The Green Party - new Labour?
Author
Discussion

nikaiyo2

5,980 posts

226 months

Thursday 23rd October 2025
quotequote all
Sport_Turismo_GTS said:
When was that?
Before Starmer got in and give us a taste of the mess mildly left wing governments cause let alone full on Mao and Trotsky excusing Green or Corbyn extremists.

ukwill

10,289 posts

238 months

Thursday 23rd October 2025
quotequote all
s1962a said:
https://news.sky.com/story/zack-polanski-and-nigel...

Interesting article. It seems like the next election will be a battle between polar opposites. Reform, on one side with their refreshing take on politics and the economy, and Green on the other side with their left leaning policies.
Is anti-nato a left leaning policy these days? I wonder what Attlee would think?

Reform are a one-trick pony. What’s worrying is enough of the electorate will be convinced by their rhetoric. They can’t even run a local council.

The nuttier the Greens get, the more Farage has a chance.

Still, as they say, a week is a long time in politics. We’ve still got years of the current one to endure.


Blue62

10,587 posts

183 months

Thursday 23rd October 2025
quotequote all
nikaiyo2 said:
Before Starmer got in and give us a taste of the mess mildly left wing governments cause let alone full on Mao and Trotsky excusing Green or Corbyn extremists.
I’m no fan of Starmer, but could you point to the successes of the previous thirteen years of coalition and Tory rule? The fact is that the system is fooked, doesn’t matter who is in charge. Check out what Trotsky and Mao stood for while you’re at it, not that it matters really but always better to know what one’s talking about.

nikaiyo2

5,980 posts

226 months

Thursday 23rd October 2025
quotequote all
Blue62 said:
I m no fan of Starmer, but could you point to the successes of the previous thirteen years of coalition and Tory rule? The fact is that the system is fooked, doesn t matter who is in charge. Check out what Trotsky and Mao stood for while you re at it, not that it matters really but always better to know what one s talking about.
Well they did not talk the country into stagflation in a ham fisted attempt to make political capital.

A few members of my family were murdered by communist and were made refugees.

I see Mao and Trot as people who used terror and murder as a way to spread a populist political ideology, they killed millions and millions and spread untold misery. Unending revolution and all that… spreading poverty, oppression and an early grave to people who had no desire to be Soviet or Chinese vassals.

DeejRC

9,665 posts

113 months

Monday 10th November 2025
quotequote all
Hands up who is shocked?

CT05 Nose Cone

26,146 posts

258 months

Tuesday 11th November 2025
quotequote all
Why is she mentioning risks, i thought they were all vulnerable people in need of help?

Legacywr

15,883 posts

219 months

Tuesday 11th November 2025
quotequote all
In fairness to him, he’s not suggesting legalising Class A drugs, which is the story that seems to be put about.

M3333

2,347 posts

245 months

Tuesday 11th November 2025
quotequote all
Zack Polanski’s leadership of the Green Party is built on a house of cards: eco-populism that sounds bold but collapses under scrutiny. He’s wrong on strategy, wrong on economics, and wrong on electoral reality. Here’s why.

1. He’s betting the farm on a left-wing surge that doesn’t exist
Polanski claims Labour has “betrayed” its base and that the Greens can “replace” it. But national polling tells a different story. Yes, a single Find Out Now poll in October 2025 briefly showed Greens at 15.3% vs Labour’s 15.2%—but that was an outlier driven by post-budget anger. YouGov, Ipsos, and More in Common all show Labour still commanding 25–30% among working-class and progressive voters, with Greens stuck at 8–11%. The idea that millions of Labour voters will defect to a party with four MPs and a history of council-level irrelevance is fantasy. Polanski confuses Twitter echo chambers and student unions for the British electorate.

2. Eco-populism is just old-school socialism in a green T-shirt
Polanski’s flagship policies—wealth taxes, nationalisation, rent controls, UBI trials—are rebranded Corbynism. He’s not “broadening” the Green agenda; he’s abandoning the one thing that made the party distinctive: credible, evidence-based environmentalism. The 2024 election proved voters respond to targeted green policies (insulation grants, heat pumps, local renewables) in swing seats like Bristol Central and Waveney Valley. Polanski’s pivot to “tax the rich, fund everything” risks turning the Greens into a protest vote that peaks at 10% and wins nothing.

3. He’s alienating the voters who actually elected Green MPs
The four Green MPs in 2024 won in diverse, not uniformly left-wing seats:
Brighton Pavilion: affluent, liberal, Remain
Bristol Central: young, urban, student-heavy
North Herefordshire: rural, ex-Tory, anti-sewage
Waveney Valley: farming communities, flood-risk
Polanski’s rhetoric—calling for “replacing Labour,” praising Gaza protests, and dismissing rural concerns as “timid”—plays well in Islington but repels the pragmatic voters who switched from the Tories. Green councillors in Suffolk and Devon report members leaving over his “London-centric” tone.

