Silver
Author
Discussion

Scootersp

4,137 posts

219 months

Saturday 7th February
quotequote all
and Felix is very much not a tin foil hat silver only guy. He's ex city trader broad market follower, defiitely not a permanent Gold/silver bug but does know a anomally/opportunity when he sees one.

TVRBRZ

672 posts

120 months

Saturday 7th February
quotequote all
I registered for the Felix newsletter. Although this is all so logical, I can't help thinking the FOMO is beginning to outweigh common sense.

If it is all so obvious (COMEX deliveries, manipulation, demand, debasement), has the bandwagon not already been and gone? Or is it the simple truth that Paper manipulation has left Western Financial orgs so exposed that they are fighting a vicious rearguard action?

Surely the Masters of the Universe must have seen this coming? Or is it really a Perfect Storm? (Must stop with the seafaring film genre alegories....)

paddy1970

1,522 posts

140 months

Sunday 8th February
quotequote all
TVRBRZ said:
I registered for the Felix newsletter. Although this is all so logical, I can't help thinking the FOMO is beginning to outweigh common sense.

If it is all so obvious (COMEX deliveries, manipulation, demand, debasement), has the bandwagon not already been and gone? Or is it the simple truth that Paper manipulation has left Western Financial orgs so exposed that they are fighting a vicious rearguard action?

Surely the Masters of the Universe must have seen this coming? Or is it really a Perfect Storm? (Must stop with the seafaring film genre alegories....)
The Masters of the Universe absolutely saw it coming. But the question is whether they can manage the current situation without it spiraling out of control...

They are fighting a rearguard action, but they're not defeated yet. They might hold the line for years. Or it might break next month. Nobody knows.


wisbech

4,393 posts

152 months

Sunday 8th February
quotequote all
paddy1970 said:
The Masters of the Universe absolutely saw it coming. But the question is whether they can manage the current situation without it spiraling out of control...

They are fighting a rearguard action, but they're not defeated yet. They might hold the line for years. Or it might break next month. Nobody knows.
I think the problem is that you have some adults in the room (Bessant and Powell, now Warsh) trying to keep things together, while the US government continues to spend way beyond its means, and is run by Trump. As you say, nobody knows if the US will return to sanity, or abuse the dollar’s status as reserve currency until it isn’t anymore. When you have Steven Miran publishing papers that basically call on the US to renege on debt…. (He proposed rewriting treasury bonds to be 100 years, so no need to refinance, and/or haircut the interest payments with withholding taxes)

Mazinbrum

Original Poster:

1,407 posts

209 months

Sunday 8th February
quotequote all
paddy1970 said:
TVRBRZ said:
I registered for the Felix newsletter. Although this is all so logical, I can't help thinking the FOMO is beginning to outweigh common sense.

If it is all so obvious (COMEX deliveries, manipulation, demand, debasement), has the bandwagon not already been and gone? Or is it the simple truth that Paper manipulation has left Western Financial orgs so exposed that they are fighting a vicious rearguard action?

Surely the Masters of the Universe must have seen this coming? Or is it really a Perfect Storm? (Must stop with the seafaring film genre alegories....)
The Masters of the Universe absolutely saw it coming. But the question is whether they can manage the current situation without it spiraling out of control...

They are fighting a rearguard action, but they're not defeated yet. They might hold the line for years. Or it might break next month. Nobody knows.
I can’t believe the big dogs don’t have a plan for this event.

TVRBRZ

672 posts

120 months

Sunday 8th February
quotequote all
Perhaps the plan is to keep crashing the price every 6 weeks or so until we all give up and go back to buying bonds and putting money in savings accounts (which is what good little peasants should do).

So the price recovers above 100, gets crushed to 50, recovers to 120, crushed to 60, gets to 160, drops to 80 etc etc. The underlying trend is upwards but with horrific volatility.

The one quote I liked from Felix was about risk appetite. Something about 30% loss on a 20% holding is a 6% loss of your total pot. That would not make me go to bed with a bottle of vodka as he so elegantly put it. I would have a large glass of whisky though!

