems to have driven the infantilisation of this age group.
There are many things that have infantalised the latest generation. Personally I blame the 40+ crowd who raised them and have all the political power in the country.
Thankfully the Millenials can be left to their avocado toast for this one.
Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff