114 Charges: The Manchester City Found Guilty Thread
Discussion
siovey said:
Glassman said:
Matthew Syed's comments on Pep are interesting:
"Either Pep knew about it in which case he is neither a visionary nor a legend, just a fraud or he didn't know, making him incredibly short-sighted.
"I mean, I m no forensic accountant, yet I ve been questioning City s financial arrangements for over a decade, despite facing constant insults and threats. And Pep didn't see a thing? Is he blind?"
Lol. Surely Pep must have had some idea what was going on. (Pep is not an idiot)"Either Pep knew about it in which case he is neither a visionary nor a legend, just a fraud or he didn't know, making him incredibly short-sighted.
"I mean, I m no forensic accountant, yet I ve been questioning City s financial arrangements for over a decade, despite facing constant insults and threats. And Pep didn't see a thing? Is he blind?"
A club way smaller than Real Madrid, Barcelona, United, Liverpool, Arsenal, Everton (
) being able to outbid them on ANY player they wanted. Laughable! Edited by siovey on Sunday 4th October 17:48
200Plus Club said:
The lying and deceitful nature of the club added to the wilful obstruction and now blatant changing stories to suit really is unprecedented in football and in many ways the punishments need to fit the crimes (115 of)
I agree, but on a mild technical point they haven’t been accused of any crimes (yet)Let’s just hope the PL has the courage to do the right thing and punish Manchester City accordingly. It needs to be something very significant which will send out a strong message. A fine alone is not the answer imho. But I do wonder whether money and influence will end up affecting the outcome. I hope I’m wrong but it seems to be the way the world is nowadays. Meanwhile, another one of very many…..
BRM.

BRM. vaud said:
TriumphStag3.0V8 said:
All these people saying the players are not at fault etc.... they are the ones who accepted payments mechanisms and other deals that they must have known that were questionable, as well as payments to family members, shell companies and whatever else.
In it up to their necks! Wonder how much HMRC will find to ask questions about.
While in understand your point, I suspect many players might think a shell company is one that sounds like the sea if you hold it up to your ear.In it up to their necks! Wonder how much HMRC will find to ask questions about.
Joking aside, like many high paid individuals they place a lot of trust in their financial advisors.
Many of the findings relate specifically to individual player wages and image rights. payments. Income tax evasion by the players is also a key part of the HMRC referral.
Graveworm said:
vaud said:
TriumphStag3.0V8 said:
All these people saying the players are not at fault etc.... they are the ones who accepted payments mechanisms and other deals that they must have known that were questionable, as well as payments to family members, shell companies and whatever else.
In it up to their necks! Wonder how much HMRC will find to ask questions about.
While in understand your point, I suspect many players might think a shell company is one that sounds like the sea if you hold it up to your ear.In it up to their necks! Wonder how much HMRC will find to ask questions about.
Joking aside, like many high paid individuals they place a lot of trust in their financial advisors.
Many of the findings relate specifically to individual player wages and image rights. payments. Income tax evasion by the players is also a key part of the HMRC referral.
You could though literally have players saying 'I just agreed to what the accountant said and got my money, i was too busy playing football'
FredericRobinson said:
Whenever I read any reporting relating to the finances of the company I work for I read it, and I m somewhat below the level he was at at City.
I don't, unless the firm looks iffy to start with. In which case I'll rarely do business with them anyway. I suspect you are in a tiny minority. I get my financials and contract sorted. Outside of that I don't go looking at their tax returns etc.
What’s being suggested is that footballers and their agents should be checking the club's returns against EPL and UEFA rules. When even the EPL and UEFA can't get that done properly for over a decade, that feels like a bit of a stretch.
As noted, they should all be stripped of their titles IMO. But to say they should have known/were complicit (at least without proof) is too far IMO.
coldel said:
Graveworm said:
vaud said:
TriumphStag3.0V8 said:
All these people saying the players are not at fault etc.... they are the ones who accepted payments mechanisms and other deals that they must have known that were questionable, as well as payments to family members, shell companies and whatever else.
In it up to their necks! Wonder how much HMRC will find to ask questions about.
While in understand your point, I suspect many players might think a shell company is one that sounds like the sea if you hold it up to your ear.In it up to their necks! Wonder how much HMRC will find to ask questions about.
Joking aside, like many high paid individuals they place a lot of trust in their financial advisors.
Many of the findings relate specifically to individual player wages and image rights. payments. Income tax evasion by the players is also a key part of the HMRC referral.
