The Official Newcastle United Thread
The Official Newcastle United Thread
Author
Discussion

DoctorX

8,212 posts

196 months

Tuesday 12th August 2025
quotequote all
andrewpandrew said:
Sounds like Isak is saying he’ll never play for Newcastle again, even if he’s not sold in this window. What a snide he’s turned out to be.
So he’d be breaching his contract and won’t get paid. He might want to think about that if we can’t sell him.

andrewpandrew

2,859 posts

18 months

Tuesday 12th August 2025
quotequote all
Skyedriver said:
andrewpandrew said:
Sounds like Isak is saying he’ll never play for Newcastle again, even if he’s not sold in this window. What a snide he’s turned out to be.
Source?
Ornstein at the moment.

Not that it makes much difference, Howe doesn’t want him anywhere near the squad anyway.

fathomfive

11,218 posts

219 months

Tuesday 12th August 2025
quotequote all
andrewpandrew said:
Skyedriver said:
andrewpandrew said:
Sounds like Isak is saying he’ll never play for Newcastle again, even if he’s not sold in this window. What a snide he’s turned out to be.
Source?
Ornstein at the moment.

Not that it makes much difference, Howe doesn’t want him anywhere near the squad anyway.
Fun start to the week.

Be interesting to see how that would play out.

andrewpandrew

2,859 posts

18 months

Tuesday 12th August 2025
quotequote all
Probably just a last throw of the dice by his agent who is desperate for a pay day.

SWoll

22,763 posts

287 months

Tuesday 12th August 2025
quotequote all
andrewpandrew said:
Probably just a last throw of the dice by his agent who is desperate for a pay day.
More a case of a player desperate for a move.

Disappointing that this is what the situation has devolved to as not something any fan likes to see.

andrewpandrew

2,859 posts

18 months

Tuesday 12th August 2025
quotequote all
SWoll said:
More a case of a player desperate for a move.
Perhaps, but I’d bet my house that his agent is pulling the strings here.

_DJ_

5,057 posts

283 months

Tuesday 12th August 2025
quotequote all
The article also says he told Eddie Howe he wanted to leave before the window opened.

If that's the case, Newcastle have made a complete mess of this.

They refused to increase his salary last year and he's played on, feeling unappreciated.

Makes his position more understandable, if unprofessional.

He just needs to move. Newcastle need to tell him/his agent his price and ask Liverpool to pay it.

If they want him that much, surely the only option is to call their bluff and not let them wait for an end of window bargain as they are clearly planning on.

If they won't pay it, then it will put Isak in a tricky spot...



Edited by _DJ_ on Tuesday 12th August 08:46

SWoll

22,763 posts

287 months

Tuesday 12th August 2025
quotequote all
andrewpandrew said:
SWoll said:
More a case of a player desperate for a move.
Perhaps, but I’d bet my house that his agent is pulling the strings here.
He'll be getting advice I'm sure but the decision his at the end of the day.

I'd be enjoying this a lot more if it was happening to a team I didn't like.

andrewpandrew

2,859 posts

18 months

Tuesday 12th August 2025
quotequote all
_DJ_ said:
The article also says he told Eddie Howe he wanted to leave before the window opened.

If that's the case, Newcastle have made a complete mess of this and ah
I’ll imagine we’ll never really know whether that is true or not. Either way, I can’t see a club offering the asking price yet…

SWoll

22,763 posts

287 months

Tuesday 12th August 2025
quotequote all
andrewpandrew said:
_DJ_ said:
The article also says he told Eddie Howe he wanted to leave before the window opened.

If that's the case, Newcastle have made a complete mess of this and ah
I’ll imagine we’ll never really know whether that is true or not. Either way, I can’t see a club offering the asking price yet…
I think realistically £130-140m with add one is where it'll eventually end up.If it does happen?

Either way, the game at SJP on the 25th should prove a lively affair..

Adam.

29,703 posts

283 months

Tuesday 12th August 2025
quotequote all
_DJ_ said:
If they want him that much, surely the only option is to call their bluff and not let them wait for an end of window bargain as they are clearly planning on.
I am not sure 110 plus add ons taking it to around 120, an EPL record, could be considered a bargain. The 150 number has been thrown about but has that been confirmed by MUFC as the asking price?

Regardless a player is worth what another club will pay, and at the moment we are in a one horse race so will be interesting to see who blinks first.

Isak’s behaviour is not great, even if promises were broken you shouldn’t down tools, we got this with Coutinho

fathomfive

11,218 posts

219 months

Tuesday 12th August 2025
quotequote all
Adam. said:
_DJ_ said:
If they want him that much, surely the only option is to call their bluff and not let them wait for an end of window bargain as they are clearly planning on.
I am not sure 110 plus add ons taking it to around 120, an EPL record, could be considered a bargain. The 150 number has been thrown about but has that been confirmed by MUFC as the asking price?

Regardless a player is worth what another club will pay, and at the moment we are in a one horse race so will be interesting to see who blinks first.

Isak’s behaviour is not great, even if promises were broken you shouldn’t down tools, we got this with Coutinho
Indeed. I'm not bothered by players wanting to leave, it happens.

Downing tools the way he has is unwarranted and unprofessional, even if he is pissed off at broken promises.

CountyLines

5,934 posts

32 months

Tuesday 12th August 2025
quotequote all
andrewpandrew said:
SWoll said:
More a case of a player desperate for a move.
Perhaps, but I’d bet my house that his agent is pulling the strings here.
confused The player is in charge, not the agent.

Adam.

29,703 posts

283 months

Tuesday 12th August 2025
quotequote all
CountyLines said:
confused The player is in charge, not the agent.
An agent is constantly whispering in your ear, is “on your side” and most players are thick as mince.

So I think that’s simplistic

CountyLines

5,934 posts

32 months

Tuesday 12th August 2025
quotequote all
What players move against their own wishes because their agent wants them to?

andrewpandrew

2,859 posts

18 months

Tuesday 12th August 2025
quotequote all
CountyLines said:
What players move against their own wishes because their agent wants them to?
Are you being deliberately obtuse?

I'm talking about the way in which he's conducted himself. I've no doubt the agent has told him to down tools. I've no doubt the agent is the one feeding the press.

CountyLines

5,934 posts

32 months

Tuesday 12th August 2025
quotequote all
I was responding to Adams post, not yours.

andrewpandrew

2,859 posts

18 months

Tuesday 12th August 2025
quotequote all
By the way, the "promises" that were made to Isak were around money, not the ability to join another club. When Mitchell came in those promises were broken. I can understand a player feeling aggrieved that a change in management has led to that promise not materialising, but I'll reiterate, this was never about him being allowed to join another club.

SWoll

22,763 posts

287 months

Tuesday 12th August 2025
quotequote all
andrewpandrew said:
CountyLines said:
What players move against their own wishes because their agent wants them to?
Are you being deliberately obtuse?

I'm talking about the way in which he's conducted himself. I've no doubt the agent has told him to down tools. I've no doubt the agent is the one feeding the press.
I've no doubt the agent is feeding the press as that's their job.

I imagine he's smart enough to know that this is the only powerplay he has left to try and force a move with the recruitment challenges the club is facing in finding a replacement for him.

andrewpandrew

2,859 posts

18 months

Tuesday 12th August 2025
quotequote all
SWoll said:
I imagine he's smart enough to know that this is the only power play he has left to try and force a move with the recruitment challenges the club is facing in finding a replacement for him.
Indeed. I'm pretty certain we're at a point now where there isn't anyone who doesn't want him to move!