The Official 2017 Brazilian Prix Thread **Spoilers**

The Official 2017 Brazilian Prix Thread **Spoilers**

Author
Discussion

HarryFlatters

4,203 posts

212 months

Tuesday 14th November 2017
quotequote all
Vaud said:
I agree. My money would be on Ocon.
Bottas back to Williams to replace Massa, Ocon into the Mercedes, Kubica or DiResta back at Force India?

It is silly season after all hehe

anonymous-user

54 months

Tuesday 14th November 2017
quotequote all
Vaud said:
I agree. My money would be on Ocon.
You know Ocon would have a go that's for sure.

Perez tried to show him who was boss and look how that turned out.

Nice problem to have for Mercedes.

I still think Wehrlein "who is a Mercedes driver" should be given the chance of a better car.

Bottas to Williams

Ocon to Mercedes

Wehrlein to Force India or whatever they are going to be called.

swisstoni

16,957 posts

279 months

Tuesday 14th November 2017
quotequote all
Merc may get a taste for the No.2 Driver idea.
I hope they don’t btw.

It is, after all, what Ferrari have done for years.
Lots of reasons why it’s the best way to go racing as a team (if not the best type of racing to watch especially if you don’t like seeing people have to pull over for their teammate).

If Rosberg was still around it’s quite likely that Vettel would now have 5 WDC as the Mercs would have split more points and probably have knocked chunks out of each other as well.

Bristol spark

4,382 posts

183 months

Tuesday 14th November 2017
quotequote all
I guess it depends if Merc prefer the more relaxed environment of this year?

However if Ferrari and especially Red Bull with two great drivers are on form next year, they may wish they had a better second driver.


LaurasOtherHalf

21,429 posts

196 months

Tuesday 14th November 2017
quotequote all
It's a peculiar and interesting problem for Mercedes to have, if I was in charge I've got to be honest and say I'd employ a number 2 while Ferrari have VET as their number 1.

Red Bull seem to have nailed their support on for VER so there is the real possibility of three teams next year going for it with two of them putting their weight behind one driver.

Where does that leave RIC? In all honesty I don't know, it looks like he has zero competition from any Toro Rosso driver but he's not exactly number 2 material is he? Would he be taken on by Mercedes as he seems to want?

In that case Mercedes would seem to have BOT, RIC, OCO and WEH all looking to grab their seat alongside HAM. They must have some idea that if they didn't have a number 2 this year they wouldn't have secured the WDC or at least might not have.

The key to everything is HAM's decision on when to leave in my opinion. If he's in it for the long hall a younger teammate/stick with BOT makes sense, if he's making noises about only one or two more seasons they should pounce on RIC and build around him.

Redlake27

2,255 posts

244 months

Tuesday 14th November 2017
quotequote all


Kimi has been circulating in 4th place for a decade too.

Flying Finn feels like a phrase from far ago.

HustleRussell

24,639 posts

160 months

swisstoni

16,957 posts

279 months

Tuesday 14th November 2017
quotequote all
Hamilton has never vetoed a strong teammate and I don’t think he’d be adverse to having Ricciardo in the other car. But it would be a tough season and probably hand WDC to Vettel.

(I don’t think we have seen a clean Head to Head with Verstappen and Ricciardo - reliability aside, I think Ricciardo is the better driver on Sundays).

Dr Z

3,396 posts

171 months

Tuesday 14th November 2017
quotequote all
NRS said:
Did they not give Hamilton another engine mode for using to try and overtake Kimi? So they can't have been at 100% everything before then, even if it was turned up somewhat.
Yes, but keep in mind that the whole thing evolves throughout the race and sometimes for one lap he'd get more of the ERS assist on to the DRS zones to attack and the next lap will have to harvest more. For the Kimi attack he was told to go to position 2 on the HPP rotary, which to my understanding relates to fuel mix for that little something extra through the whole lap.

Something like +8 km/h to even his team mate (both in clear air) is just silly.

Plus, pitlane start means his car setup could be completely race-biased rather than in the middle of race & quali for every other car, not to mention the more favourable reverse tyre strategy. Suspect he took a lot out of his tyres catching up to Kimi, and not quick enough in S2 to be close in the corners prior to the long run to T1. The Ferrari seemed to be quicker through Ferradura (6), Pinheirinho (9) & Mergulho (12). Concentrate on a good exit out of Juncao and bob's your uncle.

Would have been interesting if he had got past Kimi. Would Merc have asked Bottas to move over?

Derek Smith

45,613 posts

248 months

Tuesday 14th November 2017
quotequote all
Dr Z said:
Plus, pitlane start means his car setup could be completely race-biased rather than in the middle of race & quali for every other car, not to mention the more favourable reverse tyre strategy. Suspect he took a lot out of his tyres catching up to Kimi, and not quick enough in S2 to be close in the corners prior to the long run to T1. The Ferrari seemed to be quicker through Ferradura (6), Pinheirinho (9) & Mergulho (12). Concentrate on a good exit out of Juncao and bob's your uncle.

Would have been interesting if he had got past Kimi. Would Merc have asked Bottas to move over?
I forgot the benefit of the pitlane start.

I think if LH had got past Kimi with, say, 10 laps to go then passing Bottas to attack Vettel would have made sense in the battle for second in the WDC. The points difference would have been reduced and there was always the chance of a bit of a battle, which would slow Vettel and make him vulnerable to Bottas. If he'd got past then would Hamilton have let his team mate through? He's done it before.

My assumption is that all options would have been discussed pre race.

Dodgey_Rog

1,986 posts

260 months

Tuesday 14th November 2017
quotequote all
At the end of each Grand Prix now, I'm waiting to see what utter dross Villeneuve spouts out. I never liked him as a driver, he seems to have an opinion about everything and just seems bit of a gobste.

glazbagun

14,276 posts

197 months

Tuesday 14th November 2017
quotequote all
Agreed. Though I was surprised to find Hill, in his book, felt JV the more enjoyable team mate than Coulthard who was the young up and comer then.

jbudgie

8,907 posts

212 months

Tuesday 14th November 2017
quotequote all
Bottas doesn't seem to be a fighter, you just knew that Vettel would have him.

Derek Smith

45,613 posts

248 months

Tuesday 14th November 2017
quotequote all
glazbagun said:
Agreed. Though I was surprised to find Hill, in his book, felt JV the more enjoyable team mate than Coulthard who was the young up and comer then.
It's easy enough to fall out with a colleague, especially one who is in competition with you. Hill had the measure of Villeneuve. Coulthard, though, didn't know when he was beaten.

Johnny Herbert didn't get on with Schumacher and Fastish Eddie did. Senna, evidently, got on well with Berger and not with that French bloke. I've seen Berger close up and he didn't impress me with his attitude. Prost though seems to be a pleasant chap on all the videos I've seen.

It seems that if you can outperform your team mate, you like them. You never can tell though.


Vaud

50,425 posts

155 months

Tuesday 14th November 2017
quotequote all
Dodgey_Rog said:
At the end of each Grand Prix now, I'm waiting to see what utter dross Villeneuve spouts out. I never liked him as a driver, he seems to have an opinion about everything and just seems bit of a gobste.
"rent a mouth"

HustleRussell

24,639 posts

160 months

Thursday 16th November 2017
quotequote all
Dr.Z, just as expected

Hard to imagine Mercedes being right on it from the start of 2018 with such a huge fundamental change in philosophy, then again they proved me wrong this season...

sparta6

3,694 posts

100 months

Thursday 16th November 2017
quotequote all
Vaud said:
Dodgey_Rog said:
At the end of each Grand Prix now, I'm waiting to see what utter dross Villeneuve spouts out. I never liked him as a driver, he seems to have an opinion about everything and just seems bit of a gobste.
"rent a mouth"
Surprised JV is not on Pistonheads too biggrin

Vaud

50,425 posts

155 months

Thursday 16th November 2017
quotequote all
sparta6 said:
Surprised JV is not on Pistonheads too biggrin
I wish he was.

Dr Z

3,396 posts

171 months

Thursday 16th November 2017
quotequote all
HustleRussell said:
Dr.Z, just as expected

Hard to imagine Mercedes being right on it from the start of 2018 with such a huge fundamental change in philosophy, then again they proved me wrong this season...
Agree, this is a very interesting development for 2018. The pre-season test is going to be telling.

I expect they'll lose a lot of performance at the start compared to where they are now as the baseline is established to develop the aero package, then claw it back as the season develops, while RBR & Ferrari fight in the early part of the season. Max or Dan's 1st WDC? Would be good!

Hope Merc don't nail it straight away, and more importantly, hope throwing lots of money at it won't be the answer. smile

HustleRussell

24,639 posts

160 months

Thursday 16th November 2017
quotequote all
Dr Z said:
HustleRussell said:
Dr.Z, just as expected

Hard to imagine Mercedes being right on it from the start of 2018 with such a huge fundamental change in philosophy, then again they proved me wrong this season...
Agree, this is a very interesting development for 2018. The pre-season test is going to be telling.

I expect they'll lose a lot of performance at the start compared to where they are now as the baseline is established to develop the aero package, then claw it back as the season develops, while RBR & Ferrari fight in the early part of the season. Max or Dan's 1st WDC? Would be good!

Hope Merc don't nail it straight away, and more importantly, hope throwing lots of money at it won't be the answer. smile
It is speculated elsewhere that Mercedes tried a high rake setup in Brazil, and Niki Lauda has said that the move to high rake doesn't necessitate a much shorter wheelbase which is interesting- I imagined that it would require significant change to the tub, suspension, basically all of the aero etc etc. Perhaps it's not that big a deal after all?