You could though literally have players saying 'I just agreed to what the accountant said and got my money, i was too busy playing football'

IF that ends up being something that happened, we should also ask why HMRC were asleep at the wheel. These are such high value contracts, and have always been in the spotlight value wise, that you would hope HMRC have been on them like they are everyone else.
vaud said:
TriumphStag3.0V8 said:
All these people saying the players are not at fault etc.... they are the ones who accepted payments mechanisms and other deals that they must have known that were questionable, as well as payments to family members, shell companies and whatever else.
In it up to their necks! Wonder how much HMRC will find to ask questions about.
While in understand your point, I suspect many players might think a shell company is one that sounds like the sea if you hold it up to your ear.In it up to their necks! Wonder how much HMRC will find to ask questions about.
Of all those to blame, I think the players are at the very bottom fo the list. Many will be going through agents, with offers and interest from lots of clubs, all across Europe and probably further afield too.
I really doubt any of them would think about how the money goes into the club or where it's from.
I think it's unfair to blame them or to otherwise think tehy should have known/looked into it.
I really doubt any of them would think about how the money goes into the club or where it's from.
I think it's unfair to blame them or to otherwise think tehy should have known/looked into it.
Murph7355 said:
I don't, unless the firm looks iffy to start with. In which case I'll rarely do business with them anyway. I suspect you are in a tiny minority.
I get my financials and contract sorted. Outside of that I don't go looking at their tax returns etc.
What s being suggested is that footballers and their agents should be checking the club's returns against EPL and UEFA rules. When even the EPL and UEFA can't get that done properly for over a decade, that feels like a bit of a stretch.
As noted, they should all be stripped of their titles IMO. But to say they should have known/were complicit (at least without proof) is too far IMO.
I don’t look into the tax returns, but if the finances are major news for years I don’t just think ‘nothing to do with me’I get my financials and contract sorted. Outside of that I don't go looking at their tax returns etc.
What s being suggested is that footballers and their agents should be checking the club's returns against EPL and UEFA rules. When even the EPL and UEFA can't get that done properly for over a decade, that feels like a bit of a stretch.
As noted, they should all be stripped of their titles IMO. But to say they should have known/were complicit (at least without proof) is too far IMO.
Murph7355 said:
coldel said:
Graveworm said:
vaud said:
TriumphStag3.0V8 said:
All these people saying the players are not at fault etc.... they are the ones who accepted payments mechanisms and other deals that they must have known that were questionable, as well as payments to family members, shell companies and whatever else.
In it up to their necks! Wonder how much HMRC will find to ask questions about.
While in understand your point, I suspect many players might think a shell company is one that sounds like the sea if you hold it up to your ear.In it up to their necks! Wonder how much HMRC will find to ask questions about.
Joking aside, like many high paid individuals they place a lot of trust in their financial advisors.
Many of the findings relate specifically to individual player wages and image rights. payments. Income tax evasion by the players is also a key part of the HMRC referral.
You could though literally have players saying 'I just agreed to what the accountant said and got my money, i was too busy playing football'

IF that ends up being something that happened, we should also ask why HMRC were asleep at the wheel. These are such high value contracts, and have always been in the spotlight value wise, that you would hope HMRC have been on them like they are everyone else.
What I mean is, that is what all of them will play out.
"Thats what I pay my accountants for to manage all that"
"I have a full on job with football I don't have time to check all the finances I trust they are being managed by the club"
"I am no good with money I just take what ends up in my pay check after deductions"
And so on
redrabbit29 said:
Of all those to blame, I think the players are at the very bottom fo the list. Many will be going through agents, with offers and interest from lots of clubs, all across Europe and probably further afield too.
I really doubt any of them would think about how the money goes into the club or where it's from.
Most of them likely wouldn't even understand it anyway......I really doubt any of them would think about how the money goes into the club or where it's from.
coldel said:
Murph7355 said:
coldel said:
Graveworm said:
vaud said:
TriumphStag3.0V8 said:
All these people saying the players are not at fault etc.... they are the ones who accepted payments mechanisms and other deals that they must have known that were questionable, as well as payments to family members, shell companies and whatever else.
In it up to their necks! Wonder how much HMRC will find to ask questions about.
While in understand your point, I suspect many players might think a shell company is one that sounds like the sea if you hold it up to your ear.In it up to their necks! Wonder how much HMRC will find to ask questions about.
Joking aside, like many high paid individuals they place a lot of trust in their financial advisors.
Many of the findings relate specifically to individual player wages and image rights. payments. Income tax evasion by the players is also a key part of the HMRC referral.
