SpaceX (Vol. 2)
Author
Discussion

Talksteer

5,832 posts

264 months

Saturday 3rd October
quotequote all
Hill92 said:
On the human eating part, they need a Human Landing System Starship for Artemis. But they don't need it to be human rated for earth launch/return in the short term given Orion is being used to ferry the crews separately.
Yes the human lander will be vastly easier to certify as it as it flys 100% of descent and ascent on rocket power, the rocket and guidance can be redundant and they have a powered abort at all stages.

The forces are 1/6 of a comparable manoeuvre on earth too and there is no air.



Beati Dogu

9,381 posts

170 months

Wednesday 7th October
quotequote all
After 75 days at sea, ship 40 is now back in Texas.


hondajack85

1,861 posts

30 months

Tuesday 13th October
quotequote all
Beati Dogu said:
After 75 days at sea, ship 40 is now back in Texas.

He wants to test launch 100s of these tin cans but each one takes months to get back to base for examination.
Amazing.

fiatpower

3,662 posts

202 months

Tuesday 13th October
quotequote all
hondajack85 said:
He wants to test launch 100s of these tin cans but each one takes months to get back to base for examination.
Amazing.
It wasn’t the intention to return that ship for testing. It just survived landing so made sense to bring it back.

Beati Dogu

9,381 posts

170 months

Wednesday 14th October
quotequote all
Ship 40 being hoisted upright back at the barn:



Ship 41 may be the first one that returns under its own steam.

98elise

32,848 posts

192 months

Wednesday 14th October
quotequote all
fiatpower said:
hondajack85 said:
He wants to test launch 100s of these tin cans but each one takes months to get back to base for examination.
Amazing.
It wasn t the intention to return that ship for testing. It just survived landing so made sense to bring it back.
He seems to either have no knowledge of SpaceX plans, or is trolling. Another of his insights on this thread....

hondajack85 said:
It went up and came down and exploded and everyone onboard was killed.
But hang on,due to it being unmanned it was another roaring success.
It like news from the distopian world of 1984.
Its a shame some people can't keep trolling to NP&E, or just grow up and contribute something worthwhile to a science thread.

GTO-3R

8,007 posts

244 months

Wednesday 14th October
quotequote all
Obvious troll is obvious. I'm amazed people actually have time to waste their life doing it tbh!

hondajack85

1,861 posts

30 months

Friday 16th October
quotequote all
98elise said:
fiatpower said:
hondajack85 said:
He wants to test launch 100s of these tin cans but each one takes months to get back to base for examination.
Amazing.
It wasn t the intention to return that ship for testing. It just survived landing so made sense to bring it back.
He seems to either have no knowledge of SpaceX plans, or is trolling. Another of his insights on this thread....

hondajack85 said:
It went up and came down and exploded and everyone onboard was killed.
But hang on,due to it being unmanned it was another roaring success.
It like news from the distopian world of 1984.
Its a shame some people can't keep trolling to NP&E, or just grow up and contribute something worthwhile to a science thread.
An obvious dangerous troll on the internet like Musk doesn't deserve any respect in any of his endevours.
Its like respecting a sex offender due to the music they put out before getting exposed.


Eric Mc

125,903 posts

296 months

Friday 16th October
quotequote all
I am all for criticising Musk in the areas where he deserves criticism - and that includes certain aspects of his SpaceX operations, not just his other technical endeavours or his political activities.

However, if you are going to criticise him, pick on the areas that deserve criticism. Don't just make random and ill informed , downright stupid comments that only serve to emphasis your ignorance.

RustyMX5

9,281 posts

248 months

Friday 16th October
quotequote all
Beati Dogu said:
Ship 40 being hoisted upright back at the barn:



Ship 41 may be the first one that returns under its own steam.
Quite a few tiles missing and it almost looks as though the tiles near to where the main body joins the nose have been burned virtually flat.

RacingStripes

1,362 posts

61 months

Friday 16th October
quotequote all
Beati Dogu said:
Ship 40 being hoisted upright back at the barn:



Ship 41 may be the first one that returns under its own steam.
That'll be impressive from the bottom of the ocean.

Arnold Cunningham

4,610 posts

284 months

Friday 16th October
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
I am all for criticising Musk in the areas where he deserves criticism - and that includes certain aspects of his SpaceX operations, not just his other technical endeavours or his political activities.

However, if you are going to criticise him, pick on the areas that deserve criticism. Don't just make random and ill informed , downright stupid comments that only serve to emphasis your ignorance.
yes

Arnold Cunningham

4,610 posts

284 months

Friday 16th October
quotequote all
RustyMX5 said:
Quite a few tiles missing and it almost looks as though the tiles near to where the main body joins the nose have been burned virtually flat.
Don't underestimate the impact of weeks of wind & wave action on it.

RustyMX5

9,281 posts

248 months

Friday 16th October
quotequote all
Arnold Cunningham said:
RustyMX5 said:
Quite a few tiles missing and it almost looks as though the tiles near to where the main body joins the nose have been burned virtually flat.
Don't underestimate the impact of weeks of wind & wave action on it.
As someone who's spent most of my life around boats........ wink

I'd take a view that reentry would be significantly more violent and have a much higher energy density than surface waves and a force 6 breeze might give. Although if any tiles had come loose during reentry then it's entirely plausible that immersion in salty water followed by a trip across the Pacific could have helped a few more fall off.

Arnold Cunningham

4,610 posts

284 months

Friday 16th October
quotequote all
Yeah, but you wouldn't build your space ship our of GRP, or your boat out of ceramic thermal-protection tiles.

Or actually, based on some boats I've seen, maybe people would.....

Buzz84

1,768 posts

180 months

Friday 16th October
quotequote all
RustyMX5 said:
Quite a few tiles missing and it almost looks as though the tiles near to where the main body joins the nose have been burned virtually flat.
They sent an expedition to inspect the ship and recover a whole load of tiles while it was floating around in the ocean. This was before decided to load it onto that ship and return it home.
They have a YouTube video about them going and getting them.

Edited by Buzz84 on Friday 16th October 23:53

xeny

5,536 posts

109 months

Saturday 17th October
quotequote all
Buzz84 said:
They sent an expedition to inspect the ship and recover a whole load of tiles while it was floating around in the ocean. This was before decided to load it onto that ship and return it home.
They have a YouTube video about them going and getting them.

Edited by Buzz84 on Friday 16th October 23:53
Seems to be this segment: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EthkNLasUa8&t=...

Buzz84

1,768 posts

180 months

Saturday 17th October
quotequote all
xeny said:
Buzz84 said:
They sent an expedition to inspect the ship and recover a whole load of tiles while it was floating around in the ocean. This was before decided to load it onto that ship and return it home.
They have a YouTube video about them going and getting them.

Edited by Buzz84 on Friday 16th October 23:53
Seems to be this segment: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EthkNLasUa8&t=...
Yes that it, they are in there with drills removing loads of tiles.

The whole thing is pretty good actually, it shows how they are made.

jeremyc

28,376 posts

315 months

PH TEAM

Saturday 17th October
quotequote all
Discussions about Elon Musk and his other businesses in this thread please, not off-topic posts here.

Peterpetrole

1,879 posts

28 months

Tuesday 20th October
quotequote all
I'm seriously considering flying out for the next launch in a few weeks. Probably heading to Brownsville rather than Boca Chica as seems like a bit less driving.