Mr Whippy

32,453 posts

272 months

Sunday 8th February
quotequote all
TVRBRZ said:
Perhaps the plan is to keep crashing the price every 6 weeks or so until we all give up and go back to buying bonds and putting money in savings accounts (which is what good little peasants should do).

So the price recovers above 100, gets crushed to 50, recovers to 120, crushed to 60, gets to 160, drops to 80 etc etc. The underlying trend is upwards but with horrific volatility.

The one quote I liked from Felix was about risk appetite. Something about 30% loss on a 20% holding is a 6% loss of your total pot. That would not make me go to bed with a bottle of vodka as he so elegantly put it. I would have a large glass of whisky though!
Surely after ~ 20yrs of playing silly games, CBs are about to win silly prizes wrt the actions of investors.

Lots of people believe in the inflation trade, but you still have people buying rubbish yielding long term gov debt.

And then bitcoin and PM people.

Everyone can’t be right. Everyone can’t win. The winners win by lots of people losing.

paddy1970

1,522 posts

140 months

Monday 9th February
quotequote all
Mazinbrum said:
I can t believe the big dogs don t have a plan for this event.
You are correct - they're not caught off-guard. But having a plan does not mean the plan will work.

Because history shows:

Weimar had plans: mark became worthless
Rome had plans: denarius became worthless
Britain had plans: pound lost reserve status
USSR had plans: system collapsed

Plans bought time. Time eventually ran out..

Scootersp

4,137 posts

219 months

Monday 9th February
quotequote all
TVRBRZ said:
Or is it the simple truth that Paper manipulation has left Western Financial orgs so exposed that they are fighting a vicious rearguard action?
It's partly this I think, the potential exposure that the Silver you bought you cannot get, Felix was looking at the contracts that could legitimately ask for delivery and comparing that to the stated amount the Comex has to distribute. What keeps things stable is few usually ask for the Silver to be delivered, they roll the contracts.

That there potentially isn't enough, proves the system is operating in some form of fractional reserve'esque system (some say it's very fractional 1% type level - the US debt clock page has paper to silver ratio at 378 not sure how this is calculated). A failure to deliver would spread fear, bank run type fear which would create the same potential contagion and distrust. If those that had to be cash settled, then really needed the Silver, to find some to buy, the price would be back to pure supply demand dynamics and so would have to go up?

It's not like our deposits, where they can guarantee your balances, as in a crunch, numbers can be retyped into accounts and debt added to bail out/makes things work again with no immediate barrier to this, with a physical item to make it good and everyone happy you need to give them what they thought they always had which may actually be impossible in a reasonable timeframe, no doubt some "Force majeure" would be declared?


But it's been going on for years/decades if you are interested check out the guy below and his attempt in 2010 to highlight issues

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrew_Maguire_(whis...

The same issues JP Morgan was eventually fined $920M for in 2020, what did they make in the decade between right? They also hold one of the largest reserves of Silver.

So do you "do as they say not as they do" or do you perhaps do a little of what they do, play the game we all have to with our £/$'s but have a real backup, cover all bases?

In my mind many of the things we value aren't actually that valuable, or it's possibly misjudged value, where value can go up with little extra actual effort, it's up on hype/momentum/self fulfilling popularity. I think we are actively discouraged from some limited physical things and encouraged towards other more virtual/less finite/electronic/estimated value things.

recent massive disconnect in price of physical to Paper is likely going to put people off £59 spot today Atkinsons x25 tube is £2,653, £106 per ounce which is £88.5 before Vat which is still a 50% premium and they'll only pay you £1,500 if you sell back today, that will put off all but the very committed.

This will probably settle the system down, depends on the fear within large holders of fiat, or perhaps even those countries that can use their fiat to buy it but it is always there in the background, but may be yet decades away from realisation, may never happen but Silvers use cases means it's less far from supply issues than most other commodities.

TVRBRZ

672 posts

120 months

Monday 9th February
quotequote all
That's a very interesting wiki entry - thanks ScooterSP

Greenmantle

2,248 posts

139 months

Monday 9th February
quotequote all
TVRBRZ said:
That's a very interesting wiki entry - thanks ScooterSP
yep happens all the the time

In my early days this was the one going around

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sumitomo_copper_affa...

and then there was the Hunt Brothers and "Silver Thursday" in 1980.

More recently it was cocoa beans. In fact the whole commodities arena is ripe for all this market manipulation.

Scootersp

4,137 posts

219 months

Monday 9th February
quotequote all
Just remember I properly live down the rabbit hole and just pop up on here for some air!

I love trying to understand the financial system, the contradictions and narratives and whether they are presented to us honestly or it's all spin for the advantage of others/them. There is a lot of confusion/obfuscation I think, it all works for who it needs to work for I'm sure.

TVRBRZ

672 posts

120 months

Monday 9th February
quotequote all
Greenmantle said:
More recently it was cocoa beans. In fact the whole commodities arena is ripe for all this market manipulation.
Ah, now you come to mention it, I remember watching this very good investigative documentary on Oranges as a commodity....which was also RIPE for manipulation...biggrin




Sorry, couldn't resist!

Mazinbrum

Original Poster:

1,407 posts

209 months

Wednesday 11th February
quotequote all
TVRBRZ said:
Ah, now you come to mention it, I remember watching this very good investigative documentary on Oranges as a commodity....which was also...

Sorry, couldn't resist!
Thing is you can grow more cocoa beans. If they manipulate the price of precious metals lower surely the paper price will become disconnected from the physical price.
God knows what will happen on Feb 27 when the CME haven't got enough to honour physical delivery should it be required.
I do know CME,The Fed, BoE et al will surely have a plan that will outsmart me!

A44RON

668 posts

127 months

Thursday 12th February
quotequote all
This is already happening; the Physical silver price has separated from the spot/paper price when it comes to buying...

However when it comes to selling, the dealers and mints will only buy back Physical silver below spot price... hehe

Scootersp

4,137 posts

219 months

Friday 13th February
quotequote all
Yes it's likely the physical demand will drop for smaller buyers as it's so far above the paper price.

It will be interesting if in the long run if it closes back up to near spot whether strong physical buying resumes.

It's worse for us here with the VAT element, but that isn't present in many places around the world so isn't such a barrier.

Currently £56 spot silver ounce, would be £67.20 with the vat, Atkinsons want £91 ish so not far off 40% premium! They pay £55 for them, ebay you'll get £85-90 for them.

Condi

20,562 posts

202 months

Sunday 15th February
quotequote all
Mazinbrum said:
Thing is you can grow more cocoa beans. If they manipulate the price of precious metals lower surely the paper price will become disconnected from the physical price.
God knows what will happen on Feb 27 when the CME haven't got enough to honour physical delivery should it be required.
I do know CME,The Fed, BoE et al will surely have a plan that will outsmart me!
I've come to this thread a bit late, and wouldn't profess to know the ins and outs of metals specifically, but with regard to physical delivery it's not up to CME to deliver, it's up to whoever has sold the paper contract. The CME is just the exchange, and you don't trade with the exchange, you trade with a counterparty.


KingNothing

3,351 posts

184 months

Wednesday 18th February
quotequote all
Want to say it’s been about 2 weeks since the “best value” silver Britannia's have been in stock on the Royal Mints website whereas beforehand they were being restocked daily/every other day, I mean the last few ones I got were all 2024 ones so I don’t know if their just totally out of those now, or if they’re just out of stock in general, 2026 ones have remained in stock for most of the time I’ve checked, but are currently about £7 + VAT more.

Crumpet

5,511 posts

211 months

Sunday 22nd February
quotequote all
Hypothetically, if someone offered you 50x 2oz silver bars in a very nice presentation box with pictures of all the kings and queens of England on them, would you pay £4500 for them?

TheRainMaker

7,889 posts

273 months

Sunday 22nd February
quotequote all
You could flip them straight to Atkinsons for £6000, with no risk.

The box is not worth anything; just go by weight.