You could though literally have players saying 'I just agreed to what the accountant said and got my money, i was too busy playing football'

IF that ends up being something that happened, we should also ask why HMRC were asleep at the wheel. These are such high value contracts, and have always been in the spotlight value wise, that you would hope HMRC have been on them like they are everyone else.
What I mean is, that is what all of them will play out.
"Thats what I pay my accountants for to manage all that"
"I have a full on job with football I don't have time to check all the finances I trust they are being managed by the club"
"I am no good with money I just take what ends up in my pay check after deductions"
And so on
Graveworm said:
It's not that they didn't it's that they should have. It's not how their pay was funded it's how it was structured which was what the commission found. If I sign a contract with X which is the pay check and when I do it I also sign a contract with B holdings Cayman and C holdings UAE. which pay money into a separate bank account Graveworm investments in the Seychelles - then I am going to struggle to be able to say I just signed what I was givien and it will not be a defence at all to any legal liability.
But if someone was told that their £1m/month wage will be comprised of two cheques - one of £500k from Man City Ltd and another £500k "for their image rights" from Not At All Dodgy Abu Dhabi Image Rights Consultants Ltd - would they think that was illegal? If they report both income streams to the tax office would the tax office think it strange?Voldemort said:
But if someone was told that their £1m/month wage will be comprised of two cheques - one of £500k from Man City Ltd and another £500k "for their image rights" from Not At All Dodgy Abu Dhabi Image Rights Consultants Ltd - would they think that was illegal? If they report both income streams to the tax office would the tax office think it strange?
Except in the case of the three redacted players examples, in the findings, they apparently didn't report the second "Cheque" to the HMRC. The estimate for the 3 unnamed players is 12M in unpaid income tax as a result, hence the referral. It also doesn't matter if they thought it was illegal just whether it was. Voldemort said:
But if someone was told that their £1m/month wage will be comprised of two cheques - one of £500k from Man City Ltd and another £500k "for their image rights" from Not At All Dodgy Abu Dhabi Image Rights Consultants Ltd - would they think that was illegal? If they report both income streams to the tax office would the tax office think it strange?
Lots of assumptions in there, we clearly don't have the full view.Even if they had separate payments coming in, they could easily argue ignorance and say they assumed the tax was taken care of.
I don't think we will ever really know unless HMRC declares things officially and charges of tax evasion are publicly levied.
Even then I would expect 'Yes I didn't pay tax, but it was done without my knowledge, I am now going to pay the tax plus interest and move on with my career'
coldel said:
Lots of assumptions in there, we clearly don't have the full view.
Even if they had separate payments coming in, they could easily argue ignorance and say they assumed the tax was taken care of.
I don't think we will ever really know unless HMRC declares things officially and charges of tax evasion are publicly levied.
Even then I would expect 'Yes I didn't pay tax, but it was done without my knowledge, I am now going to pay the tax plus interest and move on with my career'
Ignorance of the law isn't an automatic get out clause. Even if they had separate payments coming in, they could easily argue ignorance and say they assumed the tax was taken care of.
I don't think we will ever really know unless HMRC declares things officially and charges of tax evasion are publicly levied.
Even then I would expect 'Yes I didn't pay tax, but it was done without my knowledge, I am now going to pay the tax plus interest and move on with my career'
You would imagine football accountants would be aware of image rights deals.
So one doing Haalands accounts would see his £400k a week plus some other income and i imagine likely query where his image rights are being paid or is this part of his fixed salary for example?
A number of people have made the point about the EFL having to agree to accept City is the punishment is relegation. Why don’t the EPL just expel them from the league ?
Whether the EFL take them in or not is not the EPL’s problem, it’s City’s.
If the EFL say no it is still City’s problem and would have to go looking for a new home.
Whether the EFL take them in or not is not the EPL’s problem, it’s City’s.
If the EFL say no it is still City’s problem and would have to go looking for a new home.
Graveworm said:
Many of the findings relate specifically to individual player wages and image rights. payments. Income tax evasion by the players is also a key part of the HMRC referral.
6 out of the 115 charges relate specifically to a breach of the rule requiring full details of a player's remuneration to be included in his contract with the club that is registered with the league.54 charges are about inaccurate financial information - an unknown number within those 54 relate to the "Fordham arrangements" for image rights.
I think you'd be really hard pushed to prove any of the players knew something dodgy was going on. They just sign on the dotted line and go and do what they are paid to do.
Gassing Station | Football | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff

