Are Red bull cheating?
Are Red bull cheating?
Author
Discussion

PhilAsia

7,895 posts

106 months

Friday 18th October 2024
quotequote all
honda_exige said:
Jonnny said:
honda_exige said:
Yes this isn't obvious at all. rolleyes The FIA have all the footage from the CCTV this year from the cameras directly over the car. It's fairly trivial to go back and review.

If this is the adjustment, why is everyone talking about the pedal box/cockpit?
Because it goes through the cockpit then through the bottom of the foot space via an access panel under the heal.
It would not take much to shorten that by twelve-ish inches and operate it with a driver's foot rather than a mechanic's hand...if it assisted in making the car faster, and if they were of a mind to.

"Oh, I found this in the footwell..."

honda_exige

8,413 posts

237 months

Friday 18th October 2024
quotequote all
PhilAsia said:
honda_exige said:
Jonnny said:
honda_exige said:
Yes this isn't obvious at all. rolleyes The FIA have all the footage from the CCTV this year from the cameras directly over the car. It's fairly trivial to go back and review.

If this is the adjustment, why is everyone talking about the pedal box/cockpit?
Because it goes through the cockpit then through the bottom of the foot space via an access panel under the heal.
It would not take much to shorten that by twelve-ish inches and operate it with a driver's foot rather than a mechanic's hand...if it assisted in making the car faster, and if they were of a mind to.

"Oh, I found this in the footwell..."
Are you seriously suggesting that RedBull installed that thing in his right hand, one of these.....



.... into the footwell of their car, secured it and made it operable by the driver's foot? I mean that's a similar level of inventiveness to Trump suggesting you can inject bleach to cure Covid nuts

732NM

13,837 posts

46 months

Friday 18th October 2024
quotequote all
honda_exige said:
Yes this isn't obvious at all. rolleyes The FIA have all the footage from the CCTV this year from the cameras directly over the car. It's fairly trivial to go back and review.

CCTV isn't switched on until the car is bagged for curfew.

The pedals are routinely worked on during the parc ferme period.

That's why engineering it to be accessible whilst working in the footbox area is so dodgy and why the FIA are now applying a seal.

732NM

13,837 posts

46 months

Friday 18th October 2024
quotequote all
honda_exige said:
Are you seriously suggesting that RedBull installed that thing in his right hand, one of these.....



.... into the footwell of their car, secured it and made it operable by the driver's foot? I mean that's a similar level of inventiveness to Trump suggesting you can inject bleach to cure Covid nuts
You can't be this thick?

It's not a driver adjustable device.

It's a device operated by the mechanic which can easily be carried out during parc ferme.

HocusPocus

2,107 posts

132 months

Friday 18th October 2024
quotequote all
RBR missed a trick. Should have used a DAS style push pull system to adjust ride height. Push for increased downforce approaching corner, pull to release air pressure for fast corner exit.

My CV in the post to Horner. smile

confucuis

1,335 posts

155 months

Friday 18th October 2024
quotequote all
honda_exige said:
Jonnny said:
honda_exige said:
Yes this isn't obvious at all. rolleyesThe FIA have all the footage from the CCTV this year from the cameras directly over the car. It's fairly trivial to go back and review.

If this is the adjustment, why is everyone talking about the pedal box/cockpit?
Because it goes through the cockpit then through the bottom of the foot space via an access panel under the heal.
If the argument is that it's so obvious when being adjusted that it would be impossible to avoid being seen by CCTV when adjustment is necessary then it also stands to reason that there should be plenty of TV evidence throughout the year of them legally adjusting while in the garages...

super7

2,275 posts

239 months

Friday 18th October 2024
quotequote all
Thats the bit they want you to see…….

zsdom

1,847 posts

151 months

Friday 18th October 2024
quotequote all
confucuis said:
honda_exige said:
Jonnny said:
honda_exige said:
Yes this isn't obvious at all. rolleyesThe FIA have all the footage from the CCTV this year from the cameras directly over the car. It's fairly trivial to go back and review.

If this is the adjustment, why is everyone talking about the pedal box/cockpit?
Because it goes through the cockpit then through the bottom of the foot space via an access panel under the heal.
If the argument is that it's so obvious when being adjusted that it would be impossible to avoid being seen by CCTV when adjustment is necessary then it also stands to reason that there should be plenty of TV evidence throughout the year of them legally adjusting while in the garages...
Isnt the argument that it isnt that obvious they’re adjusting it specifically. Eg RB say they’re working on the pedal box when actually they’re adjusting the ride height, there was no way for the FIA to see what they are doing that deep down in the car

Hence the seal

jules_s

5,291 posts

264 months

Friday 18th October 2024
quotequote all
MB: You don't adjust an F1 car with a 2' extension bar hehe

super7

2,275 posts

239 months

Friday 18th October 2024
quotequote all
Is this why Newey has left….. even MB doesn’t believe the story…. Double extension wrench smile

732NM

13,837 posts

46 months

Friday 18th October 2024
quotequote all
I could fake adjusting the pedals whilst actually altering roll bar, spring and suspension links on some of the older generation F1 cars, and no one would notice, even if being filmed.

They were doing the old song and dance long extension bar through the cockpit look at this game, when you'd just use a stubby rachet that fits in the palm of your hand.

Speedywurzel

478 posts

252 months

Friday 18th October 2024
quotequote all
I’ve not read the topic all the way through so apologies if it’s been discussed, but who would have designed this at red bull,Newey? Would he of known about it as well?

BrettMRC

6,158 posts

191 months

Friday 18th October 2024
quotequote all
Olympic level squirming going on hehe


Edit: it's all McLarens fault!

732NM

13,837 posts

46 months

Friday 18th October 2024
quotequote all
Speedywurzel said:
I’ve not read the topic all the way through so apologies if it’s been discussed, but who would have designed this at red bull,Newey? Would he of known about it as well?
He knew everything.

snotrag

15,746 posts

242 months

Friday 18th October 2024
quotequote all
Solid effort by Martin there - go on then, lets see it...!

PhilAsia

7,895 posts

106 months

Friday 18th October 2024
quotequote all
honda_exige said:
PhilAsia said:
honda_exige said:
Jonnny said:
honda_exige said:
Yes this isn't obvious at all. rolleyes The FIA have all the footage from the CCTV this year from the cameras directly over the car. It's fairly trivial to go back and review.

If this is the adjustment, why is everyone talking about the pedal box/cockpit?
Because it goes through the cockpit then through the bottom of the foot space via an access panel under the heal.
It would not take much to shorten that by twelve-ish inches and operate it with a driver's foot rather than a mechanic's hand...if it assisted in making the car faster, and if they were of a mind to.

"Oh, I found this in the footwell..."
Are you seriously suggesting that RedBull installed that thing in his right hand, one of these.....



.... into the footwell of their car, secured it and made it operable by the driver's foot? I mean that's a similar level of inventiveness to Trump suggesting you can inject bleach to cure Covid nuts
No, it isn't what I was suggesting. What I was suggesting is something much smaller, that could be somehow secreted into place by a mechanic (without the scrutineer suspecting) and used to adjust after qualifying whilst working on the the car.

asfault

13,798 posts

210 months

Friday 18th October 2024
quotequote all
there has to be some other easier way during the race or pitstop to change this...

732NM

13,837 posts

46 months

Friday 18th October 2024
quotequote all
snotrag said:
Solid effort by Martin there - go on then, lets see it...!
Your camera won't fit biggrin

732NM

13,837 posts

46 months

Friday 18th October 2024
quotequote all
PhilAsia said:
No, it isn't what I was suggesting. What I was suggesting is something much smaller, that could be somehow secreted into place by a mechanic (without the scrutineer suspecting) and used to adjust after qualifying whilst working on the the car.
It's not against the rules to work on the car. Zero need to hide tools.

zsdom

1,847 posts

151 months

Friday 18th October 2024
quotequote all
Horners just so unlikeable isnt he