4. His economic illiteracy is breathtaking
Polanski wants to “tax extreme wealth” to fund public services. Fine—but the numbers don’t add up. The Wealth Tax Commission (2020) estimated a one-off 1% tax on assets over £500k would raise £260bn. Polanski’s spending pledges (free care, NHS “transformation,” mass insulation) would cost £100bn+ per year. That’s a fiscal black hole even before capital flight kicks in. His refusal to model policies or engage with the OBR exposes eco-populism as gesture politics, not governance.

5. He’s handing Reform UK a free pass
By obsessing over Labour’s “betrayal,” Polanski ignores the real threat: Reform UK. Nigel Farage’s party is polling 18–22% and winning working-class votes in Red Wall seats the Greens never contest. Polanski’s Clacton photo-op was PR, not strategy—he has no plan to win back ex-Labour voters who’ve gone right, not left. The Greens risk becoming the mirror image of Reform: loud, tribal, and electorally irrelevant.

6. Membership surge? It’s a sugar high
Yes, Green membership doubled to 126,000—but 70% are in London, the South East, and university cities. That’s not a national movement; it’s a metropolitan clique. Turnout in local elections remains <5% in most wards. Polanski’s podcast hits the charts because it’s preached to the converted, not because it’s converting anyone new.

Vsix and Vtec

1,438 posts

49 months

Tuesday 11th November 2025
quotequote all
Im not sure I've read many posts on here that are more reasoned or thoughtful than that, well done!

borcy

13,086 posts

87 months

Tuesday 11th November 2025
quotequote all
I suppose it depends on the green's realistic target? 15 MPs, if so they might do it.

Edited by borcy on Wednesday 12th November 06:40

GlenMH

5,472 posts

274 months

Tuesday 11th November 2025
quotequote all
borcy said:
I suppose it depends on the green's realistic target is? 15 MPs, if so they might do it.
Yes - that is the point about the next election: the Greens (or Reform) don't have to win a huge number of seats to be able to act as kingmakers. It is going to be a properly interesting election...

DeejRC

9,665 posts

113 months

Wednesday 12th November 2025
quotequote all
The Greens are targeting about 15seats. That is monumental success for them.
If Reform get 15seats - that is monumental failure for them.

s1962a

Original Poster:

7,696 posts

193 months

Thursday 13th November 2025
quotequote all
https://www.itv.com/news/2025-11-11/greens-support...

article said:
The polling suggests young people are abandoning Keir Starmer's party in their droves, with their support for Labour plummeting from 43% in March to 25% in November.

But the Greens, who elected their new leader Zack Polanski in September, have surged to become the party most popular with young adults, increasing their support from 16% in March to 32% in November.

amusingduck

9,879 posts

167 months

Thursday 13th November 2025
quotequote all
Vsix and Vtec said:
Im not sure I've read many posts on here that are more reasoned or thoughtful than that, well done!
It's AI wink

Vsix and Vtec

1,438 posts

49 months

Thursday 13th November 2025
quotequote all
amusingduck said:
It's AI wink
That's not exactly a ringing endorsement if its that good it beats most other assessments!

P-Jay

11,427 posts

222 months

Thursday 13th November 2025
quotequote all
I'll be honest, as a left of centre / centrist, it doesn't seem a bad offering at the moment.

The sticking point, leaving NATO. Practically very unappealing, Nuclear weapons are something that will never go away, unless something worse comes along or maybe aliens turn up and give us another enemy worry about. Not having them when Russia, China and other protentional enemies in the future do, seems a very bad idea. Morally, we wouldn't be leaving ourselves helpless. Due to our economic and geographic position, we'd simply be shifting the cost and everything else to our neighbours, because no Western Country wants Russia or China to attack the UK giving them a platform between Europe and the US.

swisstoni

24,250 posts

310 months

Thursday 13th November 2025
quotequote all
P-Jay said:
I'll be honest, as a left of centre / centrist, it doesn't seem a bad offering at the moment.

The sticking point, leaving NATO. Practically very unappealing, Nuclear weapons are something that will never go away, unless something worse comes along or maybe aliens turn up and give us another enemy worry about. Not having them when Russia, China and other protentional enemies in the future do, seems a very bad idea. Morally, we wouldn't be leaving ourselves helpless. Due to our economic and geographic position, we'd simply be shifting the cost and everything else to our neighbours, because no Western Country wants Russia or China to attack the UK giving them a platform between Europe and the US.
Just leaving NATO you have a problem with? Ok with open borders?

Slow.Patrol

5,768 posts

45 months

JoshSm

5,484 posts

68 months

Friday 12th December 2025
quotequote all
Slow.Patrol said:
It's the Green Party, they aren't members of the reality-based community.

And in this specific case it wouldn't be unfair to suggest the statement is probably based on explicit personal interest rather than anything inconvenient like facts or statistics.

Vanden Saab

18,062 posts

105 months

Friday 12th December 2025
quotequote all
It seems the Greens are going the same way as Your party.
Apparently kicking people out of the party for stating transwomen are men is illegal.


https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/d5a9d9e60ceede03